The entire use of Carney makes no sense. It’s the reason people are questioning Fran. I could see him thrown in on the road against Miami that just lost and will be super motivated. I think even if he plays would be concerned with the play calling.
I honestly think he caved as others have stated what he stated two plus weeks ago was that Ricky was the best of the choices, I believe he was desperate and as he stated he wanted to see if he could get a Spark. Do I think Luke was given enough time probably not, however once again he probably knew what we did not. And by the way that is totally on Fran, however the Sharks were calling for a change a long time ago, started comparing him to the Pittsburgh quarterback you at least need to give it a shot right? That includes many on the board, and certainly the Moron BA with his newbie disciple JE Who were circling a long time ago and so many others. He could have handled the situation much better, coach Fran Brown, however he was trying and did not have any other options. My hope is he puts RC back in, and see where we go. I believe that will help all parties involved including the S, as well as RC good bad or indifferent. I do want to remind the shark idiots about CDWR and what they stated about him literally inhumane for a 20 year old in reference to physiologic traits. I Trust in the future coach Fran Brown will not cater to shark idiots and trust his gut. If this was not the case so be it and move on, make the best of it. And I do believe he is learning for sure. The old Sack Mac pack, but that turned out real well. I was just barely around at that time chronologically but I heard lots of great things about that man. I did however get to see really good, fun football as a result of that. This guy talks a lot like him I trust
Have to disagree, Fran was completely wrong on Rickie twice, now playing Filardi shows he is playing games to try to prove a point. There is no possible way you could look at 3 games results and continue to play Rickie. You also don't have someone listed as your backup for 4 games in a row if they aren't the next best option, unless you are lying. And twice you put Carney in games.
No he legitimately sucks
That's not what you said. You said based on what you had seen of Carney you weren't questioning the coaches. I'm irrelevant. Don't try to use my idiocy as a defense.
Appreciate your feedback, when you attack people with limited insight into specific situations and certainly limitations without significant insight it becomes personal concerning him. I stand by what I stated because that is my experience with this individual and I feel he is an opportunistic snake with a propensity towards gluttony and propagation of ill informed antagonistic rhetoric that is certainly untrue on so many occasions. Please do not turn a player or coaches performance Into a literacy discussion and certainly correlate it with moral competency in a very degrading way. He is an opportunistic bully with a pen. His reporting is the equivalent of an unciteable source with zero credibility unless he has slithered into the ignorant arms of a valid source without knowing his character. He is trash with no decorum. I will definitely stand for what is right when you attack good kind people long before these discussions on multiple occasions. I pray for him however why would I like a snake. Grace brent
None of it makes sense. People do not like the speculation... but random/idiotic decisions invite speculation. We literally just witnessed a coaching staff decide that the guy that was #3/#2 for 9 weeks... should be displaced for someone not on scholarship. And then he gets all but one drive in the full game.
It's maddening.
It's either a strange decision, or we have to believe that up until the very point that Fran reopened the QB competition that Carney had shown more, and had more investment in practice priority in the program up until then, at which point Filardi suddenly overtook him and appeared to realize his potential at just the right time.
Not to go all caps on you... but THE DEPTH CHART ON OCTOBER 27 DID NOT HAVE FILARDI AT ALL. On Monday, the starting QB for Friday was not on the agenda. That absolutely makes it a random idiotic decision. How many snaps has Filardi taken in practice running our offense with the starters??
Angeli>Collins>Carney in terms of PT all year through 9 games. In Game 10, we elevate a kid who has not gotten any meaningful PT with the #1 offense to starter. If he WAS getting snaps in recent weeks, it was at the expense of Collins/Carney. If he WAS NOT getting snaps in recent weeks, he could not have been ready for UNC.
We actually did it twice because both Carney and Williams were hurdled.
So, there is movie precedent at least.
I don't disagree with you at all on this. I just understand why he wanted him removed. There's, I'm sure, hundreds of other coaches that feel the same way about local hacks.
That's why I keep saying that it seems like no matter what the explanation is as to why Carney's playing time has been so weird, someone comes out of it looking bad. Either Carney himself because he hasn't gotten ready or has made himself unplayable (but not completely unplayable, because he's on the depth chart and has gotten some snaps?), or the coaches because they've made some nonsensical, mind bottling decisions.
