I think the issue is there are a number of posters who think Gerry deserves the job based on taking Duke to the wire in one game and winning his conference tournament. Making the hire based on one game, or a week of games, is crazy. But to debate those people you have to present arguments against Gerry.
To me it's clear: the arguments are against Gerry right now. It's too soon. I think he's done a good job at Siena so far, and I think he's going to be a very good coach, but his best chance at success at Syracuse is not right now it's in the future. Maybe the job is open then, maybe not.