Marrone's Injury "Reports" | Syracusefan.com

Marrone's Injury "Reports"

realcusefan888

Walk On
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
145
Like
13
While I am HUGE supporter of coach M...This latest injury report gives you nothing. Larger programs than us give the fans and media something to go on. Withholding injury info does no make a player heal quicker! Upper body and lower body injury? Really? For Chandler is that an ingrown toe nail or did his leg fall off??? Did Fisher bite his tongue or does he have 6 broken ribs??? We and the media deserve more. No idea whether this is one game or several for Chandler.
Anyone have info?

GO CUSE?
 

Dnyr85

Starter
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
1,246
Like
987
Why do we deserve to know more? It's a tactical game that coaches play between each other. It doesn't have anything to do with us.

I agree. Yes, it is frustrating not knowing what and how long the injury is gonna be.
I am in the group that all we need to know is so and so is hurt, so and so will be filling in and that the team will move forward. Honestly, when I do get the info on an injury it usually gets me angry, lol, so the less I know the better.
 

OrangeXtreme

The Mayor of Dewitt
Joined
Aug 15, 2011
Messages
170,192
Like
261,605
I'm guessing that Marrone is providing only the minimum info that the BE requires.
 

Chip

Creature of Bad Habits
Joined
Aug 14, 2011
Messages
24,966
Like
60,427
Marrone needs to do what he needs to do in these situations. No sense complaining about it if he's following the rules and acting in the best interest of the team.

But I will say, given the lack of information that the fans and media get, we shouldn't complain about all the expansion topics. Gotta talk about something. We've talked the game to death, no one cares about what URI brings to the table, and there is no news from the team...
 

Cuse4Life

Walk On
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
137
Like
140
Why does the Media feel like the 4th side of the government and that they know is a must. Why cant he do what he wants and its no persons business about peoples injury...whatever happened to doctor client confidentiality?
 

Cuseregular

Hall of Fame
Joined
Aug 21, 2011
Messages
7,856
Like
19,278
While I am HUGE supporter of coach M...This latest injury report gives you nothing. Larger programs than us give the fans and media something to go on. Withholding injury info does no make a player heal quicker! Upper body and lower body injury? Really? For Chandler is that an ingrown toe nail or did his leg fall off??? Did Fisher bite his tongue or does he have 6 broken ribs??? We and the media deserve more. No idea whether this is one game or several for Chandler.
Anyone have info?

GO CUSE?

Heres what's likely happening. Given the fact that Jones played the whole game and seemed slowed a bit and the scuttlebutt is that its a knee issue he's likely dealing with a nagging meniscal cartilage issue would be my guess. You can play through it albeit at reduced efficiency and put off invasive surgery til seasons end, kind of like Terrence Roberts did a few years back with hoops. The fact that it's RI this weekend my guess is that they're likely deciding to give Jones rest saving him for later in the season knowing they can take care of RI without him.

The way Oliver looked post game says the same to me on that last point and that his upper body injury in minor. Anderson on the other hand, everything about the way that went down suggests to me that he'll be laid up for a while. Let's hope I'm right on the first two guys and wrong on the last one.
 

GoCuse14

All Conference
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
2,175
Like
3,617
didnt someone rumor that it was an LCL issue?
 

BleedsOrange44

Starter
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
1,455
Like
361
I'm always amazed at the fans that think the coaches or players "owe us an explanation." Fact is they don't. Marrone thinks it's important to protect player's privacy relating to health issues as much as possible, so he gives the minimum. Yes I'd like to know, but I don't hold Marrone responsible or think it's really an issue. We'll find out eventually.

And I don't care what other "larger" programs do. They also cheat, pay players, etc. Should we do that to because that's what "larger" programs do? Come on now.
 

Cuseregular

Hall of Fame
Joined
Aug 21, 2011
Messages
7,856
Like
19,278
didnt someone rumor that it was an LCL issue?
Heard that. If it is it will be the first LCL injury of significance I've heard of in my 20+ year health care career.
 

realcusefan888

Walk On
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
145
Like
13
Why do we deserve to know more? It's a tactical game that coaches play between each other. It doesn't have anything to do with us.

Player's privacy??? coaching tactics? give me a break guys...These are athletes with football related injuries! Nobody has Herpes here! and as far as coaching tactics...really? against RI? Are you telling me we are playing coy with injuries to throw RI off? Will they start another left tackle in response?
 

DownTheField

2nd String
Joined
Aug 23, 2011
Messages
809
Like
1,403
Player's privacy??? coaching tactics? give me a break guys...These are athletes with football related injuries! Nobody has Herpes here! and as far as coaching tactics...really? against RI? Are you telling me we are playing coy with injuries to throw RI off? Will they start another left tackle in response?
Why do you deserve to know anything? Are you going to skip the game if you can't watch Chandler play?
 

