Agree 100% with both of you. Taking a commitment in June is the antithesis of a "reach." The staff must have really seen something that they liked in this prospect -- I'm guessing that it was the athleticism / quick feet. Obviously, this isn't a fat slob [260 pounds on a 6-5 frame], so they probably project that he'll retain that athleticism even as he adds good size and weight as part of a collegiate S&C program. I'm betting that in two years, this kid will be at 290.
I'll be the first to admit that the offer list underwhelms, but give me smart, athletic OL over big fat guys who can't move any day. I trust the staffs' evaluation on this one; we're never going to get blue chip linemen, so we might as well identify and actively go after high upside guys in the trenches who fit our system.