Class of 2023 QB Rickie Collins (LA) TRANSFERRING TO SYRACUSE (12/20/24)

[SUFaninNJ]

And Bill Scharr threw a better ball than Philcox, but got run off the team because he wasn't popular with the other players.

I always wondered what the story was with Scharr.

 

[Capt. Tuttle]

Glad the kid committed, not sure he is any better then JW only time will tell, little concerned this may put a nail
In the coffin for Kyle coming back, how many QBS can you possibly waste a scholarship on unless somebody is leaving or switching positions.

105 scholarships

 

[orangemass]

I’d certainly call committing to the same school two days in a row Relentless.

Post of the day

 

[SmilinBob]

I hear it's a 1 year deal with a player options for the 2nd and 3rd year.

 

[OrangeTarheel]

I lurk here daily, just not a huge poster

It’s all good man, tiny posters are just as good as huge ones

 

[kcsu]

Definitely not over Kyle McCord

Are you sure

 

[LeMoyneCuse]

I watched some of his Jr. year highlights on Hudl. The offense he played in is pretty big boy - he’s throwing from the pocket and into relatively tight windows. We can only hope this is something that he’s continued to improve on.

 

[kcsu]

I always wondered what the story was with Scharr.

He was an arse

 

[UpstateSM]

It’s all good man, tiny posters are just as good as huge ones

I've been told I'm an adequate poster. If I was any better at posting it would hurt.

 

[sufandu]

Do we know though? We saw what we had in 2023 and it was terrifying. We have no idea about JW. Johnson, who i don’t view highly at all, was the back up the entire season.

I think what's important is that we trust the coaches to know. As fans, we're never going to know how good a new guy is until we get to see him and in college sports there are always new guys. We had no way of knowing what we had prior to 1990 or 1995, but because of our success prior to those seasons we just trusted our coaches would anoint the right guy.

Ultimately, it's a bit of a crapshoot no matter who you are. We've seen factories march out elite rated QBs that fell on their faces.

 

[orange79]

I've been told I'm an adequate poster.

 

[Toga]

It’s all good man, tiny posters are just as good as huge ones

I mean I'm no Arnold Palmer or anything.

 

[DomeHolmes]

Phicox one year as a starter - 16 TDs, 11 interceptions, 188 yards a game on 60% completions. Like I said, part of a good team, but hardly an all-time great at Syracuse. Just like Danny Schayes had a long NBA career; that doesn't mean he was great at SU in his 1 year as a starter.

Taking the era into account, (2 wide outs, run heavy) these are solid numbers. If you look at Heisman runner up Mcphersons stats for JR/SR year combined, Philcox was much more accurate, and had about the same ypg and TD/INT ratio.

 

[LeMoyneCuse]

I think what's important is that we trust the coaches to know. As fans, we're never going to know how good a new guy is until we get to see him and in college sports there are always new guys. We had no way of knowing what we had prior to 1990 or 1995, but because of our success prior to those seasons we just trusted our coaches would anoint the right guy.

Ultimately, it's a bit of a crapshoot no matter who you are. We've seen factories march out elite rated QBs that fell on their faces.

This is one of my issues with how people view the transfer portal; as a means to always populate your roster with proven commodities. Yes, it’s helpful to jumpstart a coaching tenure and to fill gaping holes. But watching guys come in and develop and grow into the next guy is one of the joys of college football.

 

[PAcuse]

soooooo we all going to stop crapping on the journalism profession or are we too high on our horses?

pffft you expect waaay to much out of us

 

[RF2044]

3 years to play, right?

Awesome "get ." Apprentice under McCord for a year, then step in for multiple seasons

 

[Cappy3]

This is one of my issues with how people view the transfer portal; as a means to always populate your roster with proven commodities. Yes, it’s helpful to jumpstart a coaching tenure and to fill gaping holes. But watching guys come in and develop and grow into the next guy is one of the joys of college football.

If they stick around long enough.

 

[baggerbob]

If they stick around long enough.

That's why Fran is looking for measurables, speed, size, character to build a base from the ground up. That's why high school is important, in the northeast a lot of good athletes who can be coached up.
You need to create the depth so that the players who are 2nd team become plug and play.

 

[IthacaMatt]

The "journalism profession" has to start adhering to the established practices. The problem is, the true journalists are competing against the journos that just try to scoop everyone without recourse for jumping the gun.

Social media has destroyed journalism.
Come to think of it, the media has destroyed journalism.
And the Internet.

 

[David321]

NCAA as a whole did a couple years ago

But Fran didn't.

 

[GoSU96]

That's why Fran is looking for miserables speed, size, character to build a base from the ground up. That's why high school is important, in the northeast a lot of good athletes who can be coached up.
You need to create the depth so that the players who are 2nd team become plug and play.

If he”s looking for miserables this board is a good place to start

 

[IthacaMatt]

That year was great, it felt like we would take a step back, but Philcox kept us strong.

Yes, he was a game manager, and very good at it.
But he wasn't asked to carry that offense. He had Robert Drummond, Michael Owens and Daryl Johnston to run the ball. Rob Moore was the featured WR, and we also had Deval Glover and Pat Davis was a pretty good tight end.
We topped 30 points 6 times, while only giving up 17 points a game.

 

[UpstateSM]

But Fran didn't.

If Fran was testing and punishing players for cannabis use I don't think we would have enough players to fill a two deep every week lol

 

[baggerbob]

If he”s looking for miserables this board is a good place to start

Went back and corrected that, phone autocorrect is stupid.

 

[Roger N]

Fran made a point to say that trait that he’s looking for from a qb is “winner.” Can he feel confident on that point with a guy like Collins who hasn’t proven anything? I don’t have a pov, just trying to piece together what might actually happen.

The will to win. Dungy and Shrader had it and DeVito didn’t