I agree with you about Scoop being underrated but it's just not true that JJ's freshamn year stats are worse than Scoop and Triches freshman year stats.
Scoop averaged 5.5 ppg and 2.5 assists on 47% shooting and 28% from 3.
Triche averaged 8.1 ppg and 2.8 assists on 50% shooting and 40% from 3.
Starling averaged 11.3 ppg and 1.1 assists on 42% shooting and 30% from 3.
You could argue that maybe Triche had a better freshman year because he was more efficient, but Triche's efficiency didnt translate to any other year of his career and Starlings freshman efficiency closely resembles Triches career efficiency. And Starling averaged more ppg ad a freshman than either Triche or Scoop averaged for their career. If either Triche or Scoop were asked to take on the usage Starling did as a freshman, their efficiency would have been lower than his, probably considerably so. And that doesn't factor in that Starling was playing through a shoulder injury.
I think Starling has the potential to lead the ACC in scoring.