Chukwu vs. Melo | Syracusefan.com

Chukwu vs. Melo

SWC75

Bored Historian
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
34,005
Like
65,626
Talking about next year's team is suddenly almost worthy of the off-topic board but a friend asked me what to expect next year, (he never thinks we'll be any good, so I try to cheer him up). I was describing Chukwu to him and saying that I hoped he would have the impact in the middle of the Zone that Fab Melo did in 2012, when we had a 30-1 regular season with the only loss coming when he was suspended. The one team to beat us was Cincy in the BET when they went off from three. Then we lost to the Buckeye in the Big Dance without Melo and with a blizzard of referee whistles. We wound up with our best numerical record ever, (in terms of wins - losses), 34-3. I figure with a shot blocker like Chukwu in a zone surrounded by guards who are 6-5 and 6-6 and forwards who are 6-9 and 6-8, we might be able to play the kind of defense next year we did in 2012, (and maybe get out and run on offense as a result, as we did in 2012), and maybe get similar results.

Melo was listed as 7-0 244 on the roster that year. Chukwu is listed as 7-2 226 but I've read they are trying to get him up to 240. So Melo was stronger but Chukwu is taller, the tallest player we've ever had. I saw Obokoh standing next to him and the top of the 6-9 Obokoh's head seemed to be parallel with the bottom of Chukwu's chin. So we could be a very physically imposing team next year.

One thing I could not do for my friend is describe what Chukwu did in his one year at Providence, (he has potentially three years at SU so this could be quite an era).. So, naturally, I looked it up.

Chukwu played in all 34 of his team's games that year, a total of 335 minutes. He was 33 for 50 from the field, an astronomical 66% field goal percentage. obviously those were all dunks and lay-ups and mostly put-backs but we haven't been very good at dunks and lay-ups this year and an offensive rebound has often been a excuse for Coleman to put on a dribbling exhibition, so 66% looks pretty good to me. He shot 24 for 40 at the foul line, 60%. But we've seen worse. He had 83 rebounds, 5 assists, 9 steals and 23 blocks. He turned the ball over 19 times and committed 63 fouls. Here is his his line based on those numbers:

9.9m 10.7p 9.9r 0.6a 1.1s 2.7b = 25.0+ 2.0mfg 1.9mft 2.3to 7.5pf = 13.7- = 11.3np 6.8oe 4.5fg

I decide to compare that to both of Fab Melo's years here: his highly disappointing first year and his tremendous second year:

2010-11:
9.9m 9.4p 7.8r 1.0a 1.2s 3.1b = 22.5+ 2.7mfg 2.0mft 3.1to 7.3pf = 15.1- = 7.4np 4.7oe 2.7fg

Chukwu played exactly the same number of minutes. He scored and rebounded a little better. , didn't pass quite as well or block quite as many shots. He also didn't miss quite as many shot but neither big many shot the ball much. Melo had more turnovers. Neither guy could stay on the floor because they committed way to many fouls, always a sign of a player who, in JB's words, doesn't know where he has to be on defense.

2011-12:
25.4m 12.3p 9.2r 1.1a 0.8s 4.6b = 28.0+ 3.9mfg 1.2mft 2.3to 4.5pf = 11.9- = 16.1np 7.2oe 8.9fg

Melo greatly reduced his fouls so he played many more minutes, (even if he never became a 35 minute guy). He got more shots off and his scoring went up but I don't recall him ever becoming a post-up type scorer. His rebounding improved but was still short of what Chukwu did at Providence. Melo's blocked shots dramatically increased and were well ahead of Chukwu's rate. That, like the reduced fouls, would be a product of learning where where he has to be on defense, although it's interesting that his steals went down. What is not shown is all the charges Melo took, which delighted JB. I don't really like a center taking charges because if he doesn't get the call, he's taken himself out of the play with the flow, (and Melo learned to flop from soccer). But he always seemed to get the call. He did reduce his turnovers, even thought he was getting the ball more. Melo improved his free throw shooting from 36% in 2011 to 63% in 2012.

Chukwu will have had a year practicing with the team and already had his first year at this level against Providence. Like Melo, he'll have some talented athletes around him. It's not obvious that he'll be able to do what Melo did in 2012 or that we will be that good next year, but it certainly seems possible.
 
Last edited:
I've been intrigued by this comparison, as well. And I'm hoping Chukwu will weaken (locally) the bizarre modern proliferation of that assignment of the "we don't need him to score" to those built precisely to do just that. These guys can touch a rim even without standing on their toes.

But we are excusing them from having to score.

I demand every 7 footer average 20 and 20 a night. And if he doesn't slam it from within 5 feet every time, he gets kicked off the team (in my dreams as a coach, my recruiting dept. has already sent a memo/warning about that to any future son of Craig Forth who might sniff a scholly on the hill). Or skyhook that mother out to an open guard, like Fab often did.

