Rickie Collins

[powdersmack]

You play the person who gives you the chance to win, and unless Collins has a good 1st quarter next week against Duke play for the future and that is Carney.

You're willing to give him all of one quarter? And the future? Angeli and Collins both have time, as does Carney...Fran Brown plays for the NOW.

 

[JeremyCuse]

Without Angelli, the QB competition needs to be reopened. Collins had an opportunity to show he was able to close out a critical game and didn't.
If he doesn’t show something very early next week play Carney and build for the future.

Carney is gonna get a long look. Collins is very raw as a passer, I wouldn't be shocked if Carney became the starter at some point this year.

 

[bballbeadle]

Coach Collins up. Hes QB1 now. Carney next year.

Angeli next year.

 

[CanadianSU]

So we live and die with Collins?

Yes, he was fine.

The TD pass was money.

 

[Ttk.gman2]

Coach Collins up. Hes QB1 now. Carney next year.

Carney next year???

 

[anglerman]

Yes, he was fine.

The TD pass was money.

He looked terrible to me. I predict we see Carney before too long

 

[JeffCuse]

Carney next year???

Im just saying not this year. Who knows what next year holds.

 

[Qbobby]

If u expect him to just walk in and score you are crazy he got a couple first downs but yes he need stop improve and improve fast and not turn the ball over .

I mean, he literally walked in and scored...

 

[Dr. Bill]

Carney is gonna get a long look. Collins is very raw as a passer, I wouldn't be shocked if Carney became the starter at some point this year.

Carney is straight out of HS. Why is there so much faith in this kid. Ricky is in his 3rd year of college. We better hope Ricky can grow as a starter.

 

[Sudano]

I mean, he literally walked in and scored...

And then threw alot of poor passes, even his completions were off.

 

[CanadianSU]

He looked terrible to me.

Pretty over the top take. Not sure what he did that could remotely be defined as terrible.

 

[Ttk.gman2]

Im just saying not this year. Who knows what next year holds.

I think Rickie or Steve starts next year . Carney is a couple years away.

 

[Ttk.gman2]

I mean, he literally walked in and scored...

Talking about after that drive….

 

[Ttk.gman2]

And then threw alot of poor passes, even his completions were off.

He doesn’t have the game reps he will improve over the year all we need is to get to a bowl game against this tough schedule and the season is a success.

 

[Phillymoose]

He looked terrible to me. I predict we see Carney before too long

I don't agree with this. Some of the play calls were dumb but he put the ball where it was needed.
The OL picked a bad time to crumble under pressure... whereas they played well for most of the game.
What are we even taking about after Collins got the save in Death freaking Valley?

 

[Qbobby]

Talking about after that drive….

After the drive I saw him have at least two passes dropped and Clemson blitzing the crap out of him. After not prepping to be the starter, I thought he did about as well as you could expect.

 

[Sudano]

He doesn’t have the game reps he will improve over the year all we need is to get to a bowl game against this tough schedule and the season is a success.

You're right, just pointing out facts.

 

[baggerbob]

You're right, just pointing out facts.

Hopefully a full week of practice will get Rickie on the same page as his receivers and the offense will take off.

 

[JeremyCuse]

Carney is straight out of HS. Why is there so much faith in this kid. Ricky is in his 3rd year of college. We better hope Ricky can grow as a starter.

I hope Ricky takes the job and runs with it but he's not at LSU and lost out to Angeli here for a reason. Carney can sling it has a much bigger arm and SU wants to throw a lot. It's not a big leap.

 

[Ttk.gman2]

After the drive I saw him have at least two passes dropped and Clemson blitzing the crap out of him. After not prepping to be the starter, I thought he did about as well as you could expect.

I’m saying the same thing? He will improve each week and get more comfortable.

 

[Ttk.gman2]

I hope Ricky takes the job and runs with it but he's not at LSU and lost out to Angeli here for a reason. Carney can sling it has a much bigger arm and SU wants to throw a lot. It's not a big leap.

How do you know he has a bigger arm than Rickie?

 

[JeremyCuse]

How do you know he has a bigger arm than Rickie?

From people who have watched practice

 

[Ttk.gman2]

From people who have watched practice

If carney is such a better qb than Rickie why was Rickie named starter in the spring?

 

[JeremyCuse]

If carney is such a better qb than Rickie why was Rickie named starter in the spring?

I said Bigger arm, didn't say he was the better overall qb

 

[OrangeXtreme]

Can't get a med redshirt, we're passed the 30% mark of the season. Can still ask for one but likely to be denied

This is game 4 out of 12. 30% of 12 games = 3.6 which gets rounded up to 4.

Problem is Angeli already redshirted in 2022.

He has to apply for a waiver. You know how that goes.