I liken this to the Draft vs Free Agency debate in the NFL.
Usually the best teams are the teams that utilize the NFL Draft and have a homegrown roster and only fill certain needs with the Free Agency.
I think too many teams in college have used both ends of the spectrum to the extreme. IMO the best way is to build a college roster is with HS kids and fill in the needs, losses, misses using the transfer portal. I have been very happy with what Red has done on the recruiting front. Which should be what 85-90% of the roster should be formed from. I think Red has struggled with the transfer portal, but hopefully, once these HS players start to fill in the roster. We won’t need as many players from the Transfer Portal.
The 6th year players will be gone, and this will really even out the number of players available in the transfer portal and the advantage you get from those grown men.
I thought Red could have utilized the Transfer portal better to churn the roster in the first couple years before his recruits started to get here but that doesn’t seem to be the case. But I do like the recruits Red is starting to pull in. May take a little longer than we would have liked, but the trajectory is pointing up. Talent generally wins out, and Red took over a roster void of high end talent.