GoCuse14

All Conference
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
2,175
Like
3,617
Player's privacy??? coaching tactics? give me a break guys...These are athletes with football related injuries! Nobody has Herpes here! and as far as coaching tactics...really? against RI? Are you telling me we are playing coy with injuries to throw RI off? Will they start another left tackle in response?

Oh so RI is the last game of the year? Lordy
 

BleedsOrange44

Starter
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
1,455
Like
361
Player's privacy??? coaching tactics? give me a break guys...These are athletes with football related injuries! Nobody has Herpes here! and as far as coaching tactics...really? against RI? Are you telling me we are playing coy with injuries to throw RI off? Will they start another left tackle in response?
Yes player's privacy. Just because larger programs don't respect their player's privacy doesn't mean it's not OK for Marrone to. It's Marrone's decision, and part of his program. Nothing wrong with it. We, as fans, are owed nothing more than their best effort on the field. Period.
 

StealthTurkey

Walk On
Joined
Sep 6, 2011
Messages
111
Like
104
I'm guessing that Marrone is providing only the minimum info that the BE requires.

You are correct. Since the changes in requirements last year, you no longer actually even have to report injuries. See: Pitt last year. They didn't report a single injury. You are now allowed to be as vague as you want to be.
 

Scooch

Living Legend
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
13,092
Like
34,556
My man, Bill Belichick, listed Tom Brady as "probable (shoulder)" for every game like 6 years in a row... and I thought it was the most fantastic thing ever.

Marrone owes you nothing.
 

orangemass

All American
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
4,256
Like
5,834
Need to check out the twits to get the real updates... Chandler sending out any updates?
 

CaliCuse

All American
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
7,208
Like
2,180
While I am HUGE supporter of coach M...This latest injury report gives you nothing. Larger programs than us give the fans and media something to go on. Withholding injury info does no make a player heal quicker! Upper body and lower body injury? Really? For Chandler is that an ingrown toe nail or did his leg fall off??? Did Fisher bite his tongue or does he have 6 broken ribs??? We and the media deserve more. No idea whether this is one game or several for Chandler.
Anyone have info?

GO CUSE?
There are legal privacy issues he needs to be care ful of . Medical condition it seems is an important aspect of that regulation. Its not being withheld to piss you or me off believe me , its not. I don't know if this is a federal or ncaa thing. I know in my old industry od banking it was federal as well as the medical community.:eek:
 

JoeSU

All American
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
4,139
Like
4,618
While I am HUGE supporter of coach M...This latest injury report gives you nothing. Larger programs than us give the fans and media something to go on. Withholding injury info does no make a player heal quicker! Upper body and lower body injury? Really? For Chandler is that an ingrown toe nail or did his leg fall off??? Did Fisher bite his tongue or does he have 6 broken ribs??? We and the media deserve more. No idea whether this is one game or several for Chandler.
Anyone have info?

GO CUSE?
My understanding that HIPAA regulations prevent an employer or school disclosing personal medical information. This applies to students-at-large as well as student athletes. IMO this is as it should be. It's nobodies business.
 

BleedsOrange44

Starter
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
1,455
Like
361
My man, Bill Belichick, listed Tom Brady as "probable (shoulder)" for every game like 6 years in a row... and I thought it was the most fantastic thing ever.

Marrone owes you nothing.
Couldn't agree more
 

CaliCuse

All American
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
7,208
Like
2,180
My understanding that HIPAA regulations prevent an employer or school disclosing personal medical information. This applies to students-at-large as well as student athletes. IMO this is as it should be. It's nobodies business.
If you are a betting person knowing the health of key players is important but other then that I agree not your effn business. If he plays fine. If not put in the depth chart players and pat them on the back while wishing them the best. I love the backup players when given their chance to shine or flop. Either way it answers questions ,I would think. It can verify the coaching choice or make a mockery of same.:rolling:
 

Ragman2000

Pee-Trough Advocate
Joined
Aug 17, 2011
Messages
1,941
Like
6,562
Nobody has Herpes here!

How in the hell do you know if my herpes has been cured? While your at it, can you give me a hemorrhoid update too? I have a hard time seeing my own a$$. Mostly because my wife looks at me funny when I try to look at it in the mirror.

RealCusefan needs to give a weekly syracusefan.com injury report. My colon will be listed as "Questionable" this week, while my ED shall be listed as "probable."
 

Reyes39

Scout Team
Joined
Sep 3, 2011
Messages
436
Like
553
Don't think we deserve to know much of anything about injuries...but I'd sure like to know how long the player will be out. Without that info I'll probably end up keeping an eye on the tunnel all game waiting for Chandler to make a heroic return (w/ smoke machine) to lead the Orange to victory.
 

Similar threads

    • Like
Orangeyes Daily Articles for Thursday for Football
Replies
4
Views
484
    • Like
Orangeyes Daily Articles for Tuesday for Football
Replies
6
Views
535

Forum statistics

Threads
157,249
Messages
4,165,106
Members
5,507
Latest member
Lpoolnation

Online statistics

Members online
194
Guests online
711
Total visitors
905




Top Bottom