General20
Basketball Maven
- Joined
- Aug 28, 2011
- Messages
- 1,774
- Like
- 12,035
If that happens at some point in the future (and it's a long way off), then what? One of the coaches in the new organization (P5?) will break THE NEW RULES, and it'll 'force' another school(s) to break the rules to compete ... and it'll snowball until we'll be back to the same problem we have now. People break rules whenever high stakes and money are involved. I don't have a problem with a member organization like the NCAA .. where every school has an incentive to make it work and weed out/punish the bad apples.
Glad someone posted this. Makes Fab's footnote investigation seem pretty silly.
I totally agree with you. The real problem with the NCAA is that they represent small schools who actually want amateur athletics as well as big schools who make tens of millions off this business. It is impossible to do what is best for both, they are too fundamentally different, so it is literally impossible for the NCAA to succeed at what they are trying to do.
We need a new version of the NCAA exists just to police the big schools who want to make a big business out of this. That's what I want to see happen, and more importantly, I want rules that make sense for those schools. Sure some schools will break them, but then we will all know those schools are wrong and they should be punished. It would be very different than it is now where you have to break the rules in order to compete.
Also policing 60-70 big schools who are all playing by the same rules is a more easily accomplished job than policing many hundreds of schools all at different levels with different rules.