I was debating Hill with my friend yesterday.
I think maybe Hill gets the benefit of the doubt because its a basketball HOF vs NBA HOF; the guy was so damn great at his peak, and he stayed in college for 4 years at a time when guys were coming out after 2. Say he comes out after 2 instead, and now his NBA career likely has 2 more high level seasons; his case is a lot better, right?
Also, I know Hill hung around a lot as a role player, but he did play for a long time. He went to school for 4 years, missed time for injury, but the guy did play 1,026 games. Here are some HOF around him in NBA games played
Walt Bellamy- 1043
Oscar Robertson- 1040
Chet Walker-1018
Gail Goodrich-1031
Joe Dumars-1018
Calvin Murphy 100
David Robinson-987
Chris Mullin-986
Isaiah Thomas-979
Mitch Richmond-976
Kevin McHale-971
Like, it's really not that bad, is it?
Ray Allen should totally be in, what am I missing there?