I don't really get this.
Ayala can come in, get 25+mpg on a team that should at the very least contend for an NCAA tournament bid while playing in the ACC. He'll be surrounded by talent. By coming in 2017, he'll be on target age-wise with his class and will be 18 for half of the season (would turn 19 in January). And in his sophomore year he will very likely see over 30mpg.
By staying in 2018, he'll be old for his class, delaying potential future earnings by 1 year (assuming he has NBA dreams) and will end up being 20 before his freshman year was over. The chances he gets offered by Duke, Kansas or Kentucky seems very unlikely.
Not sure the advantage his people see by keeping him in 2018.
I'm with most of you, if he wants to stay in 2018 I say we move on.
If his intention is 2017, great, but I hope we hear something soon and don't lose out on Thorpe by waiting.