SWC75
Bored Historian
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 33,970
- Like
- 65,517
People questioned Norm Rothschild setting up a date with tough middleweight Peter Mueller on the eve of a possible championship fight. Rothschild noted that fights against the likes of Al Andrews and Allie Gronik were tough sells and that the people who complained about Carmen risking his reputation against good fighters were the same ones who never showed up for the Andrews and Gronik fights. “Carmen’s a fighter for one reason- money. The only way he can get it is by fighting people who could fill the auditorium. This fight, like the Italo Scortchini and Pierre Langlois fights, is against a middle weight. A loss won’t hurt his welterweight standing…Personally, I think he can beat Mueller. He’s the best welterweight in the world and fighting fellows like Scortchini and Langlois taught him how to combat various styles.”
Mueller had signed a contract to come in weighing no more than 155 pounds but he was two pounds over that limit at the weigh-in. Basilio and his camp decided to go through with the fight anyway but the NYS Athletic Commission suspended Muller for 30 days, not a very meaningful act as Mueller’s next scheduled fight wasn’t until March anyway. Muller had had four fights since coming over from Germany and won three of them, over Tiger Jones, Joe Miceli and Ernie Durando, all as an underdog. His only loss was to an unbeaten young fighter from Utah named Gene Fullmer. Muller predicted he’d add Carmen Basilio to his list of upsets over American fighters. The Tiger Jones upset became more impressive two days before the Basilio-Muller bout because Jones himself upset the great Sugar Ray Robinson, who was making a comeback after his 1952 retirement.
But Robinson may have been a bit rusty and, as Jack Slattery pointed out, Durando had Mueller down and nearly out until the referee let him off the hook. He even said that “Mueller will get his first taste of fistic action against a well-conditioned American opponent”. He noted that one of Carmen’s sparring partners had quit after being knocked out. “This when Carmen was wearing king size training gloves.” Slattery predicted a knockout and a fight against Saxton for the title in the spring but noted that the backers of a Boston fighter named Tony DeMarco had made an offer to Saxton that exceeded the one Norm Rothschild had offered for a bout with Basilio.
Mueller, known as the “Cologne Clown”, blew kisses to the audience and sang “Mambo Italiano” to anyone who wanted to listen during the introductions. But when the fight began, he had no time for any clowning.
Mueller got off to a good start, using wrestling and brawling tactics to try to use his extra heft to push Carmen around. He stopped Carmen in his tracks with “a tremendous left hook to the body” in the first round and seemed to have him in trouble in the second. Carmen went into more of a crouch and Mueller seemed to have trouble landing his punches after that. A left hook at the bell in the third presaged the 5th round knockdown that really turned the fight around. Bill Reddy heard a spectator comment to a friend: “See, I told you this Basilio was overrated”.
Then Carmen lowered the boom in the fifth, nailing Mueller with a right cross and left hook that sent him through the ropes. Mueller never went down but the ref gave him a standing 8 count so it counted as a knockdown. Carmen dominated the remaining rounds, cutting Mueller’s left eye in the 7th and repeatedly rocking him with solid shots. Carmen seemed to get stronger as the fight wore on and “kept hammering with both fists”. The caption to one of several pictures in the paper showing Basilio clobbering Mueller with a punch said, simply “That Hurts”. The German almost stumbled on the way back to his corner after the 8th round, but he never did go down. Basilio said afterwards that the ropes probably saved Mueller from a knockout in the 5th and again in the 10th when he nailed him with still another left hook.
The referee had it 7-2-1 for Basilio. The Judges were 8-1-1 and 6-4. The War Memorial record crowd, (confirming Norm Rothschild’s comments about how he and Carmen could make money off of “name” fighters), cheered the decision “loud and lustily”.
The paper reported that “both fighters got fat checks. Carmen received slightly more than $13,000.00 and Mueller was paid approximately $12,000”. It was speculated that Jim Norris of the IBC would be in Syracuse the following week to finalize the plans for a Basilio-Saxton fight in Syracuse. But he never showed up, citing other business commitments. His plans “did not include a visit to Syracuse at this time”. Rothschild began to campaign for a middleweight title shot vs. Bobo Olson. Slattery felt Olson was too big for Carmen but felt that no middleweight had better credentials. One boxing writer listed the top fighters, pound for pound in the world at that point and Carmen came in 4th, Olson 3rd. And Carmen had now beaten three ranking middleweights in Scortichini, Langlois and Mueller. Al Andrews, after getting beat up by Basilio, Beat #1 ranked middleweight contender Joey Giardello.
