OrangeXtreme
The Mayor of Dewitt
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2011
- Messages
- 232,172
- Like
- 422,371
I love Coach Mac but I consider Coach P the second best coach in program history after Ben.
i believe this year was the 1st he was eligible for the College Football HOF.
an honor that will undoubtably come his way.
3x ECAC Coach of the Year and an over .600 All Time winning percentage (even with storz stats)Yep
Is this a debate? Paul is the second best coach in Syracuse history. Had Gedney made it to the end zone in 92 do they finish #2 or #3 that year?Without Paul and George Mac goes the way of his predecessor
That’s why Jake made the decision he made. Best stretch of sustained quality In this program’s history is directly attributable to Pasqualoni The way that he was summarily dismissed by those nonentities crushed this program
Sure there's debate. Those '91 and '92 teams were built by Mac. P certainly has a strong case but so does Mac.Is this a debate? Paul is the second best coach in Syracuse history. Had Gedney made it to the end zone in 92 do they finish #2 or #3 that year?
i wish the younger people here could have experienced Syracuse football when we were the cool team in college football w NFL talent everywhere.
Sure there's debate. Those '91 and '92 teams were built by Mac. P certainly has a strong case but so does Mac.
Paul was at the helm of the sinking ship of SU FB. As much credit as he gets for the successes, he deserve the same for the demise. There were certainly facility factors out of his control, but he had lost control of the team. Guys in the team at the end were actively de-recruiting prospects when they were on campus.Without Paul and George Mac goes the way of his predecessor
That’s why Jake made the decision he made. Best stretch of sustained quality In this program’s history is directly attributable to Pasqualoni The way that he was summarily dismissed by those nonentities crushed this program
Paul was at the helm of the sinking ship of SU FB. As much credit as he gets for the successes, he deserve the same for the demise. There were certainly facility factors out of his control, but he had lost control of the team. Guys in the team at the end were actively de-recruiting prospects when they were on campus.
The last bowl game was a debacle. There was a 100 page playbook and ZERO offensive adjustments were made at halftime. The kids were just screamed at about lack of effort. No acknowledgement that there were game plan problems.
I regularly had some players at my house over a 5 year period, including Paul's last 2-3. The program and team were in a death spiral.
It was time for Paul to go. He just wouldn't/couldn't adjust his schemes, and he was really unable to recruit at a high level.
All of that said, I think that had he landed Michael Vick, he wins a NC and the program and Paul's history, are different.
Huh? Dino's 10 win team was three years removed from Shafer, was filled with many of his guys, and ran completely different offensive and defensive systems. The '91-'92 teams were loaded with the same players as the '90 team that was Mac's last and ran the same offense and defense. Many of the starters in '92 had been starters since '90. That was a young team that matured those next two years.ok so let’s do the same thing for dinos 10 win season. Shafer doesn’t get that benefit of the doubt. A coach coaches the team.
Paul is the second best ever. To me once a coach gets to 4 bcs esque games he can lay claim to be better than P.
Huh? Dino's 10 win team was three years removed from Shafer, was filled with many of his guys, and ran completely different offensive and defensive systems. The '91-'92 teams were loaded with the same players as the '90 team that was Mac's last and ran the same offense and defense. Many of the starters in '92 had been starters since '90. That was a young team that matured those next two years.
Don't try to make this look like I was insulting P. I said both have a strong case. To me, a successful rebuilding job and an undefeated season make a very strong case.
Coach P's SU career is like the finale of The Sopranos, it will be debated forever, with some people saying it was brilliant, and others saying it was disappointing.
I love Coach Mac but I consider Coach P the second best coach in program history after Ben.