Turns out I have a lot more time on my hands now, and got into a wormhole in this thread. I wanted to respond in-depth to what I think is your, and some others, irrational opinions as to the cause and effect of the program's general "mediocrity" after recent events. Also, I don't mean any of this personally Alsacs, but I see so many "facts" that aren't facts, and self-contradictions that I could just not stand idly by.
I find it very funny you are pointing to other fans "straw man arguments" when you are quite literally making multiple straw man arguments in this very thread. Tried to capture the specific argument below:
Person 1 (paraphrasing others' points but providing facts still in the sub-bullets) :
- "Brycen Goodine and Howard Washington did not earn more minutes, and Jg3 + Buddy gave us the best chance to win most every night. Buddy and Jg3 deserved the bulk of minutes that they received."
- Brycen Goodine averaged 1.9 ppg, 30% fg overall, and was 3/24 from three point land.
- Howard Washington in his career averages 1.0 ppg, 27% fg overall, and was 4/26 from three.
Because of these numbers, and probably because JB is a hall of fame coach and sees these dudes every day in practice, decided that they should not cut into the minutes of Jg3 and Buddy. I shouldn't even have to present the numbers from Jg3 and Buddy to prove they were the better players who deserved the bulk of minutes, other than it being quite obvious their numbers were significantly better in extended minutes. Don't know for sure but I would bet there
aren't 10 teams in College Basketball who are returning a backcourt that averaged 27.7 ppg this year. And they're both underclassmen! It's a core I'm personally excited about and think most cuse fans are.
Person 2 (your argument, and I won't even paraphrase) :
- "Buddy Boeheim played more MPG last year than Melo did in 2003. That is funny."
- Simply not a fact (Now that's funny!) - Buddy averaged 35.6 mpg and Melo averaged 36.4 mpg but nice try
- "It only makes sense if you have a player like Hakim Warrick or Zion Williamson. Guys who are significantly more talented. Not average players."
- Straw man - No one said Jg3 or Buddy was on the level of those guys. That's not the argument. The argument is that Goodine and Washington weren't good enough to take minutes from them. Obviously you are implying Jg3 and Buddy are average players. If that's the case how on earth would you describe Goodine and Washington?
- "Goodine didn’t get a chance to prove that in a game. It’s a just a fact."
- Straw man (ish) and just not fact either - 8.7 mpg is not nothing and proves he did get game chances.
- "Having only 2 “capable” guards to play when neither is a superstar is crazy for a program we think we are."
- Major Straw man - I think you must have meant this looking forward to next season based on the context of your post. If my assumption is correct, this is just an asinine take. First, there's a massive gap of skill characterizations between "capable" and "superstar". While Jg3 and Buddy certainly aren't superstars, they've proven to be much more than "capable". Second off, we have a pretty damn good freshman coming here in Kadary Richmond so that's 3 guards. Third, it's downright disingenuous to suggest that JB doesn't see the risk of having 3 guards on the roster. I'm sure he and his assistants will do whatever they can to subsidize the risk of that very situation whether it be another high school recruit, grad transfer, or Juco transfer. The season just ended and the transfer portal is still shaking out, give it some time.
- "You are obviously okay with mediocrity."
- The biggest Straw man of all - Implying the program and our team is mediocre, and implying people are fine with mediocrity. Yet you're the one advocating to give more minutes to some of our worse players?
I present statistics and calling out your "facts" because I know you will not accept the subjective opinion (although it is really objective) that Buddy and JG3 are just much better players than Brycen + Washington and deserved the bulk of minutes. Because I've been reading this board for quite some time and see you post quite often, I assume you'll turn to the ol' "You think this program is headed in the right direction? You are okay with the results of the past 5 years?" I don't post a ton, and would like to start posting more, so to answer that question bluntly: I think 3 tourney appearances including a final four and a sweet 16, and some fun and amazing games in between is something to be happy about. Would I like more regular season success and to be a more feared entity in the ACC? Of course, but I think 95% of programs across the country would sign up right now for the results we've had in the last 5 years. And yes, I am optimistic about the future, including next year and beyond. To be honest, my biggest concern for this program is the day JB decides to hang it up, but that tangent is for another time.
What's funny about all this is I do personally believe Goodine could have gotten a few more consistent minutes because of his defense and still think he has a pretty high ceiling. He was much better in limited time defensively than Jg3 and Buddy, due to his athleticism, but didn't make enough of an impact to warrant the offensive liability that he seemingly was. Putting his stats to the side, if you can't tell he has issues handling the ball and making plays, I don't know what to tell you. His shots also tended to not even really be close. So he's not really a point guard because of a weak handle and also not really a shooting guard because he didn't attack or shoot well. It's really not hard to see that Joe and Buddy on the floor gave us the best chance to win, but even so, I do think Goodine earning closer to 11-12 minutes could have made a difference on the defensive end and his overall confidence. From a minutes perspective, I actually advocated for Jesse Edwards earning more time. His smoothness as a big and length are really intriguing to me and don't think his lack of strength and inexperience would have really made us any worse off when Sidibe was struggling the first 3/5ths of the season.
And not everything is perfect. I do think we've had some recruiting misses dating back to Kaleb Joseph that is concerning including Jalen Carey, Goodine, and Matt Moyer. All were considered 4 stars, did we do a bad job developing or were they just not that good to begin with? For Moyer and Joseph, the answer is seemingly the latter. For Carey and Goodine, the jury is still out. I do think Goodine has the best chance of all our recent transfers minus BJ to end up being a transfer that we regret. But I certainly am comfortable riding with Jg3, Buddy, Kadary, and hopefully another guard moving forward.
And I totally have concerns for next year. Much more real and tangible concerns that have nothing to do with Goodine or Washington.
- Replacing Elijah's production in the transfer portal- How do you replace the leading scorer in the ACC? Even Seth Towns and Landers Nolley, while excellent players, aren't on Elijah's level otherwise they'd be going to the NBA too.
- Shot-making from the wing - Sort of has to do with the above but more-so looking at our current roster than considering a transfer replacement.
- Marek can score more consistently. I think as a senior, he will, but what's his ceiling? Is 15 ppg too much of a stretch? Probably, but I bet JB gives him the chance to be that kinda player. There's been countless press conferences where JB's stated that he tells Marek he needs to look to score more. Even if he can't score from the outside, I think he can go drive and score from the paint much more consistently/frequently.
- Quincy to me is our X-factor next year. Assuming he gets closer to 30+ minutes per game, what's his output? JB swears that he can shoot it, but I'm skeptical. Still optimistic he can average 13-15 ppg in extended minutes plus his usual aggressive rebounding and toughness, which will be invaluable to next year's team. But Quincy taking a step up and being a go-to guy is I think a huge key for next year.
- Braswell I'm just not as high on him as others seem to be. I think he's okay, can shoot it fairly well, and good things do seem to happen when he's on the court, but I just find him not to be an ACC level player. He's too stiff, awkward, and doesn't have enough skill as a playmaker, and I think that limits the impact he can have for us. Hope he proves me wrong though, I definitely am rooting for him.
- Woody we will see. I will say that after watching his most recent highlights, I was struck by how much he seemed to have filled out over the past year. Has the makings of a good one, I'm just not sure how ready he is for ACC competition in year 1. Early season games and scrimmages will be big for him.
- Guard defense - Of course! I actually think JG3's defense isn't as bad as most make it out to be, but I won't make excuses for their aggregate defensive performances this year. Joe's biggest problem to me is he fell asleep too often at the top of the zone. He needs to be more focused. I also think a part of that is just experience in the zone and getting more comfortable with it, knowing where to be. He certainly got better towards the end of the year as his instincts improved. But let's also not bypass him leading the team in steals per game and 10th in the ACC. Buddy I'm afraid is what he is defensively, his athletic limitations hold him back from stopping ACC guards getting past him (i.e. cole anthony who did whatever he wanted against buddy in the dome). I think he was better at closing out than Joe, and think he's serviceable in that spot, but there are undeniable limitations to his game.
- Center Play - Probably the concern I'm worried least about even though I don't see a grad transfer coming here with 3 centers already on the roster (not including marek who can play center). I was just really encouraged to see Bourama turning a corner towards the end of the year, and am optimistic he can be more of that player consistently next season. As noted above, I'm also quite high on Jesse Edwards so I hope he takes a step up defensively as well. Won't act like I have any sort of feel for JBA's game, total mystery to me.
Okay that's enough. I apologize for anyone who read this whole thing. Slow day at the work from home office, and I wanted to reflect on the past season as well as my thoughts for next year. I promise my future posts won't be this long. Cuse by a million.