I recall in the debate over Coach Pasqualoni in football that there seemed to be a split between those who were loyal to the coach and deflected any criticism of him and those who were loyal to the school and thought we could do better. I was in the latter group although i never got to the point of wanting him fired- i thought his record was too good to justify that. I favored changes in the staff. Instead a new AD came in fired him and brought in a guy recommended by a coach he knew from his old job. That was a disaster and we've spent years crawling out of the resulting hole.
There have been several times in JB's history when people have gotten impatient with him being the coach. One was in the late 90's, when recruiting had fallen off. one year our outstanding recruit was James Theus, a good defensive guard who couldn't shoot. Then there was the legendary Greg Davis. We got Ethan Cole to transfer here. JB made Mike Hopkins his lead recruiter and brought in Troy Weaver and we won the national championship a couple years later.
Then in the late 2000's, we had a series of disappointing years: two first round NCAA losses, (it would have been three in a row without GMAC going off on BYU in 2004), followed by two NIT years. I still remember
the trip home from the UMASS loss in the 2008 NIT, where we'd somehow blown a 24 point second ahlf lead to lose to the Minutemen for the second time that year in the Dome. I stayed away from the board for a week because the people who wanted Boeheim out were in command. Their arguments were exactly what we have been hearing now.
People like to break seasons up to turn them into streaks. We were 19-8 late in the 2008-9 season when we started playing the sort of fanatical defense that has keyed our best post season runs., (we beat St. John's by 29, Cincinnati by 24 and Rutgers by 30 while holding them to an average of 54 points). That keyed a 9-2 finish, including the 6OT game, which was the beginning of a 155-28 run through the 25-0 start of 2013-14. The biggest change during that time was the switch to 100% zone, which appeared to be a great idea.
In both the 1990's slump and the current one we were coming off a probation, which can have an impact for years after it's over. You don't want to do anything wrong again or get worse penalties. We've also had things happen like DaJuan tearing up his knee and Darius Bazley opting for the G league, as well as guys who were not quite blue chip talents opting for the NBA before they had maximized their skills.
It think the idea that JB could coach at 70 but not at 74 is a bunch of crap. We've made two strong NCAA runs and beaten Duke several times in this "bad" era. I'm more receptive to the idea that the current group of recruiters might not be the right guys. head coaches are always heavily dependent on their staffs to line up the right recruits for them to 'close'. Everybody loses some of them. Maybe we need another Troy Weaver on the staff. There's nothing wrong with this program that wouldn't be solved if we could just recruit at least a good college center and point guard.