George McDonald is absolutely terrible | Page 2 | Syracusefan.com

George McDonald is absolutely terrible

They were playing backups late in the game... I don't know much about ND's defense so I couldn't tell ya. All I know is people seem to overreact when we lose and overreact when we win... stay level-headed.
They noted during the broadcast how short handed Maryland was all game on d. I admit I am down on the program. It's been a hard slog for too many years now. Nova made me realize we are still stuck. Things like not being able to get a yard, fake fgs... Cmu was a mirage. We are seriously going to struggle this year.
 
I haven't watched a ton of ND but how are there backs and receivers compared to Maryland group? Goldson is good and better runner than brown. if they are similar to Marylands ill go 28 points since our d only gave up 24 today
And 7 of those 24 were because of the blocked punt which gave Maryland a short field.
 
They noted during the broadcast how short handed Maryland was all game on d. I admit I am down on the program. It's been a hard slog for too many years now. Nova made me realize we are still stuck. Things like not being able to get a yard, fake fgs... Cmu was a mirage. We are seriously going to struggle this year.
Three of our best WRs got banged up during the game. College football changes a ton by week it seems like so I'm not too worried.
 
I haven't watched a ton of ND but how are there backs and receivers compared to Maryland group? Goldson is good and better runner than brown. if they are similar to Marylands ill go 28 points since our d only gave up 24 today
Wrs are better. Rbs are far better. Golson is on another level than md qb. It's a nightmare matchup for us. He's elusive and when he looks to scramble the throws deep.
 
14 points were squandered. 7 on the holding call on Foy that wiped out Hunt's run and the pick 6 which came as a result of a stupid (and I do mean stupid) mistake by Hunt. Flemming would have been open on the double move for a TD.

So, that would have been 31-27 without the garbage time TD. Norton missed a chip shot accounting for another 3.

We had 2 turn overs and a blocked punt (just like a TO) and they had none.

The chart below shows how turnover margin correlates to winning percentage over the four seasons in college football (2009 - 2012). Each dot represents a team in that four-year period. Per-game turnover margin is on the X-axis and winning percentage is on the Y-axis:

upload_2014-9-20_18-25-14.png


We didn't lose this game on play calling, we lost it on D, execution / turn overs.
 
This was a very frustrating game to watch, but I think some people on this board are drinking koolaide if they think we have better offensive talent than Maryland. Our receivers put no fear into anyone. Everyone talks about how good Ismail is but I haven't seen anything from him that suggests he can beat people deep. He dropped a a ball on the five yard line after Broyd dropped a slant for an easy touchdown. The only guys who consistently catch balls in their area are West and Lewis and they don't scare anyone. Our backs are average. There were about four plays today where if we had an explosive back they would have long touchdown runs. They play and run hard, but don't have that extra step that can take it to the house. The 90 yard swing pass for a td today from Maryland today was all speed. I don't think we have a back on this team who could make that play. We still are a long way from having special talent on offense.
 
The offensive coordinator gets paid to put points in the board, not to roll up yardage between the 20s.

Sorry, but color me unpressed. 2nd and 25 bubble screens don't elicit my confidence. He needs help, he should seek assistance.

We fubared a great opportunity today.
 
hoopsupstate said:
This was a very frustrating game to watch, but I think some people on this board are drinking koolaide if they think we have better offensive talent than Maryland. Our receivers put no fear into anyone. Everyone talks about how good Ismail is but I haven't seen anything from him that suggests he can beat people deep. He dropped a a ball on the five yard line after Broyd dropped a slant for an easy touchdown. The only guys who consistently catch balls in their area are West and Lewis and they don't scare anyone. Our backs are average. There were about four plays today where if we had an explosive back they would have long touchdown runs. They play and run hard, but don't have that extra step that can take it to the house. The 90 yard swing pass for a td today from Maryland today was all speed. I don't think we have a back on this team who could make that play. We still are a long way from having special talent on offense.
It wasn't all speed. We were outnumbered. There was nothing to it. Total gift
 
I dont care about anything else if you cant catch the ball you cant play WR
 
Jake said:
The offensive coordinator gets paid to put points in the board, not to roll up yardage between the 20s. Sorry, but color me unpressed. 2nd and 25 bubble screens don't elicit my confidence. He needs help, he should seek assistance. We fubared a great opportunity today.
you selling?
 
