Overall, they average the same amount of D1 players per year, as NY. However, Hawaii has a population of only 1.3 million. NY has a population of 19.7 million. So while they don't put out a ton of talent, they may be, per capita, the most talented state when it comes to producing D1 talent. It would also indicate that with such a concentration of D1 athletes in such a small area, that the level of competition is pretty impressive. Similarly, the Island of Samoa which has a population of 190,000, has 30 players in the NFL, and 200 playing division 1 football. A Samoan male, is 50 times more likely to be drafted into the NFL, than an non Samoan American. So imagine a city, not much bigger than Syracuse having 30 players in the NFL, and 200 playing D1 football. That would be some pretty insanely fertile recruiting territory.
Where do college football players come from? - Football Study Hall
How Can Tiny Samoa Dominate The NFL?