I recall that one year where Fab and Rick Jackson were both in the top 5 in conference fg% for much of the season. A combined 67 to 70% for quite a stretch. Even a hot Giddy Potts can't overcome that.
 
What doesn't show is the cast of characters feeding the post. I expect Chukwu to be better than Melo in every area except blocks.
 
I don't expect Chukwu to be as good as Melo . . . if he is then we might very well be the best team in the country.

I do expect Chukwu to be one of the best shot blockers in the ACC and to be a disruptive defensive force.

If he can do that Syracuse should be very very good next year.
 
Chukwu isn't as good a basketball player as Melo.

I'd be interested in your comparison of the two. What do you see as Chukwu's strengths and weaknesses?
 
What doesn't show is the cast of characters feeding the post. I expect Chukwu to be better than Melo in every area except blocks.

Those are lofty expectations. If it's not clear who the most valuable player on that team was I don't know what to tell you.
 
Talking about next year's team is suddenly almost worthy of the off-topic board but a friend asked me what to expect next year, (he never thinks we'll be any good, so I try to cheer him up). I was describing Chukwu to him and saying that I hoped he would have the impact in the middle of the Zone that Fab Melo did in 2012, when we had a 30-1 regular season with the only loss coming when he was suspended. The one team to beat us was Cincy in the BET when they went off from three. Then we lost to the Buckeye in the Big Dance without Melo and with a blizzard of referee whistles. We wound up with our best numerical record ever, (in terms of wins - losses), 34-3. I figure with a shot blocker like Chukwu in a zone surrounded by guards who are 6-5 and 6-6 and forwards who are 6-9 and 6-8, we might be able to play the kind of defense next year we did in 2012, (and maybe get out and run on offense as a result, as we did in 2012), and maybe get similar results.

Melo was listed as 7-0 244 on the roster that year. Chukwu is listed as 7-2 226 but I've read they are trying to get him up to 240. So Melo was stronger but Chukwu is taller, the tallest player we've ever had. I saw Obokoh standing next to him and the top of the 6-9 Obokoh's head seemed to be parallel with the bottom of Chukwu's chin. So we could be a very physically imposing team next year.

One thing I could not do for my friend is describe what Chukwu did in his one year at Providence, (he has potentially three years at SU so this could be quite an era).. So, naturally, I looked it up.

Chukwu played in all 34 of his team's games that year, a total of 335 minutes. He was 33 for 50 from the field, an astronomical 66% field goal percentage. obviously those were all dunks and lay-ups and mostly put-backs but we haven't been very good at dunks and lay-ups this year and an offensive rebound has often been a excuse for Coleman to put on a dribbling exhibition, so 66% looks pretty good to me. He shot 24 for 40 at the foul line, 60%. But we've seen worse. He had 83 rebounds, 5 assists, 9 steals and 23 blocks. He turned the ball over 19 times and committed 63 fouls. Here is his his line based on those numbers:

9.9m 10.7p 9.9r 0.6a 1.1s 2.7b = 25.0+ 2.0mfg 1.9mft 2.3to 7.5pf = 13.7- = 11.3np 6.8oe 4.5fg

I decide to compare that to both of Fab Melo's years here: his highly disappointing first year and his tremendous second year:

2010-11:
9.9m 9.4p 7.8r 1.0a 1.2s 3.1b = 22.5+ 2.7mfg 2.0mft 3.1to 7.3pf = 15.1- = 7.4np 4.7oe 2.7fg

Chukwu played exactly the same number of minutes. He scored and rebounded a little better. , didn't pass quite as well or block quite as many shots. He also didn't miss quite as many shot but neither big many shot the ball much. Melo had more turnovers. Neither guy could stay on the floor because they committed way to many fouls, always a sign of a player who, in JB's words, doesn't know where he has to be on defense.

2011-12:
25.4m 12.3p 9.2r 1.1a 0.8s 4.6b = 28.0+ 3.9mfg 1.2mft 2.3to 4.5pf = 11.9- = 16.1np 7.2oe 8.9fg

Melo greatly reduced his fouls so he played many more minutes, (even if he never became a 35 minute guy). He got more shots off and his scoring went up but I don't recall him ever becoming a post-up type scorer. His rebounding improved but was still short of what Chukwu did at Providence. Melo's blocked shots dramatically increased and were well ahead of Chukwu's rate. That, like the reduced fouls, would be a product of learning where where he has to be on defense, although it's interesting that his steals went down. What is not shown is all the charges Melo took, which delighted JB. I don't really like a center taking charges because if he doesn't get the call, he's taken himself out of the play with the flow, (and Melo learned to flop from soccer). But he always seemed to get the call. He did reduce his turnovers, even thought he was getting the ball more. Melo improved his free throw shooting from 36% in 2011 to 63% in 2012.

