SWC75
Bored Historian
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 33,729
- Like
- 64,936
We are off to our worst start in decades and the schedule seems unforgiving and people are searching for reasons for our plight. Fran Fraschilla and Seth Greenberg have said that this is the least talented Syracuse team in decades and many commentators and fans have jumped on that bandwagon. Even Jim Boeheim has agreed to some extent: in his show last night he said: “We aren’t as talented as we have been in many years.” (I believe me meant in many of the years in which he’s coached, not that it’s been many years since we had this relatively low level of talent.) “But we’ve had teams this talented that at least made it to the NIT.”
I realize that I’m swimming against the current here but I don’t really agree. Firstly let’s define the term: “Talent” is not a measurable. If the other team has a 6-11 250 center and we have a 6-9 206 center, that’s a disadvantage but it’s not a gap in talent. Talent is your natural ability to play the game. “Skill” is a developed talent that enables you to help your team win games. Quincy Guerrier has talent but he’s an unskilled player as yet. If you have talent you have the potential, with hard work and experience, to improve and you may be able to use your talent to out-play a bigger or even a faster player. But early in your career, that will be difficult. Players with great talent may be able to be stars from the moment they show up. But a team of players who have had to develop their talents and learn to play together can still win games at this level. Duke, with Williamson and Barrett last year lost to Syracuse and didn’t make the Final Four while Texas Tech played for the national championship.
CENTERS- Bourama Sidibie is clearly a more talented player that Paschal Chukwu ever was. When he first showed up, he was widely expected to win the positon from Paschal Chukwu. His knee problems prevented him from doing that. Paschal couldn’t even catch the ball. He could use his 7-2 size to block a lot of shots and could rebound when he put his mind to it but in every game this year we’ve seen Bourama do things that Paschal could never do. JB says he’s been held back by a cold these last three games. His lack of physical stature was probably a bigger issue but I thInk Bourama will have a clearly more productive season than Paschal had last year.
Jesse Edwards is bigger than Bourama, (in terms of height and reach), and may be even more talented. Jim says that he’s not ready yet but I think we’ll see more and more of him as the season progresses and I think we’ll be impressed. He’s already shown some deft moves around the basket and is clearly a better shot blocker than Bourama. He needs to continue to learn and fill out physically but I think he’ll have quite a career here.
Marek Dolezaj is clearly a talented player. The only problem is that he’s not really a center and should be a full-time forward. I still think that part of the reason Jim plays him at center is to get him on the court and allow him to play Quincy with Elijah more. He also needs to aggressively use his talents more but he’s certainly trying to do that.
I’ll take this year’s Bourama + Jesse + Marek over Paschal + last year’s Bourama + Marek.
FORWARDS – Marek has multiple skills he can use better at forward. Elijah Hughes is an NBA player and will be there next year for sure. He’s showing that he’s not just a shooter. He’s handling and passing the ball very well and his exciting dunks and blocks bring the crowd to its feet. He’s also got the best shooting range we’ve ever had here. He could probably get a little better at driving to the basket
Quincy is the one player we’ve got who can bang inside. He’s very athletic and JB says he can hit from outside, too, although we have yet to see that. But he was a perimeter player in AAU ball and didn’t play last year. I made a reference to Joe Frazier in the pool at the Superstars. That was a joke but Q does look like a great athlete learning to swim. He’s strong, athletic and talented and capable of being productive even now but he’s not a skilled player yet. When he is, watch out!
If you could combine Quincy’s body with Robert Braswell’s skills, you’d have quite a player. Braswell is stuck behind Hughes, Guerrier and Dolezaj and the fact that Jim is determined to keep his rotation at 8-9 players at the most. But no one would accuse him of not having talent. He’s a fine shooter and does everything very smoothly. I could see him emerging as a star player later in his career. He just needs a chance.
GUARDS- Buddy Boeheim proved last year he can play. He was pressing and missing early in the year, just like he is now. But when he relaxed and started making shots, he went on to a fine season. He doesn’t take it to the hole but I’ve seen him use the dribble to set up an open shot. He may not make a track team but he knows how to positon himself and play the passing lanes on defense.
No one can question that Joe Girard can shoot. He was not a point guard in high school but he’s doing a pretty good job at it at this level. He has a good assist-turnover ratio and a good handle. His big problem is getting his shot off against a big, aggressive guard. But he doesn’t let the rest of his game suffer when he isn’t scoring. In time, he’ll get better at out-maneuvering bigger defenders.
I’ve always been a Howard Washington fan his high school tapes showed an unspectacular but solid true point guard. (I’ll take solid over spectacular if that’s the choice). I was most impressed with his interviews which always used the term “we” rather than “I” and broke down his team’s games like a coach. All he needed was a blackboard. He’s clearly a steadying influence, a “coach on the floor” type and I hope he gets Goodine’s minutes going forward.
Brycen Goodine has been a huge disappointment. He has no handle and no shot and looks like the guy who gets sand kicked in his face in those old Charles Atlas ads. (At least Joe has a football player’s body).
He’s really shown me nothing so far. He has to have been better than this to have the reputation he had as a recruit. I guess I’ll have to have belief without evidence for now. Jalen Carey has been another huge disappointment. His career here may be over. But these guys were higher rated than just about all of their teammates. Nobody accused us of settling for mediocrity when they were recruited.
