I found this from 2023. Apparently, Division II schools have been able to scrimmage another school during the spring. what would the justification be to not allow tow Division I schools from practice with each other and scrimmaging each other?
Football changes
Division II delegates that sponsor football approved a pair of membership-sponsored proposals,
both which become effective Aug. 1.
One proposal, which passed with overwhelming support
, permits football players in their initial year of college enrollment at a Division II school to participate in up to three contests without using a season of competition.
"Permitting Division II freshman football players to compete in a limited number of games without using a season of competition and still having four years of competition remaining should help keep football student-athletes engaged, enrolled and improve their chances for academic success," Mike Racy, commissioner of the Mid-America Intercollegiate Athletics Association, said in the business session. "This proposal enhances the student-athlete experience for football players and hopefully will help with student retention."
The other football proposal permits a football team to scrimmage against a four-year college during its spring practice period as one of its three permissible 11-on-11 scrimmages outside the playing season. The scrimmage has to occur on or after the 10th day of the spring practice period, allowing time for student-athletes to become acclimated to full contact. Additionally, the legislation specifies that a student-athlete's participation in such a scrimmage does not trigger use of a season of competition if the student-athlete was academically eligible during the fall term.
"This proposal provides opportunities for an enhanced collegiate experience in Division II football, where student-athletes can now participate against another team in the spring that they normally wouldn't get to," Andy Peterson, director of athletics at Northwest Missouri State, said in support of the proposal. "This proposal can also impact, possibly, retention at institutions supporting football (by improving) student-athlete engagement."
Division II delegates approved 11 of 12 legislative proposals at the division's business session of the 2023 NCAA Convention on Saturday in San Antonio.
www.ncaa.org
Another good article on the subject. The information regarding tampering towards the end of the article is interesting.
Having practice games between college football programs during spring practice is financially practical. So of course the NCAA doesn't want it.
www.usatoday.com
The following quote is from Coach Rodirguez at West Virginia. I thought this was interesting cause Syracuse may need to cut or push approximately 20 players to the portal in order to make room for all of the players who have been offered scholarships and are scheduled to enroll over the summer (as many as 23, I think). The coaches already have a good idea who the 1's and 2's will be, but who will be the 3's and 4's? The 3's and 4's will either be guys who coaches believe can develop or possible older walk-ons who can provide valuable depth now. When you're crunching numbers and trying to stay at or under 105 it gets really interesting when you realize we don't have a long snapper on scholarship. How may do you keep? Also, Max Runyon played in 12 games: fullback (29 snaps), TE (1 snap) or special teams (20 plays). Does he make the cut? Josh Kubala (an ROTC or family scholarship) also played in 12 games: 12 snaps at LB and 168 snaps on special teams. Does he make the cut? We had two walk-on QBs last year (Grussar has already been moved to safety). What becomes of them?
“Those other coaches who want to come watch our spring game, they’re going to get a good look at our threes and fours,” West Virginia coach Rich Rodriguez told me last week. “We won’t have our best out there. (Coaches are) going to have to go way down the list to find out who these guys are.”
These are interesting times for sure.
Go Orange.