Chukwu will have had a year practicing with the team and already had his first year at this level against Providence. Like Melo, he'll have some talented athletes around him. It's not obvious that he'll be able to do what Melo did in 2012 or that we will be that good next year, but it certainly seems possible.

What about academics?
 
I don't expect Chukwu to be as good as Melo . . . if he is then we might very well be the best team in the country.

I do expect Chukwu to be one of the best shot blockers in the ACC and to be a disruptive defensive force.

If he can do that Syracuse should be very very good next year.

He has a very well proportioned body for someone 7'2". A year is a long time. He may surprise us to the up side.
 
To paraphrase an early 90's song that got stuck in my head for some reason, "Chuck wu! no he aint got nuttin to prove!". I think that speaks to some of what I've read about the guy, and it might be my next parody built upon board expectations for the big lad. I expect maybe 5 people to remember the song. Maybe Tee, maybe not!

Bees, do you not think Chuckwu is at least capable of pulling a senior season Rak on offense, once he reaches senior season?
 
I don't expect Chukwu to be as good as Melo . . . if he is then we might very well be the best team in the country.

I do expect Chukwu to be one of the best shot blockers in the ACC and to be a disruptive defensive force.

If he can do that Syracuse should be very very good next year.

Chukwu is coming off a minimal Frosh year and a year of sitting out.
(of course, he's practicing, but zero game experience)

He's much more raw offensively than Fab, who actually had some skills, and even flashed a jumper on occasion.

It's probably better to think of him as a taller Baye Keita, than a skinnier Fab Melo.

Fab's Soph #'s, which made him the Big East DPOY, were (rounded off/up): 8, 6, & 3.

Baye's #'s for Soph - Sr years, (approximately, mostly rounded UP) were: 3, 4, and 1.

While the presence of a tall, athletic rim protector will be a big benefit (beyond the individual stats) for our D, and something we were sorely lacking this year - keep in mind what the actual #'s are probably going to look like.
 
i'll take another mooseman over supersize goofy any day.

open-uri20150422-20810-1eqn5zt_68a0ef78.jpeg
 
Chukwu has an advantage that he can really run the floor. Fab could not get up and down the floor his freshmen year. I hope he can keep his blocks in play. Fab was good at starting the break with his blocks.
 
Chukwu is coming off a minimal Frosh year and a year of sitting out.
(of course, he's practicing, but zero game experience)

He's much more raw offensively than Fab, who actually had some skills, and even flashed a jumper on occasion.

It's probably better to think of him as a taller Baye Keita, than a skinnier Fab Melo.

Fab's Soph #'s, which made him the Big East DPOY, were (rounded off/up): 8, 6, & 3.

Baye's #'s for Soph - Sr years, (approximately, mostly rounded UP) were: 3, 4, and 1.

While the presence of a tall, athletic rim protector will be a big benefit (beyond the individual stats) for our D, and something we were sorely lacking this year - keep in mind what the actual #'s are probably going to look like.


My numbers were 'real' numbers, too, figured per 40 minutes of play. Chukwu scored more points per 40 minutes as a freshmen, (10.7) than Melo did ((9.4) but not as much as Melo did as a sophomore (12.3). I can't say how he got those points but he got them. How much he'll score as a sophomore, I don't know but with a year to work on it, I would think he might improve his freshmen scoring,as Melo did, unless we're getting so much scoring from elsewhere we don't need him to score.
 
My numbers were 'real' numbers, too, figured per 40 minutes of play. Chukwu scored more points per 40 minutes as a freshmen, (10.7) than Melo did ((9.4) but not as much as Melo did as a sophomore (12.3). I can't say how he got those points but he got them. How much he'll score as a sophomore, I don't know but with a year to work on it, I would think he might improve his freshmen scoring,as Melo did, unless we're getting so much scoring from elsewhere we don't need him to score.


He will be a big time player for us
 
My numbers were 'real' numbers, too, figured per 40 minutes of play. Chukwu scored more points per 40 minutes as a freshmen, (10.7) than Melo did ((9.4) but not as much as Melo did as a sophomore (12.3). I can't say how he got those points but he got them. How much he'll score as a sophomore, I don't know but with a year to work on it, I would think he might improve his freshmen scoring,as Melo did, unless we're getting so much scoring from elsewhere we don't need him to score.

We need to compare freshmen year GPAs. If a player is going to sink the program with bad academics he's not worth it.
 
He will be a big time player for us

Somebody with more time and motivation than me, can probably find a highlight of Dashonte Riley doing something similar.
Just saying.

here you go:

Heck, I bet there are some sweet highlights somewhere of Chino doing impressive-looking things.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
170,443
Messages
4,891,513
Members
5,998
Latest member
powdersmack

Online statistics

Members online
246
Guests online
1,593
Total visitors
1,839


...
Top Bottom