The trials of being a Montreal Expo Fan - Part 1
This will be therapeutic in a way.
From 1969-1978 the Expos were your typical expansion team. It took until their 10th year to become relevant -- a little longer than some -- but also better than its expansion mate the San Diego Padres
So let's start in 1979 which would be my first memories of baseball. While I don't remember watching the Expos in 1979 that would have been the first year my parents would have taken me to an Expo game so let's start there. Although I do need to highlight one item from 1977.
1977 -
The Expos move from Jarry Park to Olympic Stadium: Jarry Park was -- even by standards of those times -- a very substandard MLB park. The 1976 Montreal Olympics, and the building of a brand new stadium, should have been a major blessing for the franchise. Instead too much power was granted to some idiotic architect who insisted on stupidity like "Fingers coming from the side of the roof" and a Spaceship like structure which made for a horrible ball park and made building a roof much more problematic then it ever should have been. It also had arguably the worst turf situation in MLB. This should have been the opportunity for the City to have a great ballpark (in the mold of what was normal for the times). But by about 1985 it started to become a bit of a farce. And by the 1990's it became a major problem.
1979 - Expos blow the division lead in the final week of the season With 6 days left in the season they led the NL East. They finished the season 1-4 and missed the playoffs by 2.0 games. But that was okay, this was one of the most talented young teams in baseball. They had never finished .500 and were a 78 win team they year before.
They had some good young pitching, arguably the best catcher in baseball (in Gary Carter), and what was considered by some the best outfield in baseball.
"The Team of the 1980's" --
As the team entered the 1980's many expected the team to make the playoffs a number of times due to young talent. 5 of the 7 best Expos / National players in terms of WAR, were the core of the at Expos team between 1980-1984. Those players should have been enough with decent supporting talent to make the playoffs. Unfortunately they never got enough talent around them for various reasons and would never make the playoffs except for sliding in during a strike shortened season in 1981.
And entering 1980 the Expos had other great talent other than those 5.
Ellis Valentine being the largest one. An all star at 22, a gold glover at 23, he was having his best season in 1980 at the age of 25... but fell to injuries for half that year. His career was essentially done by 1981 due to injuries and drug issues.
Larry Parrish at the age of 25 in 1979, was 4th in NL MVP voting. He was supposed to be one of the key pieces. But he struggled in 1980 and 1981 - the Expos then gave up on him for 35 year old Al Oliver. Al Oliver was great in 1982 (3rd in MVP voting) but he became old very quickly after that
The Expos were not only about position players. By 1979 and 1980 they were considered to have the best group of young arms in MLB, But none of them are pictured above with consistent veteran Steve Rogers. Why? Young pitchers like David Palmer and Charlie Lea would be injury prone. David Palmer had his best season at 21 in 1979 before injuries plagued him for most of his career. Scott Sanderson who was great as a 23 year old in 1980, would never return to that level. Bill Gullickson had arguably his best year as a 21 year old rookie in 1980.
So while there were stars there were a number of young players from that 1979 and 1980 team that really never matured as talents, or just plain fell off.
1980 - Expos hold the Division Lead with 3 games to go. Miss the playoffs.
Why the hell would Dick Williams put that bum Stan Bahnsen in to pace Mike Schmidt in a critical moment on the final weekend.
1981 - Blue Monday - How many franchises have their most historic moment being a loss in an elimination playoff game?
1981 was the only year the Expos made the playoffs and that was in part because the Strike allowed for 2 teams from each division. They won their only playoff series that year against Philly, but that only led to an NLCS Appearance.
- The NLCS at the time was a 5 game series. 1981 was the year of "Fernando Mania" where Fernando was an absolute beast.
- Expos took a 2-1 series lead, but blew the opportunity to win at home in Game 4.
- Fernando Valenzuela would likely not have pitched that game 5 on short rest, but then it rained, and rained, and rained, and since that idiotic architect had built a stadium with a roof that still did not function, the game had to be cancelled.
- So now Fernando was available for game 5. Of course he pitched 8 2/3 innings of brilliant baseball.
- And then Rick Monday won the game with a home run in the top of the 9th when the Expos brought in their star pitcher to Pitch.
1982 - 1984-
Star Studded Mediocrity
As the team entered the 1982 season it was still considered one of the best in baseball. But 1982 was largely mediocre in 1982. This was the time when all the other young players on those 1979 & 1980 team seemed to regress / be gone / hurt. The 1982 team had a legit 5 all stars but not much else.
1983 and 1984 were forgettable seasons. The team floundered around .500, the owner was upset and a major move was coming
December 1984 - Owner Charles Bronfman starts to give up on the team. The Heart and Soul of the Expos, Gary Carter, is traded for 3 baseballs and a Rosin Bag.
What was the return
Floyd Youmans - showed mild promise when he was not high on coke or injured. (which was 98% of the time)
Hubie Brooks - Did get one of the oddest 100 RBI seasons in 1985. But he was the worst defensive SS I had ever seen.
Herm Winningham - A .230 hitting outfielder with no power or plate discipline. Awesome.
Mike Fitzgerald - The catcher to replace Carter, a replacement level player.
1985 and 1986 - Largely forgettable seasons. Nothing really bad happened because we were never good enough to feel pain.
November 1986 to February 1987 - Free Agency Disaster - Andre Dawson and Tim Raines
In the offseason of 1986, declining Hall of Famer Andre Dawson has had enough with the craptastic turf of the Big Owe which has led to multiple knee injuries. Those injuries robbed him of most of his athletic brilliance. Not sure if the Expos ever made a legit offer that year -- probably not. The "cheapness" era had begun. He signs with Cubs and becomes the 1987 NL MVP.
The Expos allow Tim Raines, 1986 NL Batting Champion and second in the NL in WAR in 1986 to become a free agent. No doubt he is one of the best players in baseball. Thanks to collusion no teams makes an offer to Tim Raines that year, and he signs back with the Expos.
1987 - Expos have the best record in the NL East from May 1st to the end of the year.
Why is May 1 relevant? Superstar (at that time) Tim Raines was forced to sit out the first month of the season due to an absurd free agency rule that has since been fixed. In the 140 games he was allowed to play the Expos had better records than the Mets and Cardinals.
That being said that 1987 team is one of the worst 91 win teams of all time. Not sure how they won 91 games with that roster. But they did.
1989 -
In late may Expos trade for pending Free agent Mark Langston, are 63-44 on August 7th, the 3rd best record in baseball and have a 3 game lead in the NL East. They proceed to finish the season with an awesome 18-37 record and finish 12 games out of first.
Mark Langston was not the problem that year at 12-9, 2.39 ERA, but the offence did them in.
1989 Offseason - Of course the Expos do not sign Mark Langston. Nobody expected them to. But that young pitcher who was 0-4 with a 6.67 ERA that they traded to get Langston -- Randy Johnson.
As we get to the 1990's,
Expos owner Charles Bronfman has had enough although he largely gave up on the franchise after the 1984 season and the Gary Carter trade. He sells the team to a local consortium who has no real interest in the Expos.
That consortium is fronted by Claude Brochu a mere millionaire who invested a minimal amount of the team but is told to never make any cash calls, and any cash calls will need to front any losses. And that would be a problem.
1990's Part 2 - To Come