See Jake's post.
Where was Syracuse actually ranked preseason? They were picked to finish dead last in their own conference. If the AP/Coaches poll actually had a Top 50 poll, SU wouldn't have been on it. I doubt it would have been on a Top 75 poll...perhaps Top 100, but that may not even had been the case.
Syracuse is 6-0 and ranked from basically nowhere to Top 14. I'm not sure anyone with much credibility can argue truthfully and objectively any differently. Again see Jake's post...it is SO spot on!
None of our wins to date have been overly impressive either. UConn blows and Wagner blows more. UVA isn't good. Purdue is mediocre at best, and we struggled immensely to pull out a W against both, in the Dome. Louisville, is another mediocre at best team.
NCST was severely banged up coming into the Dome after having to play at Clemson and then FSU the following week. Furthermore, they had just lost their top QB 6 days prior to our game. Moreover, we had, for all intents and purposes, 3 weeks to prepare for State. With all of the advantages laid at SU's feet, it was 17-9 ( a one possession game) with 3 minutes left in the game where the outcome was still in doubt. SU converted the 3rd and 14 at the 2:55 mark and sealed the W shortly thereafter.
If we go down to Clemson this week and upset the mighty Tigers in their house, that will be mightily impressive. If that does happen, I'm confident the pollsters were deservedly catapult the Orange to Top 5 or at worse Top 7.
Yes, preseason rankings matter. However, when talking specifically about the Orange this season, based upon where we were heading into into it (not even in the stratosphere of deservedly being ranked, not to mention our recent history of being a bad football team, etc.) we are exactly in this point in time where we belong.