RF2044
Living Legend
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2011
- Messages
- 30,906
- Like
- 100,206
I think we actually see this fairly similarly, RF. I guess the quote I was responding to in your previous post as more the one that said we don't have any players on offense and the OL sucks. My thought was that you were defending the system based on skill position personnel and poor line play. I agree you need line play to be successful. All I was trying to point out was that an offense shouldn't have to "out-talent" an opponent to move the ball. The second point was that if OL play sucks, that's still something that comes back on Marrone and Adkins to some extent. I think we actually agree on most, if not all of that.
Where we may differ is that, to me, you have to start running your offense and calling the plays you want to call at some point or you'll never start doing it. Marrone talks about this New Orleans Saints offense but if he has to have the perfect personnel to deploy it, we could be waiting a long, long time. I'm just not sure I buy the line that the offense as currently constituted will look drastically different in 2013 simply because of some turnover in personnel.
Started writing a more detailed response, but my computer froze.
Bills, there is very little in your post that I disagree with--I think we are pretty much on the same page.
The one thing I want to be clear about is that I am NOT defending the system--in large part because I don't think what we're seeing IS the system [at least, I hope not]. That's why I view some of the criticism about the product we're seeing now on offense is misguided. CIL's post on page one [or whatever] makes perfect sense to me--the coaches recognize the importance of winning in the short term, and they're doing what they think is the best approach to winning games now with the hand they have at their disposal.
I agree that it makes sense to start running the offense, if for no other reason than to establish the footprint / baseline, and to get personnel acclimated to it. And we need to get better talent in the pipeline at every positional unit, so that in two years we've got SIX competent WRs instead of 3, and so that our OL rotation isn't comprised of 6 marginal players, but rather 10 upgraded ones. Etc. And improved QB recruiting is a big part of that transformation, as well. Right now, I don't have a clue whether Kinder, Hunt, Broyld are going to solve what's been an ongoing problem since McNabb's graduation.