I don’t really agree with that.
Did Fran recruit the kid saying come here and you won’t play in year 1? I find that hard to believe especially with no QB1 at the time. If Fran did, then he made a dumb mistake. What is the point it isn’t like Carney was a big time recruit.
Also if Fran honored the agreement, why is Carney leaving?
If he wasn’t a fit how in the heck to you miss that badly? And why play him at all then? None of this makes sense.
So Fran will get a reputation for giving kids playing time? What kid doesn’t want that? Or Fran will get the rep that he wants to win games?
There is no point in redshirting kids anymore in the portal era. You only help their future team which we should not care about. Most kids don’t even want to redshirt so I don’t see much negative.