Tom Brady in SB winning seasons - Fred Coleman, Deion Branch, David Givens, Troy Brown, Daniel Graham, Christian Fauria and the running back was Antowain Smith.
IMO, the best comp, while we seem to sort of be on the subject, for McNabb is Big Ben. Both are big guys who aren't in the best of shape. Both can hurt you with their feet by not only running for a first down on occasion, but in terms of extending plays inside and out of the pocket. Each can play ugly at times and neither is perfect, but both seem to do much more winning than losing (McNabb a career .610 winning percentage; Big Ben at about .70 -- those numbers a bit more even if you lop of the DC season for McNabb as well as the first season in the league).
Roethlisberger's probably a bit better as a passer, McNabb the superior runner. Big Ben a career 92.3 rating, McNabb at 85.6, but that number is weighed down a bit by McNabb's early years when he was less refined and more of a threat with his legs.
The main difference is Big Ben's two Super Bowl wins. But this is where franchise and system come in, IMO. I respect Reid, but the Steelers are an exceedingly well-run operation. Big Ben has two rings but his two games look like this:
XL -- 9-21, 123 yards, 0 TDs 2 INTs
XLIII -- 21-30, 256, 1 TDs, 1 INT
Obviously XLIII was a solid game, but it was hardly great (Warner, by contrast, was 31-43, 377, 3 TDs, 1 INT). The first game was God awful.
