Gameday Thread? | Page 25 | Syracusefan.com

Gameday Thread?

Eric15 said:
I don't understand why we just punted -- there simply isn't enough time. That's the type of Shafer decision (and Marrone) that is maddening to me.

Very low chance of getting a first there. A few yards? Sure go for it. Id take my chances on Dixon pinning then back and us getting a turnover or quick possession. 6 mins isn't 2 or 3.
 
You'll be told it doesn't matter. It does, but you'll be told that.

Even if we don't convert, we can try and hold them to a field goal and it's still a two possession game.
 
I don't understand why we just punted -- there simply isn't enough time. That's the type of Shafer decision (and Marrone) that is maddening to me.
Couldn't punt there. You can't risk needing a 3 and out against one of the best offenses in football...when you have nothing to lose. Not Shafers fault Mahoney is incapable of hitting a wide open deep man but he's gotta have a better feel for the game and he. just. doesn't.
 
I appreciate the effort so much, but the end of the days shows us losing again, by at least 2 possessions and never really with a chance to tie the game. I don't recall being down 7 with the ball.

This doesn't change anything, unfortunately.
 
FortyFourCT said:
I appreciate the effort so much, but the end of the days shows us losing again, by at least 2 possessions and never really with a chance to tie the game. I don't recall being down 7 with the ball.

This doesn't change anything, unfortunately.

Great positive post...Thanks...
 
Eric15 said:
Even if we don't convert, we can try and hold them to a field goal and it's still a two possession game.

I'm sitting in back of a retired college coach. He said 6+ mins you can't go for that distance on 4th in our territory. You'll be told that it was stupid not to go for it though.
 
Very low chance of getting a first there. A few yards? Sure go for it. Id take my chances on Dixon pinning then back and us getting a turnover or quick possession. 6 mins isn't 2 or 3.
Cmon man. You knew it would play out like this. I know you knew this. We all did.
 
Very low chance of getting a first there. A few yards? Sure go for it. Id take my chances on Dixon pinning then back and us getting a turnover or quick possession. 6 mins isn't 2 or 3.

Do you still feel that way after Clemson running all this time off the clock? Wouldn't you rather have one opportunity to try and convert 4th and 8?
 
Eric15 said:
Do you still feel that way after Clemson running all this time off the clock? Wouldn't you rather have one opportunity to try and convert 4th and 8?

Yes
 
Eric15 said:
Even if we don't convert, we can try and hold them to a field goal and it's still a two possession game.

You mean control the controllables? Nahhhhhh.

Either way it's a longshot. Personally I prefer long shots with the ball in our hands, but I'm not a coach, so what so I know?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
167,694
Messages
4,721,245
Members
5,915
Latest member
vegasnick

Online statistics

Members online
190
Guests online
2,138
Total visitors
2,328


Top Bottom