OK, What are the Best Restaurants in Syracuse these Days?

Trueblue25

Great Dungey’s Kneecap
Joined
Apr 16, 2013
Messages
19,395
Likes
27,059
I hate paying for italian. It's noodles and sauce. That said, Nick and Angelo's in Liverpool and Tassone's in Baldwinsville are pretty good.
I usually order steak, scampi or egg plant parm depending on whats offered


Love good calamari or caprese to start
 

Forza Azzurri

All Conference
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
2,850
Likes
4,964
I usually order steak, scampi or egg plant parm depending on whats offered


Love good calamari or caprese to start
Tougher to find good calamari these days. You have to salt it right out of the oil and the health kick means that restaurants are either using less salt or even no salt.
 
Joined
Mar 25, 2013
Messages
1,091
Likes
1,062
Tougher to find good calamari these days. You have to salt it right out of the oil and the health kick means that restaurants are either using less salt or even no salt.
No, the problem is fried calamari can turn from good to bad in a matter of moments depending on how long it is in the oil. Cooking squid any style, needs careful attention or it will overcook in no time.
 

Forza Azzurri

All Conference
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
2,850
Likes
4,964
No, the problem is fried calamari can turn from good to bad in a matter of moments depending on how long it is in the oil. Cooking squid any style, needs careful attention or it will overcook in no time.
yeah, agreed on that..there is a small window when it is cooked correctly...

But I find over/undercooking to be less of a problem than the salting issue...

So many times, it gets delivered to the table and the color is right and the texture is right but there is not enough flavor because there is either no salt or not enough salt. And you cannot salt it at the table. Too late.
 

patcuse

Scout Team
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
291
Likes
425
I hate paying for italian. It's noodles and sauce. That said, Nick and Angelo's in Liverpool and Tassone's in Baldwinsville are pretty good.
Im with you Capt would never order pasta and sauce out. No bang for the buck. Not allowed to call it sauce In my house it’s gravy.
 

Millhouse

Living Legend
Joined
Aug 16, 2011
Messages
24,455
Likes
22,930
Carrraba's is a chain restaurant owned by the same company that owns outback steakhouse, LOL!

It's halfway decent for a boil-in-the bag chain restaurant, but it's no scratch italian place by any means.

I heard Vito's (the old Rico's) re-opened under new management and kept the same menu as the old place. Rico's used to be good for Italian. Haven't been to Vito's since the re-opening but seems to have good reviews: Google Maps
if boil in bag refers to sous vide, i'm a big proponent of it

it's worth buying one of those sticks just for steak. cook it perfect in the bag with salt, fire up a chimney starter, skewer the steak so it can sit over the over blazing chimey for a minute per side, slice over a some herbs and oil on the board. steakhouse quality, simple, perfect.

i'm done ordering steaks at restaurants now
 

Forza Azzurri

All Conference
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
2,850
Likes
4,964
Im with you Capt would never order pasta and sauce out. No bang for the buck. Not allowed to call it sauce In my house it’s gravy.
That is not true. Depends where you live and what the restaurants are like. My favorite little local Italian place flies its ingredients in weekly. The Cacio e Pepe or Bucatini all'Amatriciana (sorry, typo) is worth every penny...The mozz make me think I'm in Puglia or Campania...

There are some absolutely fabulous Italian restaurants in the city...

Gravy just means that either your ancestry is southern italian or you grew up surrounded by them...

Up north, it is sauce...

One other thing...I will completely concede that there are large swaths of the country where I would never consider going to an Italian restaurant unless it was a really special circumstance - like an Italian-born and educated chef who just really happened to love Des Moines or Toledo...
 
Last edited:

IthacaMatt

Living Legend
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
10,962
Likes
10,459
Guys...Carrarabas? Really?

The reason they can do a pretty good job is because they don't have a super-extensive menu. Fewer ingredients and fewer menu items mean that the ingredients stay fresher, and the staff is more likely to get the meal right.

You can say all you want about the "historic" Italian restaurants in Syracuse, but Pascale's family of restaurants, and the Grimaldi family restaurants are all in decline, if they haven't already closed.

