OrangeXtreme
The Mayor of Dewitt
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2011
- Messages
- 226,822
- Like
- 406,170
I took SDSU in survivor. Don’t think Furman can hang with their athletes.Do I roll with Furman or SDSU?! Offensive vs defensive .
I just realized that all of the 5 seeds won in the first round. Of all the years to have that happen with all the parity this season. Guess FDU, Princeton and Mercer made up for it
Wait what? How would you fill out a bracket when you don’t know what the second rounds areIf you went back to playing in the actual regions like they used to, you could reseed each round. So there wouldn't be any travel issues. You can have 1/16, 4/13, 5/12, 8/9 all in one site and 2/15, 3/14, 6/11, 7/10 all in another. IMO that would be a better way to determine a champ. I hate that FAU could make a S16 by beating an 8 and a 16 seed. Or that San Diego State can by beating a 12 and a 13 seed. Or that Missouri can by beating a 10 and a 15 seed. That is more luck of the draw.
So we would have...
East
Tennessee vs FDU
Duke vs FAU
Marquette vs Michigan State (same)
Kansas State vs Kentucky (same)
South
Alabama vs Furman
San Diego State vs Maryland
Baylor vs Princeton
Creighton vs Missouri
Midwest
Houston vs Auburn (same)
Indiana vs Miami (same)
Texas vs Pitt
Xavier vs Penn State
West
Kansas vs Arkansas (same)
UConn vs Saint Mary's (same)
UCLA vs Northwestern (same)
Gonzaga vs TCU (same)
For the S16 you stay in your region but those teams are reseeded. Same for the F4 getting reseeded.
The great thing is you can still for the most part keep the brackets. Since most people fill it out digitally it is pretty easy to have the matchups auto fill.
Let's say you picked Purdue, Memphis, Tennessee, Oral Roberts, Providence, Kansas State, USC, Marquette in your bracket. Then the next round in your bracket it would be Purdue vs Oral Roberts, Tennessee vs Memphis, Marquette vs Providence, Kansas State vs USC. Next you have Purdue vs Providence and Kansas State vs Tennessee. And finally Purdue vs Tennessee, with Tennessee in the F4. So you would be 3-5 in that 1st round, still have two S16 teams left, one E8, and one F4.
Wait what? How would you fill out a bracket when you don’t know what the second rounds are
Agreed, I’d rather live in anarchy then see a reseeded bracket.You couldn't. It would be the end of civilization as we know it.
Wait what? How would you fill out a bracket when you don’t know what the second rounds are
Furman playing a shi**y 2 3 zone. Still doesn’t workDo I roll with Furman or SDSU?! Offensive vs defensive .
Even the idiots that run the NCAA aren’t screwing up the March Madness brackets.1. It isn't a complete reseed. Just the sub region in round 2. You are locked into your sub region. Just within the region for round 3. You are locked into your region.
2. How many people fill their bracket with pen and paper? Even if you do it isn't hard to rank the four 1st round winners by seed to figure out your 2nd round matchups. When you do it online it auto fills for you already. Wouldn't change a thing in that case.
So now if you picked Purdue, Tennessee, Memphis, Oral Roberts in Round 1 you would have Purdue vs Memphis and Tennessee vs Oral Roberts. With reseeding, instead you would have Purdue vs Oral Roberts and Tennessee vs Memphis. In both cases you did not know the 2nd round matchups, you are guessing. And in both cases you guessed wrong.
Do I roll with Furman or SDSU?! Offensive vs defensive .
Ah, I see what you’re saying. Granted that takes any semblance of skill (even though its impact is very limited) as you can’t look at matchups anymore because it could change based on who wins in the first round.1. It isn't a complete reseed. Just the sub region in round 2. You are locked into your sub region. Just within the region for round 3. You are locked into your region.
2. How many people fill their bracket with pen and paper? Even if you do it isn't hard to rank the four 1st round winners by seed to figure out your 2nd round matchups. When you do it online it auto fills for you already. Wouldn't change a thing in that case.
So now if you picked Purdue, Tennessee, Memphis, Oral Roberts in Round 1 you would have Purdue vs Memphis and Tennessee vs Oral Roberts. With reseeding, instead you would have Purdue vs Oral Roberts and Tennessee vs Memphis. In both cases you did not know the 2nd round matchups, you are guessing. And in both cases you guessed wrong.
If you went back to playing in the actual regions like they used to, you could reseed each round. So there wouldn't be any travel issues. You can have 1/16, 4/13, 5/12, 8/9 all in one site and 2/15, 3/14, 6/11, 7/10 all in another. IMO that would be a better way to determine a champ. I hate that FAU could make a S16 by beating an 8 and a 16 seed. Or that San Diego State can by beating a 12 and a 13 seed. Or that Missouri can by beating a 10 and a 15 seed. That is more luck of the draw.
So we would have...
East
Tennessee vs FDU
Duke vs FAU
Marquette vs Michigan State (same)
Kansas State vs Kentucky (same)
South
Alabama vs Furman
San Diego State vs Maryland
Baylor vs Princeton
Creighton vs Missouri
Midwest
Houston vs Auburn (same)
Indiana vs Miami (same)
Texas vs Pitt
Xavier vs Penn State
West
Kansas vs Arkansas (same)
UConn vs Saint Mary's (same)
UCLA vs Northwestern (same)
Gonzaga vs TCU (same)
For the S16 you stay in your region but those teams are reseeded. Same for the F4 getting reseeded.
The great thing is you can still for the most part keep the brackets. Since most people fill it out digitally it is pretty easy to have the matchups auto fill.
Let's say you picked Purdue, Memphis, Tennessee, Oral Roberts, Providence, Kansas State, USC, Marquette in your bracket. Then the next round in your bracket it would be Purdue vs Oral Roberts, Tennessee vs Memphis, Marquette vs Providence, Kansas State vs USC. Next you have Purdue vs Providence and Kansas State vs Tennessee. And finally Purdue vs Tennessee, with Tennessee in the F4. So you would be 3-5 in that 1st round, still have two S16 teams left, one E8, and one F4.