Trebor Pena transferring to PSU

[jr4750]

Pena nor his new QB Drew Allar are exactly lighting the world on fire. Also was made abundantly clear we were bringing in another QB prior to Pena leaving. You think Pena would have more or less than 150 yards receiving this year with Angeli throwing to him?

Cooks stats would be Peña’s if he were here.

 

[ADKDave]

That's some harsh ****.

CDRW was a mess here, but he's crushing it at Marshall so far. Maybe Rickie will end up the same, who knows. But that's P5 to G5 and nothing wrong with going where you have a better chance to succeed.

Not writing him off that he could succeed here based on one start and a couple times being thrown in as backup. Concerned? Of course. But not writing him off.

"MAYBE DII", come on.

Who would have thought Tommy Cutlets would start as a nfl QB?

 

[Archbold44]

Cooks stats would be Peña’s if he were here.

Pena will get a chance to shine on a bigger stage. BUT, at the same time, NOT shining on a bigger stage can be a problem too. Perhaps it will be more difficult to get open against the Ohio State and Oregon DBs than it is to get open against 2024 Miami and Stanford, etc.

He has 8 rushing attempts and 15 receptions for PSU. WR end runs do not translate well to the NFL.

 

[ImperialOrange]

Cooks stats would be Peña’s if he were here.

Less YAC, more targets, fewer fumbles but yeah similar overall

 

[IthacaMatt]

That first drive was moving along nicely and then he just threw up that "What ARE YOU THINKING" pass and it all went to crap after.
I hope they can build him up and get him to see the other targets, especially deep as safeties are all over him.

That first interception got tipped at the line of scrimmage.

 

[GHLF]

I’m skeptical that Pena could have done anything to help Collins not lock on a guy and not work through any progressions at all. After this weekend, I’m certain Pena made the right decisions which ended up with him not being here. Anyone who doesn’t realize that after Saturday is delusional.

Collins is MAYBE a DII QB, absolutely not an FCS QB - and not even playing with prime Jerry Rice would change that.

Your assumptions after one game are delusional we shall see

 

[CbusCuse]

Musings on X [Twitter]

Pena is not the 4th option. He has barely the most receptions and yards on the team.

But PSU passing game is not good. Drew Allar is not good. Its amazing how many QB's are hyped that are just blah. This QB draft class is going to be absolutely terrible. Too bad McCord didn't get one more year and stayed at SU for 2025. Would have been great all around for him and us.

 

[MGraves5]

That first interception got tipped at the line of scrimmage.

That pass wasn't tipped. The pass 2 plays before that intended for Villari was tipped and probably should have been intercepted. The interception happened when he was just staring down his receiver and the defense made him pay.

 

[Cuse On 3]

The offense moved the ball at times but couldnt score. The Defense never did anything

Yep, this is why I think we could do a lot better on offense with Rickie if the turnovers stop. Defense will figure it out.

 

[sufan59]

Pena is not the 4th option. He has barely the most receptions and yards on the team.

But PSU passing game is not good. Drew Allar is not good. Its amazing how many QB's are hyped that are just blah. This QB draft class is going to be absolutely terrible. Too bad McCord didn't get one more year and stayed at SU for 2025. Would have been great all around for him and us.

For Penn State, it was never the wide receivers last year or this year. I actually was finding myself getting annoyed during the game how they weren't getting Pena the ball more. Like use him to soften up the defense to make room for your even more explosive playmakers. I'm curious if they figure out that they need to use him more in short to medium yardage situations. Even though as a Syracuse fan, Penn State failing to reach the next level probably leaves a door open for Syracuse to gain some momentum in Pennsylvania recruiting, it was still frustrating because I think they win the game if Allar looked to Pena more. We certainly aren't going to be shy about throwing the ball to wide receivers. It's something between Allar and the offensive staff. They didn't even look to make plays with the wide receivers until they were down 17-3. Penn State has an excellent defense and you wonder if that affects offensive play calling. You don't want to risk interceptions trying to get it to your wide receivers to put more pressure on the defense. But guess what, when you are going up against elite teams they also have great defenses. They can contain your NFL running backs and tight ends if your not throwing to the wide receivers.

 

[wfschrec]

Hmm. I'm certain Pena made a business decision to turn his back on the only school that offered him the opportunity to play in a power conference out of high school, to play for that school's biggest regional nemesis who also happened to harbor a serial child molester for years.

I don't wish him ill, but he can kick rocks.

That wasn’t all they harbored … I loathe that university and its fan base.

 

[Cusefan95]

That's some harsh ****.

CDRW was a mess here, but he's crushing it at Marshall so far. Maybe Rickie will end up the same, who knows. But that's P5 to G5 and nothing wrong with going where you have a better chance to succeed.

Not writing him off that he could succeed here based on one start and a couple times being thrown in as backup. Concerned? Of course. But not writing him off.

"MAYBE DII", come on.

That’s fair. Honestly I was thinking G5, but knew my take that Pena made the right decision was going to be very unpopular and decide to make it an absurdly hot take.

I’m not writing Collins off either - although that’s mostly because I don’t have a choice; there’s not another option. And I’ll be more than willing to eat crow if the last game ends up being the outlier and we somehow make a bowl game.

 

[Cusefan95]

For Penn State, it was never the wide receivers last year or this year. I actually was finding myself getting annoyed during the game how they weren't getting Pena the ball more. Like use him to soften up the defense to make room for your even more explosive playmakers. I'm curious if they figure out that they need to use him more in short to medium yardage situations. Even though as a Syracuse fan, Penn State failing to reach the next level probably leaves a door open for Syracuse to gain some momentum in Pennsylvania recruiting, it was still frustrating because I think they win the game if Allar looked to Pena more. We certainly aren't going to be shy about throwing the ball to wide receivers. It's something between Allar and the offensive staff. They didn't even look to make plays with the wide receivers until they were down 17-3. Penn State has an excellent defense and you wonder if that affects offensive play calling. You don't want to risk interceptions trying to get it to your wide receivers to put more pressure on the defense. But guess what, when you are going up against elite teams they also have great defenses. They can contain your NFL running backs and tight ends if your not throwing to the wide receivers.

Penn State doesn’t trust Allar, so they call a very conservative game. The only reason they ever open it up is because they fell behind and need to score - and frequently it ends like it did Saturday, with Allar throwing an INT (in this case a game ending one). Allar never does well enough sustainably to build any trust in the OC, so they keep reverting back to a conservative plan where they try not to put Allar in a situation where he screws it up.

It’s weird though, because Penn State still markets him like he’s a top QB. I could see a WR thinking that was a hole they could help fill last offseason - but it is starting to look like Allar is the problem.

 

[wfschrec]

That’s fair. Honestly I was thinking G5, but knew my take that Pena made the right decision was going to be very unpopular and decide to make it an absurdly hot take.

I’m not writing Collins off either - although that’s mostly because I don’t have a choice; there’s not another option. And I’ll be more than willing to eat crow if the last game ends up being the outlier and we somehow make a bowl game.

Cook had 6 grabs for 74 yards with Collins slinging it and Cook had at least 1 drop ... extrapolate those numbers over 12 to 13 games (if you make a bowl game) and it is far better than what he does at PSU. It was a bad decision and everyone (except him) knew it. Miami would have been a better fit for him but ... alas he chose pervert heaven.

 

[PAcuse]

That first interception got tipped at the line of scrimmage.

Ah yes I see it now after rewatching, the guy coming off the edge gets his arm

 

[MadNY3]

Unless Pena could play DL or the secondary and tackle, this team is 3-2 with or without him.

Onward.

 

[Cusefan0307]

Pena is not the 4th option. He has barely the most receptions and yards on the team.

But PSU passing game is not good. Drew Allar is not good. Its amazing how many QB's are hyped that are just blah. This QB draft class is going to be absolutely terrible. Too bad McCord didn't get one more year and stayed at SU for 2025. Would have been great all around for him and us.

QB play generally sucks this year in college. McCord may have made a mistake leaving. He might have been a really high pick this year.

 

[mustacheovich]

QB play generally sucks this year in college. McCord may have made a mistake leaving. He might have been a really high pick this year.

As far as I know he was never granted an extra year, so how could he have made a mistake?

 

[kirbivore]

Must be nice to overrated in the polls every year so you can survive losing your two biggest games on your schedule and still make the 12 team playoff. At Iowa might be tricky since it's the game before the road tOSU game, but the B1G gave Pedo St. a break with a bye week before tOSU. The home game against Indiana the week after tOSU loss could be interesting. Other than that not much on the schedule @UCLA, home Northwestern, @ Michigan St, home Nebraska, @Buttgers.

 

[PeteCalvin]

That pass wasn't tipped. The pass 2 plays before that intended for Villari was tipped and probably should have been intercepted. The interception happened when he was just staring down his receiver and the defense made him pay.

The first drive INT was tipped. If you watch the play over in slow motion, the defender taps the ball/hand just as Rickie is releasing it. The throwing motion and the way the ball comes out like a duck don’t match up. It was tipped at the point of release. I’ve watched it so many times it sickens me.

 

[anomander]

Whatever way you slice it looks like Fran made a perfect decision letting him walk and keeping a substantial sum in the war-chest. WR is the least of our problems. Easily, the deepest position group on the team.

Wish Maraad got his NIL deal.

 

[MGraves5]

The first drive INT was tipped. If you watch the play over in slow motion, the defender taps the ball/hand just as Rickie is releasing it. The throwing motion and the way the ball comes out like a duck don’t match up. It was tipped at the point of release. I’ve watched it so many times it sickens me.

Haha, I'll have to go back and watch it again. I watched earlier a few times and couldn't see where he got hit.

 

[MGraves5]

QB play generally sucks this year in college. McCord may have made a mistake leaving. He might have been a really high pick this year.

McCord didn't have any eligibility left...

 

[MGraves5]

As far as I know he was never granted an extra year, so how could he have made a mistake?

Exactly, McCord ran out of eligibility and had already been denied once

 

[Cuse On 3]

I love cook, I love that we have cook. Pena will never play here again, nor do I care. That is all. GO ORANGE!