Class of 2025 - DE Quante Gillians (NY) COMMITTED TO SYRACUSE (6/16/24) | Page 8 | Syracusefan.com

Class of 2025 DE Quante Gillians (NY) COMMITTED TO SYRACUSE (6/16/24)

Been a Cuse fan all my life but I’ve always held Michigan in high regards. If I had a choice as a prospect I would have chosen Michigan over SU. They are that big of a program. It’s easier for the kids to choose the bigger offer now. They know they can always come back home if it doesn’t work out.
Not so fast my friend:) I hear you but all things being equal I think that early playing time is important. I listen to Carmelo's kid and others across both football and Bball and the smart ones or maybe the fortunate ones who don't have to decide based just on money are looking for a fit. Playing time and the proper use of their skills. That obviously doesn't mean that Michigan doesn't have all of that but i think that Fran has more than we think at his disposal. Also, unless a kid is truly academically committed the degree matters but not to the extent that Michigan trumps SU. In fact, I would say having alumni in your hometown and back yard trumps almost everything. Bottom line who knows but if any staff can compete with Michigan and the other blue bloods it's this one.
 
Stop being a jackass and maybe people will want to seriously engage with you.
Emotion. I like it. Bring more of it to the board. Sorry you almost got me. I simply don't care about you or your post. What ever.
 
Been a Cuse fan all my life but I’ve always held Michigan in high regards. If I had a choice as a prospect I would have chosen Michigan over SU. They are that big of a program. It’s easier for the kids to choose the bigger offer now. They know they can always come back home if it doesn’t work out.
Think that was the old su thought process. Under Fran not sure he would be willing to take a player that decommitted.
 
Not so fast my friend:) I hear you but all things being equal I think that early playing time is important. I listen to Carmelo's kid and others across both football and Bball and the smart ones or maybe the fortunate ones who don't have to decide based just on money are looking for a fit. Playing time and the proper use of their skills. That obviously doesn't mean that Michigan doesn't have all of that but i think that Fran has more than we think at his disposal. Also, unless a kid is truly academically committed the degree matters but not to the extent that Michigan trumps SU. In fact, I would say having alumni in your hometown and back yard trumps almost everything. Bottom line who knows but if any staff can compete with Michigan and the other blue bloods it's this one.
If it was Michigan with Hardbaugh and in the national title race, ok. But Moore looks in over his head and they look like they're heading for a rough patch.
 
Not so fast my friend:) I hear you but all things being equal I think that early playing time is important. I listen to Carmelo's kid and others across both football and Bball and the smart ones or maybe the fortunate ones who don't have to decide based just on money are looking for a fit. Playing time and the proper use of their skills. That obviously doesn't mean that Michigan doesn't have all of that but i think that Fran has more than we think at his disposal. Also, unless a kid is truly academically committed the degree matters but not to the extent that Michigan trumps SU. In fact, I would say having alumni in your hometown and back yard trumps almost everything. Bottom line who knows but if any staff can compete with Michigan and the other blue bloods it's this one.
You are trying to come up with reasons why a kid should choose SU over Michigan and Im providing thoughts based on how 17 year olds think these days. ( Not as a SU fan). I have talks with them about recruitment on a regular basis.
 
In the old days, Michigan had their way w/SU recruits. They successfully recruited JJ Grant, Mike Hart and Jaimie Morris over us. Don’t know if the dynamic has changed.
There was one guy early in Babers tenure we got from NJ over Mich. what was his name? DL, injured, never panned out.
 
Yeah that's it. The old false extreme extension. All I'm asking is to feel something, anything related some minimal level of angst. The least amount of some feeling related to losing. I am such a fan of Syracuse Football I feel emotion related to every little thing. I know your going to mis interpret that into some extreme emotion. I truly don't quite understand when fans feel absolutely nothing when a great recruit de commits. Not some extreme emotion but some small appropriate hint of something related to losing a terrific recruit.
Nothing is good or bad until thinking makes it so. (Paraphrasing).
Folks whose lives are emotionally impacted by decisions of teenagers which have no impact on their own lives are a fascinating lot.
 
You are trying to come up with reasons why a kid should choose SU over Michigan and Im providing thoughts based on how 17 year olds think these days. ( Not as a SU fan). I have talks with them about recruitment on a regular basis.
I thought your post was about the fact that you would have chosen Michigan as a 17 year old. I didn't realize you had spoken to him.
 
In the old days, Michigan had their way w/SU recruits. They successfully recruited JJ Grant, Mike Hart and Jaimie Morris over us. Don’t know if the dynamic has changed.
There was one guy early in Babers tenure we got from NJ over Mich. what was his name? DL, injured, never panned out.
Not sure on the NJ kid but Terry Lockett had a Michigan offer and Iffy was recruited heavily by Michigan at the end. Harbaugh flew in personally to one of Iffy's basketball games like a week before signing day to try and flip him.
 
I thought your post was about the fact that you would have chosen Michigan as a 17 year old. I didn't realize you had spoken to him.
You mentioned Fran so I assumed you were referring to today's prospects. I was sharing my mindset as 17 year old in the early 90's
 
Last edited:
That was us and wisconsin. Shafer and crew got stuck at his house in a snow storm. Too bad the kid had bad injuries.
Unfortunately, this seems to be the status quo for any "big" recruiting win we've happened to have over the last decade+
 
Nobody is a bigger fan of Syracuse University sports than I am -- but let's be honest. Michigan is a much higher profile football program than ours, and a much better academic institution, overall.

Or course, there might be alternative reasons why a kid might opt to come to SU instead of there -- maybe they want to be closer to home, or have the opportunity to play in front of friends / family more easily, or maybe there's a quicker path to playing time, etc.

But it isn't difficult to envision how a high profile recruit -- and these types of prospects generally have a high level of confidence in their abilities -- might be swayed by a Michigan offer. Even with their struggles this season.
 
Nobody is a bigger fan of Syracuse University sports than I am -- but let's be honest. Michigan is a much higher profile football program than ours, and a much better academic institution, overall.

Or course, there might be alternative reasons why a kid might opt to come to SU instead of there -- maybe they want to be closer to home, or have the opportunity to play in front of friends / family more easily, or maybe there's a quicker path to playing time, etc.

But it isn't difficult to envision how a high profile recruit -- and these types of prospects generally have a high level of confidence in their abilities -- might be swayed by a Michigan offer. Even with their struggles this season.
Thanks for taking off your orange shades for a second.
 
Nobody is a bigger fan of Syracuse University sports than I am -- but let's be honest. Michigan is a much higher profile football program than ours, and a much better academic institution, overall.

Or course, there might be alternative reasons why a kid might opt to come to SU instead of there -- maybe they want to be closer to home, or have the opportunity to play in front of friends / family more easily, or maybe there's a quicker path to playing time, etc.

But it isn't difficult to envision how a high profile recruit -- and these types of prospects generally have a high level of confidence in their abilities -- might be swayed by a Michigan offer. Even with their struggles this season.
The second part of that is unfortunate but valid.

The first part, I will never take my orange-colored glasses off for. Punk Michigan, and everyone else in the football universe.
 
The second part of that is unfortunate but valid.

The first part, I will never take my orange-colored glasses off for. Punk Michigan, and everyone else in the football universe.

I agree -- loathe Michigan and their stupid, insipid fanbase -- but it doesn't make it any less true.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
170,213
Messages
4,877,745
Members
5,990
Latest member
su4life25

Online statistics

Members online
220
Guests online
1,276
Total visitors
1,496


...
Top Bottom