If I were King, I would construct a conference of:
Syracuse
Penn State
Pittsburgh
Boston College
Rutgers
WVU
Maryland
Cincinnati
Virginia Tech
With regular games against:
ND
Miami
Army
Navy
But I’m not King. It’s never going to happen. What I want, as a fan, means nothing. Ten years in, I still feel no real kinship with ACC teams.
I would definitely drop Cincy from that.
I think you have to include:
SU, Pitt, Penn State, WV, BC, RU, MD, Temple (these are our Top 7 FBS historical opponents)
Then depending on how large you want to go:
Navy, Miami, Army, VA Tech, UConn, Notre Dame (the first four are 8th, 9th, 11th, and 12th)
If you need to round off to get an even number:
Cincy, ECU
I prefer round robin leagues (original Big East + Penn State and Maryland, or Notre Dame too) but having all 16 of the above wouldn't be bad either.