If anyone wants to try to claim that Dominic's or Avicolli's on Route 57 are better than Carraba's in Fayetteville they're nuts.

Rico's closed. Gentile's closed. Francesca's lost their chef, Chance Bear, about 7 or 8 years ago. Asti's isn't bad on North Salina, and the wise guy place at 700 N Salina or so (I forget the name) also changed ownership and changed their name a few years ago.

I make better Italian food than most of these places. (I cooked at Dominic's back in the early 80s, after I got out of college, when it was still good.)
 

KellySyracuse

All American
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
5,138
Likes
8,312
So no one’s been to atillio’s on james st?
I've been there but it was at least 3 years ago. Atmosphere is nice, quite a few wannabee high rollers at the bar. Food was okay but not memorable enough for me to go back. Francesca's would be my go to place on Salina with Asti coming in 2nd

Edit: sorry I've been to the Attillios on Salina St. if you didn't already guess that. Haven't tried the James St. place yet
 

rrlbees

2017 ESPN Tourney Challenge Winner
Staff member
Joined
Aug 16, 2011
Messages
58,776
Likes
66,150
The reason they can do a pretty good job is because they don't have a super-extensive menu. Fewer ingredients and fewer menu items mean that the ingredients stay fresher, and the staff is more likely to get the meal right.

You can say all you want about the "historic" Italian restaurants in Syracuse, but Pascale's family of restaurants, and the Grimaldi family restaurants are all in decline, if they haven't already closed.

If anyone wants to try to claim that Dominic's or Avicolli's on Route 57 are better than Carraba's in Fayetteville they're nuts.

Rico's closed. Gentile's closed. Francesca's lost their chef, Chance Bear, about 7 or 8 years ago. Asti's isn't bad on North Salina, and the wise guy place at 700 N Salina or so (I forget the name) also changed ownership and changed their name a few years ago.

I make better Italian food than most of these places. (I cooked at Dominic's back in the early 80s, after I got out of college, when it was still good.)
I’ll say it. Avicollis is better than Carrabas.
 

IthacaMatt

Living Legend
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
10,962
Likes
10,459
I’ll say it. Avicollis is better than Carrabas.
Sorry, but no. Nothing at Avicolli's is as good as the pork loin wrapped in prosciutto with fig sauce, or the Tuscan grilled filet. The fried zucchini sticks (get them well done) are really good, too.
 

Cusefan0307

Here for the Cold Takes
Joined
Dec 21, 2011
Messages
17,715
Likes
31,469
Antonio's I believe is strictly takeout now and they have a few locations around the city.
 

rrlbees

2017 ESPN Tourney Challenge Winner
Staff member
Joined
Aug 16, 2011
Messages
58,776
Likes
66,150
Sorry, but no. Nothing at Avicolli's is as good as the pork loin wrapped in prosciutto with fig sauce, or the Tuscan grilled filet. The fried zucchini sticks (get them well done) are really good, too.
Go to Avicollis and start with their beans and greens (has sausage in it too). Then order your salad with Italian and crumbly blue and have a couple rolls dipped in their oils and spices. Then order the chicken riggies with red or pink sauce (I prefer red). Then tell me you didn’t go to heaven.
 

Cusesky8214

All Conference
Joined
Nov 16, 2016
Messages
2,513
Likes
6,958
Go to Avicollis and start with their beans and greens (has sausage in it too). Then order your salad with Italian and crumbly blue and have a couple rolls dipped in their oils and spices. Then order the chicken riggies with red or pink sauce (I prefer red). Then tell me you didn’t go to heaven.
Fantastic pizza and wings there too!
 

IthacaMatt

Living Legend
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
10,962
Likes
10,459
Go to Avicollis and start with their beans and greens (has sausage in it too). Then order your salad with Italian and crumbly blue and have a couple rolls dipped in their oils and spices. Then order the chicken riggies with red or pink sauce (I prefer red). Then tell me you didn’t go to heaven.

OK, fair enough. You have a much better chance at a good meal someplace when you have someone to recommend stuff off the menu.
 


Top Bottom