If you watched the Yankees every day, his decisions tonight would not be surprising. It blew up in his face tonight, but the guy has worked miracles this season just to have this team contending for a wild card spot. I'm not going to kill him.
That's why I said he deserved manager of the year consideration. Not often you can have a team 10 games over .500 with a negative run differential.
I've watched Girardi for a long time and he does make strange pitching moves. But Farrell is no better.