3-5-5 was voted down by the SEC and B1G in the hope it would make the ACC implode and they could pick over the bones. With the announcement that the network will happen and the ACC is here to stay, maybe they'd be a bit more amenable to a rule change that will allow 3-5-5. If they don't, if I were ACC Commish, I would recommend to the membership that we go to rotating divisions. 4 teams are permanently assigned to the Atlantic and Coastal divisions and the VA and NC schools change divisions every 2 years. Every school would get at least 1 home-and-home with every other school every 6 years instead of the 12 it takes now.
It still causes problems. Keep the Florida schools separate and make 4 pods of three teams. Then rotate the pods.
FSU is always in the Atlantic
Miami is always in the Coastal
North: SU, BC, Louisville
South: Clemson, NC State, Wake
East: UVA, UNC, Duke
West: GA Tech, VA Tech, Pitt
Year 1
Atlantic: FSU, North, South
Coastal: Miami, East, West
Year 2
Atlantic: FSU, North, East
Coastal: Miami, South, West
Year 3
Atlantic: FSU, North, West
Coastal: Miami, South, East
Year 4
Atlantic: FSU, East, West
Coastal: Miami, North, South
Year 5
Atlantic: FSU, South, West
Coastal: Miami, North, East
Year 6
Atlantic: FSU, South, East
Coastal: Miami, North, West
So for UVA this is your schedule:
Year 1/4: Miami/FSU, UNC, Duke, GA Tech, VA Tech, Pitt, plus 2 of the Atlantic/Coastal teams
Year 2/5: FSU/Miami, UNC, Duke, SU, BC, Louisville, VA Tech, plus 1 of the Coastal/Atlantic teams
Year 3/6: Miami/FSU, UNC, Duke, Clemson, NC State, Wake, VA Tech, plus 1 of the Atlantic/Coastal teams
Which over a 6 year period comes out to:
6 games vs UNC, Duke, VA Tech
At least 3 games vs FSU, Miami
At least 2 games vs GA Tech, Pitt, SU, BC, Louisville, Clemson, NC State, Wake
Plus 8 extra games vs teams from the 2/3 game groups
For SU:
6 games vs BC, Louisville, Pitt
At least 3 games vs FSU, Miami
At least 2 games vs UVA, UNC, Duke, GA Tech, VA Tech, Clemson, NC State, Wake
Plus 8 extra games vs teams from the 2/3 game groups
So we are playing BC, Louisville, Pitt the same amount of times as the current set up. At worst we lose 3 games vs FSU but get Miami at least 2 more times. We get at least one more game vs UVA, UNC, Duke, GA Tech, VA Tech. At worst we lose 4 games vs Clemson, NC State, Wake. But again those extra 8 games not set in stone can be used to up the amount of times we play each team.
Going with this setup gets you through the entire conference in 3 years vs the 6 years under the current set up. You don't lose a single annual must play game.