New York Football Giants 2017 Title Quest Thread

[Alsacs]

I was actually rooting for the Giants today, was starting to get scared they had a chance to get one of the qbs.

Darnold, Rosen, Allen, Jackson, Mayfield, Rudolph, Finley there are a lot of first round QBs this year.

 

[orange79]

I was actually rooting for the Giants today, was starting to get scared they had a chance to get one of the qbs.

Perhaps you should begin to worry about your own team. And how not to lose by 4 TD's on Monday night at home. And how to justify Garrett remaining coach. Because you know that's going to happen.

Plenty of QB's available even if we win another game or two.

 

[KaiserUEO]

Always root for the Giants to win, for all anyone knows, Webb may be better than both Darnold and Rosen, both of whom completely underwhelmed me Saturday night.

Question for those of you watching at home yesterday...when Future HOFer Eli completed that 33yd pass on 4th & 5, to add to his already impressive 4th Qtr and OT game winning drive total...was that a TD?? It looked to me like after the PI and with Lewis now on the ground, he caught it and was not touched.

My section stayed till the end and we were all high fiving and celebrating the catch, so it seemed quick to me, but did they review it? Was it not reviewed as he was called down? I can’t recall...

Thanks

 

[OrangeXtreme]

Always root for the Giants to win, for all anyone knows, Webb may be better than both Darnold and Rosen, both of whom completely underwhelmed me Saturday night.

Question for those of you watching at home yesterday...when Future HOFer Eli completed that 33yd pass on 4th & 5, to add to his already impressive 4th Qtr and OT game winning drive total...was that a TD?? It looked to me like after the PI and with Lewis now on the ground, he caught it and was not touched.

My section stayed till the end and we were all high fiving and celebrating the catch, so it seemed quick to me, but did they review it? Was it not reviewed as he was called down? I can’t recall...

Thanks

Replay showed he was touched on the ground.

 

[KaiserUEO]

Replay showed he was touched on the ground.

I have to see it, I thought he caught it after the barely there hand touch.

Got busy with the kids then fell asleep before I could get to any highlights.

Just trying to give Eli a TD...

Not that he cares, it’s what we all love about him.

 

[orange79]

Replay showed he was touched on the ground.

I have to see it, I thought he caught it after the barely there hand touch.

Got busy with the kids then fell asleep before I could get to any highlights.

Just trying to give Eli a TD...

Not that he cares, it’s what we all love about him.

Can't recall - did they call it a TD? Because if he touched him it was a fingernail, which to me was not enough to overturn the call (if it was called a TD).

 

[KaiserUEO]

Can't recall - did they call it a TD? Because if he touched him it was a fingernail, which to me was not enough to overturn the call (if it was called a TD).

I think it was called down on contact, but that’s what I’m asking. It happened all too quick for me.

It was like a 55 degree day but when the blew it felt like 30. Then at that point in day it was 45 feeling like 20. Coupled with the shock of the big play, a dozen+ bud lights, the celebration in the stands and next thing I knew I Eli was taking the snap and. Falling in the middle of the field for the kick.

People on radio have said TD, but it’s not really being discussed because they won.

I’m just curious.

I’ll keep this here, not to ruin the Bills fans day more, but so far both the Boomer show and Evan and Joe, have gone out of tbeir way to slam McDermott. Crazy decision there...

 

[KaiserUEO]

Just saw it, touchdown.

 

[OrangeDW]

Just saw it, touchdown.

I thought so too. I didn’t see any contact after the catch.

And it was such a great catch that I really wanted it to be ruled a TD,
and wanted Eli to get the game winning TD pass.

In a 2-8 year, I care more about things like that. It’s all I got.

 

[KaiserUEO]

I feel like this was written specifically for me...

https://nypost.com/2017/11/19/this-game-was-for-giants-die-hards-who-really-arent-crazy/

 

[Briancuse]

Perhaps you should begin to worry about your own team. And how not to lose by 4 TD's on Monday night at home. And how to justify Garrett remaining coach. Because you know that's going to happen.

Plenty of QB's available even if we win another game or two.

I have no justification, I wanted him fired a couple years ago.

 

[KaiserUEO]

I have no justification, I wanted him fired a couple years ago.

Garrett, deserves to be in your Ring of Honor for convincing everyone that dak is a NFL QB.