Millhouse said:
It wasn't all speed. We were outnumbered. There was nothing to it. Total gift
buy yours too?!
 
There are times where we outnumber teams and we can't take it to the house. I'm still trying to figure out what works in this offense that will allow us to beat good teams.
 
Simple, stick to what works which is running between the tackles he gets too dam cute seems like he just cant stick to what is working. Also stop the horizontal stuff it doesnt work. Hunt is not accurate enough with the ball to play that game and for Gosh sake please never ever again throw a bubble screen to Custis. Run the ball to set up the pass we really could have rushed for 500 today if he had just pounded them but he gets too play station. If Lester calls this game we win going away
 
Jake said:
Scoreboards> stat sheets. Agreed?
buy your tickets agreed?!

This board is ridiculous! I mean it. Any fan with seats in between the 20's... I will pay you face value right now. You're in or you're out. If you can't see the progress, you just don't understand football. I am willing to put my $ where my mouth is. Bring it.
 
Excuses. The playcalling didn't play to Hunt's strengths and put this team in a position to fail. 3rd and 25 and SU calls a draw play to just punt in the 4th quarter. COME ON MAN! That's idiot coaching. TRY and win the game. Throw it downfield and hope for a pass interference or for our guy to make a play
we don't have any plays for 3rd and 25 ,samething in nfl but in nfl with the new rules they get bailed out by striped shirts
 
Orangepace said:
buy your tickets agreed?! This board is ridiculous! I mean it. Any fan with seats in between the 20's... I will pay you face value right now. You're in or you're out. If you can't see the progress, you just don't understand football. I am willing to put my $ where my mouth is. Bring it.
You don't already have tickets super fan?
 
Millhouse said:
You don't already have tickets super fan?
Section 320B. Show up. Why waste your money?! If you hate the sales product, sell to me!
 
You all are ed! Did McDonald misread the pick-6?! Did McDonald's defense allow the 87 yard WR screen?!?! Did McDonald not out gain Maryland?
Yes all of that is true the players made mistakes as almost all players do. What we can not afford is an OC who's play calling kills drives as McDonald did on the second drive of the first half, and several other drives during the game. As a coach he should being help enable the offense not continually calling stupid drive killing plays.
We were running the ball down their throats throughout the game yet he kept calling stupid low gain high risk bubble screens at the worst times, that killed several promising drives.
I can live with some player errors, but I can not accept the coaching ineptitude!
 
The 2nd and 25 call was absurd but McDonald can't make WRs catch passes or Hunt be somewhat accurate and stop throwing over and behind everyone. His offense put up about 600 yards today with all that bs. He can't stop players for committing stupid penalties in big spots -Hunt-Parris. He can't stop players from having no clue what's going on and throwing a pick six or make Norton hit on a 25 yard FG. I blame coaching for today but there is one guy responsible for discipline and focus and that's Shafer.
 
Orangepace said:
buy your tickets agreed?! This board is ridiculous! I mean it. Any fan with seats in between the 20's... I will pay you face value right now. You're in or you're out. If you can't see the progress, you just don't understand football. I am willing to put my $ where my mouth is. Bring it.
I see progress in talent, just don't see it in play calling. Strangely, I don't feel I'm on an island.
 
Last edited:
Jake said:
I see progress in talent, just don't see it in play calling. Strangely, I don't feel I'm on an island. And you want to measure level of fandom, really? Lol. Not to be a dick (which means I'm gonna be one) but I've probably spent more seconds on this board than you've spent drawing oxygen.
hope you have! I'm willing to spend more $$! To put my mouth where my heart is! I should feel bad about that I guess, but I played football in college, D3, but I beat 90% of you all... Can me if you need, but I offered because I can. Sit scared of you must. But I did something never offered on this board and only rumored possible by cto. You are at fault by not realizing that I'm not afraid to stand up for what I know. I'm 32. You're with me or against me. Put up or shut up.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
170,329
Messages
4,885,269
Members
5,992
Latest member
meierscreek

Online statistics

Members online
217
Guests online
1,279
Total visitors
1,496


...
Top Bottom