Are you sure? Not saying that you are wrong, just seems, from the outside looking in, that the player would need to fully qualify for academic scholarship under the university's standard requirements. Otherwise, why wouldn't programs all over the country move out non contributing returning players to free up football scholarships?
Doesn't seem ethical or within NCAA rules.
It would very unethical if the NCAA comes in tell the kid who's career is over due to injury or serious health issues you no longer can get a free education and at the same time punish the school for doing the right thing.