Be careful what u wish for...

 

[bpo57]

Did the G-Men play a game last night? Just checkin'.

 

[KaiserUEO]

Did the G-Men play a game last night? Just checkin'.

A few did, the rest are on IR or were inactive.

 

[Alsacs]

A few did, the rest are on IR or were inactive.

Last night cemented Eli is done and the Giants should Draft a QB high in this draft.
The Washington defense sucks.
The Giants D outscored the O.

 

[KaiserUEO]

Last night cemented Eli is done and the Giants should Draft a QB high in this draft.
The Washington defense sucks.
The Giants D outscored the O.

How is he done??

He's missing 3 OL starters and the top reserve...and his top 4 WRs...and the rest dropped what 8 passes?? 3 by #1 draft pick Evan Engram.

He leads the league in drops this year, if those were caught, 70% completion rate.

Certainly not done.

Maybe with the Giants if their stupid, but not in NFL.

 

[Alsacs]

How is he done??

He's missing 3 OL starters and the top reserve...and his top 4 WRs...and the rest dropped what 8 passes?? 3 by #1 draft pick Evan Engram.

He leads the league in drops this year, if those were caught, 70% completion rate.

Certainly not done.

Maybe with the Giants if their stupid, but not in NFL.

3 points against a bad Redskins D.
QBs make weapons better than they are.
Eli has had a great run but if the surrounding crew needs to be better that is no different than if the QB is Ryan Fitzpatrick.

 

[Bayside44]

3 points.
QBs make weapons better than they are.
Eli has had a great run but if the surrounding crew needs to be better that is no different than if the QB is Ryan Fitzpatrick.

The fixation with Eli here is odd by non Giants fans. No one is winning with practice squad talent and subpar coaching like Dino ain't winning with Shafer's haul of guys.

 

[Briancuse]

Garrett, deserves to be in your Ring of Honor for convincing everyone that dak is a NFL QB.

Be careful what u wish for...

I liked Dak coming out of college, does that mean I deserve to be in the ring of honor?

 

[KaiserUEO]

3 points against a bad Redskins D.
QBs make weapons better than they are.
Eli has had a great run but if the surrounding crew needs to be better that is no different than if the QB is Ryan Fitzpatrick.

Which is PRECISELY what he’s done his entire career.

Your anti Eli hate is off the charts.

Understandable, after what he did your cheating team, but please...

Kevin Boss, Travis Beckham, Mario Manningham, Victor Cruz, Ruben Randle anyone??!

These guys, were not on rosters last month.

And that goes for both the OL and his targets.

 

[Alsacs]

The fixation with Eli here is odd by non Giants fans. No one is winning with practice squad talent and subpar coaching like Dino ain't winning with Shafer's haul of guys.

The fixation from me is because Eli talked about as a HOFer.
I get the injures are something but Eli should elevate his weapons.

Also the OL has improved. Flowers has been pretty good after struggling the first 3 weeks.

 

[Alsacs]

Which is PRECISELY what he’s done his entire career.

Your anti Eli hate is off the charts.

Understandable, after what he did your cheating team, but please...

Kevin Boss, Travis Beckham, Mario Manningham, Victor Cruz, Ruben Randle anyone??!

These guys, were not on rosters last month.

And that goes for both the OL and his targets.

If he did it for those guys then he should be able to score more than 3 points with what he has now.

 

[Bayside44]

The fixation from me is because Eli talked about as a HOFer.
I get the injures are something but Eli should elevate his weapons.

Also the OL has improved. Flowers has been pretty good after struggling the first 3 weeks.

He doesn't have weapons he has liabilities at least on this team - including the front office. And you wouldn't want Flowers blocking for Brady.

Guys like David Tyree and Mario Manningham will make money forever because of Eli Manning.

To me he's a HOF because of the two runs, flat out winning all those games. Stat compilers and fantasy discount that too much.

 

[KaiserUEO]

If he did it for those guys then he should be able to score more than 3 points with what he has now.

He basically has:

Roger Lewis has now made plays and 2 guys off the STREET have too.

But they can’t do it all game every game. There has to be some NFLers on offense, right now there is Eli, Flowers, maybe Jones and Engram...who’s dropping everyfluckingthing.

 

[KaiserUEO]

Now Grant and Deyeon are done for the year and Jacob rabbit willl miss games