nfl greatest 12 RB show

[Alsacs]

Brees is a lock

I mean I put him but I don't think he is a lock.
He faces the recency bias this team has had.
Gronk barely made the TE team as the 5th and last one.

Only 1 active player thus far in Adam Vinatieri.
Brady will be a second.
Brees could be the third.

Brees is on the bubble IMO. I put him on but a John Madden led group could go Favre.

 

[Cusefan0307]

I mean I put him but I don't think he is a lock.
He faces the recency bias this team has had.
Gronk barely made the TE team as the 5th and last one.

Only 1 active player thus far in Adam Vinatieri.
Brady will be a second.
Brees could be the third.

Brees is on the bubble IMO. I put him on but a John Madden led group could go Favre.

Good point about Madden. He loved favre. I just think he was the least consistent of that group. Had a few years he threw more INT's than TD's. The rest of the modern guys were more consistent.

 

[KaiserUEO]

Sid Luckman
Sammy Baugh
Otto Graham
Johnny Unitas
Bart Starr
Roger Staubach
Joe Montana
John Elway
Tom Brady
Peyton Manning

id like to take those S's out...Sid, Sammy & Starr.

just not sure the NFL will.

 

[upperdeck]

Starr is probably the one that really was more of a system guy than a great QB

 

[NateW]

Warfield? ehh...

FWIW, my father has always raved about Warfield. All his stories about the Bills playing Miami when he was young are littered with appreciation for Warfield’s talents.

 

[KaiserUEO]

Starr is probably the one that really was more of a system guy than a great QB

agree.

but he was a 'Packer' and 5x Champion and on the 60s All Decade Team.

 

[Cusefan0307]

They did a 75th anniversary team. They should have just kept the guys on that team and added new ones. Starr was not on that team btw.

 

[KaiserUEO]

They did a 75th anniversary team. They should have just kept the guys on that team and added new ones. Starr was not on that team btw.

im trying to convince myself to take him off, i just cant find the right candidate.

Marino, Favre & Brees at top.

 

[Capt. Tuttle]

I’d argue that Faulk was better than Dickerson because he was a better all-around player. And while I appreciate wanting to recognize older players, I think they overdid it here. Cases could be made for Tomlinson and Peterson as well.

If they had thrown the ball to backs in Dickerson's day, he would have caught lots of balls. A 3 down back, as I recall. He was bigger, stronger and faster than almost anyone who ever played that spot. I am a Dallas fan, so Dorsett and Emmit for me, but I would say Brown, OJ, Dickerson, Payton, and Sanders would be my must guys. After that things like longevity (Sayers and Campbell) come into play.

 

[Capt. Tuttle]

Staubach should make it over Favre.

What's the criteria. Marino might be the best passer to ever play. Elway might be the most talented. Bradshaw has all those rings.

 

[Cusefan0307]

What's the criteria. Marino might be the best passer to ever play. Elway might be the most talented. Bradshaw has all those rings.

I don't know. BB and Madden's subjectivity?

I would like to know if anyone from the 75 year team has been left of the 100 year team though. If they were that seems dumb.

 

[KaiserUEO]

I don't know. BB and Madden's subjectivity?

I would like to know if anyone from the 75 year team has been left of the 100 year team though. If they were that seems dumb.

not really.

they are adding more players so 1 would think thats the case, but its possible the level of play has been eclipsed.

it would be interesting and quite debatable.

 

[Alsacs]

I don't know. BB and Madden's subjectivity?

I would like to know if anyone from the 75 year team has been left of the 100 year team though. If they were that seems dumb.

26 voters. Led by John Madden and Peter King voted for this.
They met in NYC in June and had one other conference call.
They all submitted ballots after discussions of each finalist position group.
Belichick is just part of the TV discussions he didn’t have a ballot.

 

[Cusefan0307]

not really.

they are adding more players so 1 would think thats the case, but its possible the level of play has been eclipsed.

it would be interesting and quite debatable.

I didn’t explain myself well. I think it’s stupid that Earl Campbell didn’t make the 75th anniversary team, but he made the 100 year team. Did Bronco Nagurski make the team because I haven’t seen him yet and he was on the 75th anniversary team?