U-Tube has this fight, beginning with an interesting but irrelevant interview of Don Ameche by Rocky Marciano that took place after Gary Player won the Masters, which would have been in 1961. Rocky narrates a film of the fight from 6 years prior and makes a good crack about Muller’s phone bill:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMkCNAUEvcM
The other two parts to this can be seen to the right.
Mueller had signed a contract to come in weighing no more than 155 pounds but he was two pounds over that limit at the weigh-in. Basilio and his camp decided to go through with the fight anyway but the NYS Athletic Commission suspended Muller for 30 days, not a very meaningful act as Mueller’s next scheduled fight wasn’t until March anyway. Muller had had four fights since coming over from Germany and won three of them, over Tiger Jones, Joe Miceli and Ernie Durando, all as an underdog. His only loss was to an unbeaten young fighter from Utah named Gene Fullmer. Muller predicted he’d add Carmen Basilio to his list of upsets over American fighters. The Tiger Jones upset became more impressive two days before the Basilio-Muller bout because Jones himself upset the great Sugar Ray Robinson, who was making a comeback after his 1952 retirement.
But Robinson may have been a bit rusty and, as Jack Slattery pointed out, Durando had Mueller down and nearly out until the referee let him off the hook. He even said that “Mueller will get his first taste of fistic action against a well-conditioned American opponent”. He noted that one of Carmen’s sparring partners had quit after being knocked out. “This when Carmen was wearing king size training gloves.” Slattery predicted a knockout and a fight against Saxton for the title in the spring but noted that the backers of a Boston fighter named Tony DeMarco had made an offer to Saxton that exceeded the one Norm Rothschild had offered for a bout with Basilio.
Mueller, known as the “Cologne Clown”, blew kisses to the audience and sang “Mambo Italiano” to anyone who wanted to listen during the introductions. But when the fight began, he had no time for any clowning.
Mueller got off to a good start, using wrestling and brawling tactics to try to use his extra heft to push Carmen around. He stopped Carmen in his tracks with “a tremendous left hook to the body” in the first round and seemed to have him in trouble in the second. Carmen went into more of a crouch and Mueller seemed to have trouble landing his punches after that. A left hook at the bell in the third presaged the 5th round knockdown that really turned the fight around. Bill Reddy heard a spectator comment to a friend: “See, I told you this Basilio was overrated”.
Then Carmen lowered the boom in the fifth, nailing Mueller with a right cross and left hook that sent him through the ropes. Mueller never went down but the ref gave him a standing 8 count so it counted as a knockdown. Carmen dominated the remaining rounds, cutting Mueller’s left eye in the 7th and repeatedly rocking him with solid shots. Carmen seemed to get stronger as the fight wore on and “kept hammering with both fists”. The caption to one of several pictures in the paper showing Basilio clobbering Mueller with a punch said, simply “That Hurts”. The German almost stumbled on the way back to his corner after the 8th round, but he never did go down. Basilio said afterwards that the ropes probably saved Mueller from a knockout in the 5th and again in the 10th when he nailed him with still another left hook.
The referee had it 7-2-1 for Basilio. The Judges were 8-1-1 and 6-4. The War Memorial record crowd, (confirming Norm Rothschild’s comments about how he and Carmen could make money off of “name” fighters), cheered the decision “loud and lustily”.
The paper reported that “both fighters got fat checks. Carmen received slightly more than $13,000.00 and Mueller was paid approximately $12,000”. It was speculated that Jim Norris of the IBC would be in Syracuse the following week to finalize the plans for a Basilio-Saxton fight in Syracuse. But he never showed up, citing other business commitments. His plans “did not include a visit to Syracuse at this time”. Rothschild began to campaign for a middleweight title shot vs. Bobo Olson. Slattery felt Olson was too big for Carmen but felt that no middleweight had better credentials. One boxing writer listed the top fighters, pound for pound in the world at that point and Carmen came in 4th, Olson 3rd. And Carmen had now beaten three ranking middleweights in Scortichini, Langlois and Mueller. Al Andrews, after getting beat up by Basilio, Beat #1 ranked middleweight contender Joey Giardello.
U-Tube has this fight, beginning with an interesting but irrelevant interview of Don Ameche by Rocky Marciano that took place after Gary Player won the Masters, which would have been in 1961. Rocky narrates a film of the fight from 6 years prior and makes a good crack about Muller’s phone bill:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMkCNAUEvcM
The other two parts to this can be seen to the right.