Maybe there should be less emphasis on the tournament. That's like having a class where the grade is based on only one exam. That's not really a fair or accurate measure of how smart/good you are. I would take a bunch of 27-32 win years and conference championships and deep tourney runs (not championships) over bad seasons and a random tourney win.
I just don't think you can sufficiently describe a program by a couple of weeks in March that may or may not be rigged (it's rigged - we all know we got screwed against Ohio State and Michigan).
This is an update of a post I made in February of last year:
We’re trying to win the ACC regular season championship. Then we’ll try to win the ACC Tournament. We’re also trying to win the national championship but that can only be won by winning the NCAA tournament. It made me wonder what things might have been like over the years if we had a regular season national championship and a post season national championship as we do with the conferences. Football used to base its national championship on the last regular season poll, (that ended in 1968: the first poll was in 1936). What if we looked at the team voted #1 in the last regular season writer’s or coach’s polls as the regular season national champion? You could argue that attaining and maintain a #1 ranking to the end of a 31 game regular season is as much of an accomplishment as winning a single elimination tournament over 6 games. You might argue that the latter is harder but it also has more freakish results. If you are voted #1 at the end of the regular season, that’s not a freak thing. Maybe we should recognize both.
In basketball, the writer’s poll began in the 1948-49 season, (I’ll call that 1949 for short), the coach’s in 1950-51, (which I’ll call 1951). Where there is a conference tournament, I’ll use the last poll before the conference tournament. Here are your “regular season national champions” (source: The ESPN College Basketball Encyclopedia, the ESPN website and SportsReference.com: College Basketball):
1949 Kentucky
1950 Bradley
1951 Kentucky and Oklahoma A&M (now Oklahoma State)
1952 Kentucky
1953 Indiana
1954 Kentucky and Indiana
1955 San Francisco
1956 San Francisco
1957 North Carolina
1958 West Virginia
1959 Kansas State
1960 Cincinnati and California
1961 Ohio State
1962 Ohio State
1963 Cincinnati
1964 UCLA
1965 Michigan
1966 Kentucky
1967 UCLA
1968 Houston
1969 UCLA
1970 Kentucky
1971 UCLA
1972 UCLA
1973 UCLA
1974 NC State
1975 Indiana
1976 Indiana
1977 Michigan
1978 Kentucky
1979 Indiana State
1980 DePaul
1981 DePaul
1982 North Carolina
1983 Houston
1984 North Carolina
1985 Georgetown
1986 Duke
1987 UNLV
1988 Temple
1989 Arizona
1990 Oklahoma
1991 UNLV
1992 Duke
1993 North Carolina
1994 Arkansas
1995 UCLA
1996 Kentucky
1997 Kansas
1998 Duke
1999 Duke
2000 Cincinnati
2001 Stanford
2002 Kansas
2003 Arizona
2004 St. Joseph’s
2005 Illinois
2006 Connecticut
2007 Ohio State
2008 North Carolina
2009 Louisville
2010 Kansas
2011 Ohio State
2012 Kentucky
2013 Gonzaga
2014 Florida
2015 Kentucky
The NCAA tournament champions would also be national champions, just as the ACC tournament champions will also be ACC champions. Syracuse (
in 2014) would thus (
was) going for four championships this season: the ACC regular season and national regular season, (both of which could be won when we play our last regular season game vs. Florida State), the ACC tournament championship, which we would compete for the next week and NCAA title, which we could compete for over the final three weeks. They would all count and they would all matter. If we finish say, 36-1, (losing our first game in the Sweet 16), we would already have won a national championship. Someone else would then win the post season championship.
A composite list of national championships won, (“R” is a regular season title, “P” is the post season title):
Arizona R1989, P1997, R2003 (3)
Arkansas R1994, P1994 (2)
Bradley R1950 (1)
California P1959, R1960 (2)
CCNY P1950 (1)
Cincinnati R1960, P1961, P1962, R1963, R2000 (5)
Connecticut P1999, P2004, R2006, P2011 (4)
DePaul R1980, R1981 (1)
Duke R1986, P1991, R1992, P1992, R1998, R1999, P2001, P2010 (8)
Florida P2006, P2007 R2014 (3)
Georgetown P1984, R1985 (2)
Gonzaga R2013 (1)
Holy Cross P1947 (1)
Houston R1968, R1983 (2)
Illinois R2005 (1)
Indiana P1940, P1953, R1953, R1954, R1975, R1976, P1976, P1981, P1987 (9)
Indiana State R1979 (1)
Kansas P1952, P1988, R1997, R2002, P2008, R2010 (6)
Kansas State R1959 (1)
Kentucky P1948, R1949, P1949, R1951, P1951, R1952, R1954, P1958, R1966, R1970, R1978, P1978, R1996, P1996, P1998, R2012, P2012, R2015 (18)
LaSalle P1954 (1)
Louisville P1980, P1986, R2009, P2013 (4)
Loyola (Chicago) P1963 (1)
Marquette P1977 (1)
Maryland P2002 (1)
Michigan R1965, R1977, P1989 (3)
Michigan State P1979, P2000 (2)
North Carolina R1957, P1957, R1982, P1982, R1984, R1993, P1993, P2005, R2008, P2009 (10)
North Carolina State R 1974, P1974, P1983 (3)
Ohio State P1960, R1961, R1962, R2007, R2011 (5)
Oklahoma R1990 (1)
Oklahoma State (A&M) P1945, P1946, R1951 (3)
Oregon P1939 (1)
San Francisco R1955, P1955, R1956, P1956 (4)
St. Joseph’s R2004 (1)
Stanford P1942, R2001 (2)
Syracuse P2003 (1)
Temple R1988 (1)
Texas-El-Paso, (Texas Western) P1966 (1)
UCLA R1964, P1964, P1965, R1967, P1967, P1968, R1969, P1969, P1970, R1971, P1971, R1972, P1972, R1973, P1973, P1975, R1995, P1995 (18)
UNLV R1987, P1990, R1991 (3)
Utah P1944 (1)
Villanova P1985 (1)
West Virginia R1958 (1)
Wisconsin P1941 (1)
Wyoming P1943 (1)