A comparison of the 2022 Mets and the 2024 Mets to date looking at players who were on both teams and OPS for hitters and ERA for pitchers. (as of 5/23/24)
C- Thomas Nido (age 28-30) 2022: .600 2024: .630 result: +30
1b- Pete Alonso (age 27-29) 2022: .869 2024: .779 result: -90
2b – Jeff McNeil (age 30-32) 2022: .836 2024: .657 result: -179
SS – Francisco Lindor (age 28-30) 2022: .788 2024: .634 result: -154
CF – Brandon Nimmo (age 29-31) 2022: .800 2024: .766 result: -34
RF - Starling Marte (age 33-35) 2022: .814 2024: .693 result: -121
(Mark Vientos, Bret Baty and Francisco Alvarez played a total of 32 games at the end of the season. The sample was so small I didn’t include them)
SP – Tylor Megill (age 26-28) 2022: 5.13 2024: 3.00 result: -2.13
SP - Jose Butto (age 24-26) 2022: 15.75 2024: 3.08 result: -12.67
(Poor guy pitched 4 innings in 2022 and gave up 9 hits and 7 runs)
RP – Edwin Diaz (age 28-30) 2022: 1.31 2024: 5.50 result: +4.19
RP – Adam Ottavino (age 36-38) 2022: 2.06 2024: 3.79 result: +1.73
RP - Drew Smith (age 28-30) 2022: 3.33 2024: 2.70 result: -0.63 (but on the IL)
RP - Sean Reid-Foley (age 26-28) 2022: 5.40 2024: 1.42 result: -3.98
With the exception of Marte and Ottavino, these players should all be in their primes. If Alonso, McNeil, Lindor and Diaz were performing as they did then, we'd be in pretty good shape. But they aren't.