I disagree ... at least to the extent that you're talking about football- they are terrible because of their location. Who wants to watch Rutgers athletics when you can watch NYC pro teams?They cant get out of their own way. There is no reason why Rutgers shouldnt be solid in football and basketball based on their location. I always thought that if they went big on a coach they would do well. Im glad they hired Ash as i was concerned they would hire Joe M from P State who in my opinion would have been a home run for them.
Cow colleges are good at football because there is *nothing* else to do, so the students, alumni, and locals care about football. Most of the Rutgers grads that I know don't know what conference Rutgers is in.