OrangeXtreme
The Mayor of Dewitt
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2011
- Messages
- 230,621
- Like
- 418,188
The North remembersWhite, Walker?
He is an elite prospect with nfl size6' 3" 210 and 10.25" hand size. Accurate, has a good arm, effective as a runner when he has to run, mostly operates out of a pocket. Would need good pass protection from OL. Great offer IMO.
Eh true freshman-- could be bad coaching as well.The fact that he couldn’t unseat Thorne makes him a hard pass for me. Their QBs are awful.
It's hard to draw conclusions without knowing the behind the scenes details. McCord wasn't guaranteed a starting job even though he was the incumbant. That's unfathomable now. Changes in scenery help some guys.The fact that he couldn’t unseat Thorne makes him a hard pass for me. Their QBs are awful.
Comparing to McCord situation is apples to oranges. OSU needed a scapegoat and were bringing in a high profile recruit. White is already there and has sat behind a garbage QB the whole season.It's hard to draw conclusions without knowing the behind the scenes details. McCord wasn't guaranteed a starting job even though he was the incumbant. That's unfathomable now. Changes in scenery help some guys.
Comparing to McCord situation is apples to oranges. OSU needed a scapegoat and were bringing in a high profile recruit. White is already there and has sat behind a garbage QB the whole season.
You're right. There are lots of differences. One being he is a true freshman and McCord was a 4th year junior. It's tough to draw conclusions on a guy that hasn't had his first spring practice yet. I feel the same way I do about the transfer olinemen. Bring em all in and let the cream rise to the top. The rest can transfer again.Comparing to McCord situation is apples to oranges. OSU needed a scapegoat and were bringing in a high profile recruit. White is already there and has sat behind a garbage QB the whole season.
Apparently I’m the only one that watched Auburn play. I forgot no other true freshman has taken the QB reigns over in a bad situation … ever.You're right. There are lots of differences. One being he is a true freshman and McCord was a 4th year junior. It's tough to draw conclusions on a guy that hasn't had his first spring practice yet. I feel the same way I do about the transfer olinemen. Bring em all in and let the cream rise to the top. The rest can transfer again.
You're drawing conclusions based on NOT watching someone play. Coaches are stupid sometimes. Sean Tucker wasn't going to play as a freshman until we had two opt outs and an injury.Apparently I’m the only one that watched Auburn play. I forgot no other true freshman has taken the QB reigns over in a bad situation … ever.
I did see him in the brief opportunity he was given it wasn’t pretty. Yes it could be coaching but if we are sticking to the he is just a frosh trope how is it any better than rolling Jakari out there? The profile doesn’t make sense based on Fran’s musings about the portal, because he isn’t Kyle. Now with that being said he would make sense if Kyle was returning and they wanted to develop him to compete with the others in 2026. He won’t make the impact we need next season let’s not kid ourselves, if he does I’ll be happy to admit I was wrong, however pursuing a guy like this gives me more hope that the McCord waiver is more like fire than just smoke.You're drawing conclusions based on NOT watching someone play. Coaches are stupid sometimes. Sean Tucker wasn't going to play as a freshman until we had two opt outs and an injury.
If the coaches want to bring him in and let him compete, where's the harm? This staff does not seem like they're pinning their hopes on one guy. If he sucks, someone else gets the nod and he transfers again.
It may not be better than rolling Jakari out there. Like I said, bring in as many as you can, make them compete, play the best, and the rest get the talk. If it's a multi-year starter that wins the job, be more selective next year. If it's a one year guy, lather-rinse-repeat.I did see him in the brief opportunity he was given it wasn’t pretty. Yes it could be coaching but if we are sticking to the he is just a frosh trope how is it any better than rolling Jakari out there? The profile doesn’t make sense based on Fran’s musings about the portal, because he isn’t Kyle. Now with that being said he would make sense if Kyle was returning and they wanted to develop him to compete with the others in 2026. He won’t make the impact we need next season let’s not kid ourselves, if he does I’ll be happy to admit I was wrong, however pursuing a guy like this gives me more hope that the McCord waiver is more like fire than just smoke.