 

[Alsacs]

What would be your starting first team all time team 1-22.
QB-
RB-
WR-
WR-
TE-
FB/RB/WR/TE wildcard
LT
LG
C
RG
RT

RDE
DT
DT
LDE
OLB
MLB
OLB
CB
CB
SS
FS

Specialists
K
P
PR
KR

 

[Alsacs]

Mine
QB- Tom Brady
RB- Barry Sanders
WR- Jerry Rice
WR- Randy Moss
TE- Rob Gronkowski
Wildcard: Walter Payton
LT- Anthony Munoz
LG- John Hannah
C- Jim Otto
RG- Larry Allen
RT- Forest Gregg

DE-Reggie White
DT- Joe Green
DT- Warren Sapp
DE- Bruce Smith
OLB- Lawrence Taylor
MLB- Dick Butkus
OLB- Derrick Thomas
CB- Deion Sanders
SS- Ronnie Lott
FS- Ed Reed
CB- Rod Woodson

K- Adam Vinateri
P- Ray Guy
PR- Deion Sanders
KR- Devin Hester
Coach- Bill Belichick

 

[OrangeDW]

What would be your starting all time team 1-22.
QB-
RB-
WR-
WR-
TE-
FB/RB/WR/TE wildcard
LT
LG
C
RG
RT

RDE
DT
DT
LDE
OLB
MLB
OLB
CB
CB
SS
FS

Specialists
K
P
PR
KR

Manning
Morris
Carthon
Burress
Nicks
Bavaro
Elliott
Roberts
Oates
Snee
McKenzie

Strahan
Canty
Burt
Tuck
Taylor
Carson
Banks
Collins
Webster
Guyton
Jackson

Bahr
Landeta
Meggett
Parcells

 

[Day2]

26 voters. Led by John Madden and Peter King voted for this.
They met in NYC in June and had one other conference call.
They all submitted ballots after discussions of each finalist position group.
Belichick is just part of the TV discussions he didn’t have a ballot.

Uh, not sure where you're getting your information from, but it's wrong.

Belichick: NFL 100 process made me better coach

Patriots coach Bill Belichick, who is part of the blue-ribbon panel to select the NFL 100 All-Time Team, said the process has made him a better coach.

www.espn.com

NFL News | Latest NFL Football News | NFL.com

 

[Alsacs]

Uh, not sure where you're getting your information from, but it's wrong.

Belichick: NFL 100 process made me better coach

Patriots coach Bill Belichick, who is part of the blue-ribbon panel to select the NFL 100 All-Time Team, said the process has made him a better coach.

www.espn.com

NFL News | Latest NFL Football News | NFL.com

Straight from Peter King’s Mouth

 

[Alsacs]

 

[Alsacs]

Google Peter King all time 100 team watch the video on Facebook. For some reason it won’t link.

 

[Day2]

Two things:

1. For those trying to watch the video, just click "Watch on Facebook" in the "Unavailable" box above.
2. King doesn't say anything remotely like what you're suggesting. He confirms there were 26 people on the panel, that Belichick was on the panel and volunteered along with Madden to do the research on the old-time players (creating a subcommittee as King called it), and presented his findings to the rest of the panel. I'm honestly baffled by your conclusions.

 

[upperdeck]

if people dont vote for Mackey at TE they just dont follow SU or fball. You watch his highlight video and he makes gronk look like a child.

 

[Day2]

if people dont vote for Mackey at TE they just dont follow SU or fball. You watch his highlight video and he makes gronk look like a child.

They both made it. SU has had great representation so far.

 

[bpo57]

Mine
QB- Tom Brady
RB- Barry Sanders
WR- Jerry Rice
WR- Randy Moss
TE- Rob Gronkowski
Wildcard: Walter Payton
LT- Anthony Munoz
LG- John Hannah
C- Jim Otto
RG- Larry Allen
RT- Forest Gregg

DE-Reggie White
DT- Joe Green
DT- Warren Sapp
DE- Bruce Smith
OLB- Lawrence Taylor
MLB- Dick Butkus
OLB- Derrick Thomas
CB- Deion Sanders
SS- Ronnie Lott
FS- Ed Reed
CB- Rod Woodson

K- Adam Vinateri
P- Ray Guy
PR- Deion Sanders
KR- Devin Hester
Coach- Bill Belichick

no Jim Brown?

You left off the videographer. You know BB's gonna need one of those.