A lot of hand wringing on here no matter how hard or easy the schedule is. So, what would everyone’s ideal schedule be? Not necessarily the order, but the teams.
I would start by advocating for a 15 game schedule. You are allowed 17 "competition dates" I beleive. I would play two scrimmages, one in the fall and one in the spring. I see no need for two in the spring, but it sounds like they are scrimmaging Yale and Loyola this year. The regular season would look like the following.
ACC Games (4)
Duke
Notre Dame
UNC
UVA
New York Based Rivalries (4)
Army
Albany
Cornell
Hobart
Out of State Rivalry (1)
Johns Hopkins
That leaves 6 other games to scheduled. I agree with IT that while I wouldn't add teams like Maryland necessarily to this schedule (that is more or less nine very tough games), but wouldn't want teams like Siena either. With 15 games however I think they would need to schedule some mid-week games, which might necessitate a Binghamton. I would add the following teams -
Hofstra - Give the Long Island players a chance to play in front of their friends and families. Duke plays a neutral site game almost every year on Long Island, they attract a lot of players from that area. I think this is connected. You could also add Stony Brook, I am sure that would make the Spallina family happy.
Princeton or another Ivy League team - It doesn't seem right that Cornell is the only Ivy League team the Orange play. They have tremendous history with the Tigers, and we'd get to see highlights of Mike Powell and Damien Davis.
Harvard - Maybe too many Ivy League teams, but Syracuse seems to be getting a lot of kids from the New England area, and in similar thinking to Hofstra, it would be good to exposure in that neck of the woods. Selfishly I am New England based and it would be great to see them in person closer to home. Could also swap them out for Boston U or UMass.
Denver - Probably no different than scheduling Maryland but this gives the schedule some geographic diversity. I know the landscape of college lacrosse doesn't allow for much different, but it seems like the SU schedule the last few years has been very east coast dominant. Would be nice for the team to see other parts of the country, and have other parts of the country see them in person.
Michigan - Like the Princeton reasoning it seems strange that SU doesn't play another Big 10 team besides Hopkins. I know this changes with Maryland, but, let's take it down a little bit. Penn State or Ohio State would also be fun.
Siena - for midweek scheduling purposes I would keep a team like Siena or Binghamton on the schedule.
Anyways, I know it's hard to come up with a schedule that makes everyone happy, but I tried to balance things out. I'd be surprised if they ever went to a 15 game schedule, but Duke plays a ton of games and it works out for them. It would also be nice to see SU play in different parts of the country - neutral site games would also fix this. How about a game in Toronto? Its great they get to play so many games in the Dome, and with the early start to the season a lot teams like playing in the climate control, but things need to get shaken up sometimes.