Class of 2023 PF Joseph "JP" Estrella (ME / Brewster) Offered

[pwong]

We aren’t talking college athletes at a college. We’re talking potential college athletes. Meaning recruits.

HS kids can also earn NIL $. Dior made $100K as a HS senior doing commercials and endorsements for various companies. NIL “technically” can’t be tied to a school / not pay for play.

 

[DilemaCuse]

We aren’t talking college athletes at a college. We’re talking potential college athletes. Meaning recruits.

Ok, do you really think after that 9-0 Supreme Court decision, the court will say, "yeah, Recruits can't get any compensation, only college athletes'?

They probably lumped them all together as "Amatuer Athletes" meaning there is no distinction in their ruling between a Senior and an incoming freshman recruit. They effectively neutered the NCAA when it comes to this.

The whole point of their decision was this entity (NCAA) cannot stop or block the compensation of these athletes. People in other fields like music and arts can be compensated. Capitalism won.

 

[rrlbees]

HS kids can also earn NIL $. Dior made $100K as a HS senior doing commercials and endorsements for various companies. NIL “technically” can’t be tied to a school / not pay for play.

The Supreme Court ruling had nothing to do with NIL. It had to do with educational benefits. Read it.

Recruits can’t be paid to go to a school.

 

[rrlbees]

Ok, do you really think after that 9-0 Supreme Court decision, the court will say, "yeah, Recruits can't get any compensation, only college athletes'?

They probably lumped them all together as "Amatuer Athletes" meaning there is no distinction in their ruling between a Senior and an incoming freshman recruit. They effectively neutered the NCAA when it comes to this.

Read it. It had nothing to do with what you’re talking about. And they called them student athletes.

 

[pwong]

The Supreme Court ruling had nothing to do with NIL. It had to do with educational benefits. Read it.

Recruits can’t be paid to go to a school.

Yes, I know NIL can't be tied to a school and there aren't any pay for play causes. I'm just saying HS kids can earn NIL $ and it can be used as an incentive to be persuaded towards a certain school (not contractually binding to go to x school as a result).

 

[Capt. Tuttle]

Getting caught up on all this

The word "illegal" is being thrown around alot

If anything the 9-0 Supreme Court decision stated what the NCAA was doing in preventing college athletes from being compensated and earning money was actually "illegal"

So the NCAA rules at this point are a joke because if they ever try to enforce them on a player or school, the schools are lawyered up ready to fight and have this legal precedent as their argument

The NCAA does not want that smoke

So when it comes to Compensation and NIL, the NCAA really has no rules because if they try to enforce, they will likely lose in court

Actually, it was unconstitutional.

 

[rhcuse]

So...is it still 2:00 when JP pulls the rope-a-dope and puts on the Cuse lid?

 

[CA Monk]

Any chance here (said the naïve old school Manley Orangemen fan)?

 

[RF2044]

Any chance here (said the naïve old school Manley Orangemen fan)?

 

[OrangeXtreme]

"The stream will begin shortly".

Sounds like something my urologist would say.

 

[Sbucketball]

So...is it still 2:00 when JP pulls the rope-a-dope and puts on the Cuse lid?

He's on at 1 p.m. Here's a stream link:

 

[OrangeXtreme]

 

[CA Monk]

I think I speak for a majority of people on this board when I say I hope the kid...Oh Fl*ck U...not to the kid or his family, but to this now contaminated process.

 

[djcon57]

Meh, is what it is until the game changes for us.

 

[littlereg]

I’m not one to wish Ill-will on kids but by no means does that mean I have to hope this kid is the next coming of Jesus. He’s a random person to me just like any other person. I hope he has a successful life and that’s that,

 

[UpstateSM]

Hearing that he wasn’t a take for us anyways

 

[Cuse181]

Let’s see him sign the letter first

 

[jgeorge322]

Getting caught up on all this

The word "illegal" is being thrown around alot

If anything the 9-0 Supreme Court decision stated what the NCAA was doing in preventing college athletes from being compensated and earning money was actually "illegal"

So the NCAA rules at this point are a joke because if they ever try to enforce them on a player or school, the schools are lawyered up ready to fight and have this legal precedent as their argument

The NCAA does not want that smoke

So when it comes to Compensation and NIL, the NCAA really has no rules because if they try to enforce, they will likely lose in court

Wow, so many things go wrong when a non-lawyer tries to play lawyer.

 

[BludOrange]

After sitting a ton at Tenn and being over recruited for the following season, he'll be in the portal.

 

[orangefog]

Wow, so many things go wrong when a non-lawyer tries to play lawyer.

I OBJECT!!!!

 

[DilemaCuse]

Wow, so many things go wrong when a non-lawyer tries to play lawyer.

And yet the flood gates are opened after the decision and there is no going back

Most of us can all see it and admit it

 

[HOFCeluck]

Boeheim should’ve adopted him and he’d be a lock here

And if that didn’t work, promise him 20 shots a game.

 

[FrancoPizza]

So you’re proposal is that SU should cheat and not follow the NIL rules. Then what happens IF SU were to get caught and nailed? Then everyone can blame JB and JW. Sounds like the perfect plan for some.

We’re not “cheating” hard enough or smart enough. The top dogs are “cheating” their butts off, with plenty of cover, winning championships, then get slapped on the wrist because they’re too big to fail. We’re cheating lightly or just being careless (e.g. drug testing), not really reaping anything of substance, and have a coach that antagonizes those who set the rules which makes it easy to throw the book at us.

I put cheating in quotes because who really knows what’s going to be permissible when the dust settles in 5-10 years? We need a new university position created to sort this mess out.

 

[newmexicuse]

I dont get it, we have the first or second largest attendance every year. We have a lucrative ACC TV deal.

Why cant we compete with NIL $$$ ??????

 

[cliftonparksufan]

I dont get it, we have the first or second largest attendance every year. We have a lucrative ACC TV deal.

Why cant we compete with NIL $$$ ??????

Can't or Won't?