I'm excited about the possibility of adding this guy but I'm a bit confused about the assumptions that he walks right in (he may still need to sit a year) and immediately becomes the man (I'm not convinced he's better than Girard/Buddy/Marek/Guerrier).
People seem to think we will need an Eli clone next year. I disagree. Eli had to be the primary ball handler (at least in late game and tough situations) and the primary scorer. A huge workload that I don't think we will need any one player to duplicate because guys are going to get better and expand their games from year to year.
Girard had a great handle, we needed Eli to be the primary ball handler because Girard made a lot of bad decisions, which is understandable when you consider he jumped from playing low level high school basketball right to ACC starter. I believe Girard will improve a lot in the decision making department with a year of experience under his belt, and we will be fine without a de facto second point guard playing forward.
As for Eli's shooting. You can never have too much certainly, but I don't believe we will be short on shooting with Girard, Boeheim, Guerrier, and Dolezaj. Guerrier was coming of a year not playing organized basketball and his shot wasn't falling, but he has the potential to extend his range and I believe he will. Generally freshman who put up the kind of numbers he did have good sophomore seasons. Dolezaj has shown capable of playing farther out from the basket than he did this past year. We didn't need him behind the three point line last year, we needed him around the basket, but he can increase his range too.
The way I see it, we've got five potential double digit scorers in Girard, Boeheim, Guerrier, Dolezaj and Sidibe. If Griffin were to play next year (god knows what will happen with those rules) we'd have a sixth. He could play some guard and some forward and add another shooter and another athlete. There would be room for all six guys to play starter type minutes. It would work out well, and I think they'd be a better team than last year's team, but it will look different. There won't be one guy that everything goes through, there will be six (maybe even seven if Richmond is able to contribute right away, I'm still not sure what to make of him) guys who are all pretty much equally capable of hurting you based on the match ups.