E.D. Cleared to Practice Doubtful to play | Page 5 | Syracusefan.com

E.D. Cleared to Practice Doubtful to play

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jim Reith with the overly conservative take, no?

Jim Reith‏@therealJimReith
If Dungey plays again this year it will be a miracle, and foolish. Obviously a severe concussion, the worst hit I've ever seen.
 
Yep. That's huge for the health of the whole team. We need to get as many people back to 100% as possible for USF and UVA. Have to win those two games.
Understand that logic, however this program is in desperate need of a high profile win.....LSU woould do it.....UVA<USF goes unnoticed, I wouldn't want him in unless he is ready but if he was cleared to play he should be the starting QB
 
I'm not trying to be "hyper-sensitive" about it. But don't spread doubt, and then act like it didn't happen. