Unfortunately it wasn't bogus and it wasn't at Yankee stadium.
http://www.archives.nd.edu/about/news/index.php/2011/nd-vs-syracuse-11181961/#.UyXLbPldVn8
The issue was whether the game could end on that play, not on whether it was a good call. The rules at the time said that the kicking team became the defensive team when they surrendered the ball by kicking it. Since Sweeney got (both the hodler ona dhte kicker, based on the film I've seen of the play- which I can't find on the net), after the ball ahd left the kicker's foot, under the rules at the time, Syracuse was now the offensive team and the game could end on a penalty against Syracuse. But the refrees ignored that rule and gave Notre Dame another kick, this one from 41 yards rather than 56 and he made it.
Syracuse appealed to the NCAA, who said that, by rule, they could not change the final score of the game once the game was over. The only thing that could be done was to ask Notre Dame to concede the game, as Cornell had done to Dartmouth in 1940 when they got a fifth down and scored to beat them.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Down_Game_(1940)
Notre Dame refused and the game went into the books as a 15-17 Notre Dame victory. President Kennedy, asked about the narrowness of his Presidential victory and the role Chicago's dubious politics might have have played in it, said "I'm like Notre Dame. I'll take 'em any way I can get 'em."
Two points in Notre Dame's favor: It was an obvious violation, which shouldn't have been a "free play" for Syracuse and it was a lousy rule that got changed before the next season. Now the kicking team remains the "offensive" team until the end of the play so it isn't open season on the kicker. I'll add that trying to block a 56 yard field goal in those days when there weren't any kicking specialists ranks as the most idiotic play in football history. The ball, which, as noted, was already on it's way when Sweeney barreled into both the kicker and holder, was a dying quail that never made it within 20 yards of the goal post and was wide right in any case.
Back to basketball.
[/quote
Thanks for the info SWC...my old man was bitter over this game for a long time