I believe there are players on this team who will someday play on a strong team, maybe a great one. The issue is what happens this year. They are young and thin and learning how to play the game and play with each other. The 20 game ACC schedule put together with the NIT, the ACC Big Ten Challenge and the desire to play old rivals has produced an unforgiving schedule and our streak of winning season and NCAA or even NIT hopes are looking dim. We can improve and maybe be pretty good by the end of the season but it may come too late to remember this year with any affection. But I don’t see talent as the issue.
I realize that I’m swimming against the current here but I don’t really agree. Firstly let’s define the term: “Talent” is not a measurable. If the other team has a 6-11 250 center and we have a 6-9 206 center, that’s a disadvantage but it’s not a gap in talent. Talent is your natural ability to play the game. “Skill” is a developed talent that enables you to help your team win games. Quincy Guerrier has talent but he’s an unskilled player as yet. If you have talent you have the potential, with hard work and experience, to improve and you may be able to use your talent to out-play a bigger or even a faster player. But early in your career, that will be difficult. Players with great talent may be able to be stars from the moment they show up. But a team of players who have had to develop their talents and learn to play together can still win games at this level. Duke, with Williamson and Barrett last year lost to Syracuse and didn’t make the Final Four while Texas Tech played for the national championship.
CENTERS- Bourama Sidibie is clearly a more talented player that Paschal Chukwu ever was. When he first showed up, he was widely expected to win the positon from Paschal Chukwu. His knee problems prevented him from doing that. Paschal couldn’t even catch the ball. He could use his 7-2 size to block a lot of shots and could rebound when he put his mind to it but in every game this year we’ve seen Bourama do things that Paschal could never do. JB says he’s been held back by a cold these last three games. His lack of physical stature was probably a bigger issue but I thInk Bourama will have a clearly more productive season than Paschal had last year.
Jesse Edwards is bigger than Bourama, (in terms of height and reach), and may be even more talented. Jim says that he’s not ready yet but I think we’ll see more and more of him as the season progresses and I think we’ll be impressed. He’s already shown some deft moves around the basket and is clearly a better shot blocker than Bourama. He needs to continue to learn and fill out physically but I think he’ll have quite a career here.
Marek Dolezaj is clearly a talented player. The only problem is that he’s not really a center and should be a full-time forward. I still think that part of the reason Jim plays him at center is to get him on the court and allow him to play Quincy with Elijah more. He also needs to aggressively use his talents more but he’s certainly trying to do that.
I’ll take this year’s Bourama + Jesse + Marek over Paschal + last year’s Bourama + Marek.
FORWARDS – Marek has multiple skills he can use better at forward. Elijah Hughes is an NBA player and will be there next year for sure. He’s showing that he’s not just a shooter. He’s handling and passing the ball very well and his exciting dunks and blocks bring the crowd to its feet. He’s also got the best shooting range we’ve ever had here. He could probably get a little better at driving to the basket
Quincy is the one player we’ve got who can bang inside. He’s very athletic and JB says he can hit from outside, too, although we have yet to see that. But he was a perimeter player in AAU ball and didn’t play last year. I made a reference to Joe Frazier in the pool at the Superstars. That was a joke but Q does look like a great athlete learning to swim. He’s strong, athletic and talented and capable of being productive even now but he’s not a skilled player yet. When he is, watch out!
If you could combine Quincy’s body with Robert Braswell’s skills, you’d have quite a player. Braswell is stuck behind Hughes, Guerrier and Dolezaj and the fact that Jim is determined to keep his rotation at 8-9 players at the most. But no one would accuse him of not having talent. He’s a fine shooter and does everything very smoothly. I could see him emerging as a star player later in his career. He just needs a chance.
GUARDS- Buddy Boeheim proved last year he can play. He was pressing and missing early in the year, just like he is now. But when he relaxed and started making shots, he went on to a fine season. He doesn’t take it to the hole but I’ve seen him use the dribble to set up an open shot. He may not make a track team but he knows how to positon himself and play the passing lanes on defense.
No one can question that Joe Girard can shoot. He was not a point guard in high school but he’s doing a pretty good job at it at this level. He has a good assist-turnover ratio and a good handle. His big problem is getting his shot off against a big, aggressive guard. But he doesn’t let the rest of his game suffer when he isn’t scoring. In time, he’ll get better at out-maneuvering bigger defenders.
I’ve always been a Howard Washington fan his high school tapes showed an unspectacular but solid true point guard. (I’ll take solid over spectacular if that’s the choice). I was most impressed with his interviews which always used the term “we” rather than “I” and broke down his team’s games like a coach. All he needed was a blackboard. He’s clearly a steadying influence, a “coach on the floor” type and I hope he gets Goodine’s minutes going forward.
Brycen Goodine has been a huge disappointment. He has no handle and no shot and looks like the guy who gets sand kicked in his face in those old Charles Atlas ads. (At least Joe has a football player’s body).
He’s really shown me nothing so far. He has to have been better than this to have the reputation he had as a recruit. I guess I’ll have to have belief without evidence for now. Jalen Carey has been another huge disappointment. His career here may be over. But these guys were higher rated than just about all of their teammates. Nobody accused us of settling for mediocrity when they were recruited.
I believe there are players on this team who will someday play on a strong team, maybe a great one. The issue is what happens this year. They are young and thin and learning how to play the game and play with each other. The 20 game ACC schedule put together with the NIT, the ACC Big Ten Challenge and the desire to play old rivals has produced an unforgiving schedule and our streak of winning season and NCAA or even NIT hopes are looking dim. We can improve and maybe be pretty good by the end of the season but it may come too late to remember this year with any affection. But I don’t see talent as the issue.
Last edited: