Dude, we just lost 2 guys. We have 3 open scholarships. It's not a choice. We could use BOTH. Badly. This would actually be a really complimentary fit. Golden is the 4/5 combo inside guy with some beef. Braswell is more like a spindly SF with rangy arms, like a Reggie Miller (G'Town, not Indiana) who seems kind of bouncy, but not that polished or smooth offensively.
That would give us cover in the front court, if we got both. Hell, we would STILL have room for another 7 foot project at center.
Personally, I don't think we need Quade Green as a transfer. I just don't see it. We've got a lot of guards already, and we're going to tie up ANOTHER scholarship on a transfer while we're trying to get back? I just don't see it.
IM, we have plenty of scholarship space right now, as you indicated.
2018-19 (12 available):
7 likely returning players (Frank, HW, Hughes, Oshae, Marek, Sidibe, PC)
1 scholarship recruit (Carey)
Buddy B (not on scholarship, if space needed)
That's 8 accounted for with either 3 or 4 available.
If Tyus returns, great. If Golden pledges, great. That's still 1 or 2 open slots.
You wouldn't take a 5-star PG???? Give me Quade over a project forward, for sure. Adding experienced high end talent would be hard to turn down. College hoops is all about scoring and guard play, you make it work here.
Hit the 2019 class hard when you'll have another ship back with a ton of spacing opening up (Frank, likely Oshae, PC).
Braswell should be a backup option to Golden, IMO, if that falls through. If Tyus does leave, the push for Braswell could also intensify as the space will most certainly be there.