Luke Carney
- Thread starter Ttk.gman2
- Start date
If Luke is going to redshirt he won't be playing Friday night. The reason is if he were to play , and play well , and win the game. Then Fran would have to make him the starter. So if anyone else plays besides Rickie it has to be Belin , or Filardi.
FloridaCuse
All Conference
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2023
- Messages
- 3,123
- Like
- 5,229
How excited are you?
RyanCuse44
All Conference
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2019
- Messages
- 2,451
- Like
- 5,701
SuFTW
All Conference
- Joined
- May 13, 2020
- Messages
- 3,164
- Like
- 5,701
If Carney plays well and starts the rest of the season he likely would be happy to give up the redshirt.
GoSU96
Living Legend
- Joined
- Aug 17, 2011
- Messages
- 23,629
- Like
- 48,740
Screw the redshirt. Four games left to get game reps. Four preseason games for next season.
Cusefan78
Negative Nancy
- Joined
- Aug 30, 2011
- Messages
- 2,082
- Like
- 4,395
Have to assume qb2 will have to start tye first few weeks next year also. Keep hearing it’s a solid year to rehab an Achilles. .
Moontan
2017 ESPN College Bowl Pick’em Winner
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2011
- Messages
- 10,711
- Like
- 11,141
"Rickie Connis"... who dat?
DocFlanders
All Conference
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 2,538
- Like
- 4,298
He can redshirt next year if Angeli comes back and crushes it
Archbold44
2nd String
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2025
- Messages
- 716
- Like
- 1,508
Who knows? Other people not starting include Ricardo Collins, Colin Richards, and Dick Collinsworth.
OrangeXtreme
The Mayor of Dewitt
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2011
- Messages
- 250,371
- Like
- 467,502
Connie Lingus?
FloridaCuse
All Conference
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2023
- Messages
- 3,123
- Like
- 5,229
Brent Axe article Saturday morning is "Why Is Fran Brown Putting a Quarterback on the Field He Doesn't Trust to Throw the Ball?" He ends the article with this remarkable statement:
"We can no longer trust the word of Brown and his coaching staff on the supposed limits of Carney’s throwing ability or knowledge of the playbook based on practice footage only they get to see.
"We need to see it for ourselves with real football bullets flying.
"For better or worse, let Luke throw the football.
"What do you have to lose at this point?"
www.syracuse.com
"We can no longer trust the word of Brown and his coaching staff on the supposed limits of Carney’s throwing ability or knowledge of the playbook based on practice footage only they get to see.
"We need to see it for ourselves with real football bullets flying.
"For better or worse, let Luke throw the football.
"What do you have to lose at this point?"
Axe: Why is Fran Brown putting a quarterback on the field he doesn’t trust to throw the ball?
Luke Carney has just three pass attempts as a Syracuse quarterback.
Brent Axe article Saturday morning is "Why Is Fran Brown Putting a Quarterback on the Field He Doesn't Trust to Throw the Ball?" He ends the article with this remarkable statement:
"We can no longer trust the word of Brown and his coaching staff on the supposed limits of Carney’s throwing ability or knowledge of the playbook based on practice footage only they get to see.
"We need to see it for ourselves with real football bullets flying.
"For better or worse, let Luke throw the football.
"What do you have to lose at this point"
Luke Carney has just three pass attempts as a Syracuse quarterback.
Brent Axe Is a literal shark without an ounce of moral integrity, In my opinion foul is his middle name. He pales in comparison to Let's say Mike Waters who is objective but honestly cares and realizes the specific population that carries a specific weight no matter the time we live in. He is chum, BA and is reflective of current degradation of society, consistent with his slice and focus that being college sports. He is a Poisonous, non objective thermometer who reports found extremes while looking for weakness and exposing. He is not a journalist of old, 30 years ago he would have been forced out from a journalistic integrity standpoint. Let alone moral station most importantly.
"We can no longer trust the word of Brown and his coaching staff on the supposed limits of Carney’s throwing ability or knowledge of the playbook based on practice footage only they get to see.
"We need to see it for ourselves with real football bullets flying.
"For better or worse, let Luke throw the football.
"What do you have to lose at this point"
Luke Carney has just three pass attempts as a Syracuse quarterback.
Brent Axe Is a literal shark without an ounce of moral integrity, In my opinion foul is his middle name. He pales in comparison to Let's say Mike Waters who is objective but honestly cares and realizes the specific population that carries a specific weight no matter the time we live in. He is chum, BA and is reflective of current degradation of society, consistent with his slice and focus that being college sports. He is a Poisonous, non objective thermometer who reports found extremes while looking for weakness and exposing. He is not a journalist of old, 30 years ago he would have been forced out from a journalistic integrity standpoint. Let alone moral station most importantly.
Last edited:
OttoinGrotto
2023-24 Iggy Award Most 3 Pointers Made
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 70,096
- Like
- 217,041
You're kind of beating around the bush, how do you really feel?
newmexicuse
All Conference
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2011
- Messages
- 3,849
- Like
- 8,681
Carney did not look ready in his brief cameos, but that being said, it seems everybody else has been given an extended look - why not Luke ?
At this point, I would start Luke and if nothing good happens, may as well just let Rikki run out the season.
The QB room is a monstrous sized disaster.
Going into this season, I did not believe that 10 wins was repeatable, but I was optimistic we would win 6 or 7 and make a bowl. Now it seems the upside is 4 wins and even that may not be attainable.
We cannot even assume that Angeli will be ready for the beginning of next season. Getting a starting caliber portal QB is essential.
At this point, I would start Luke and if nothing good happens, may as well just let Rikki run out the season.
The QB room is a monstrous sized disaster.
Going into this season, I did not believe that 10 wins was repeatable, but I was optimistic we would win 6 or 7 and make a bowl. Now it seems the upside is 4 wins and even that may not be attainable.
We cannot even assume that Angeli will be ready for the beginning of next season. Getting a starting caliber portal QB is essential.
Ernj
2nd String
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 909
- Like
- 2,029
So that he can have 4 years when he transfers.
Why does everyone assume he’s going to transfer? And which Power 4 schools would even want Carney on their team—he’s undersized. I get that Fran mismanaged his freshman year, but he is getting opportunities to play now. What other school is giving him chances like that?
I have zero clue what any of this means……but I agree with every syllable.
OburgOrange
Living Legend
- Joined
- Aug 27, 2011
- Messages
- 22,998
- Like
- 71,011
This. I wonder which school his dad wants him to go to?
VTAaron
Hofmann Smuggling Expert
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2021
- Messages
- 1,234
- Like
- 1,135
Coaches haven't even let him throw a ball, so how do we know? Instead let him pass a Williis ball up a failing middle every time. We know that doesn't work period. He at least doesn't have any interceptions for all his game time. We can't judge him or Collins at this point as I assume there all good QB's with the right play calling and coaching staff. Right now I blame it on the OC and unable to adapt with a loss of a 'star' QB. If this is a measure of a team the QB we got some long hard heartaches to come if we can't have a coach adapt to new players or work on that as a contigency.
Similar threads
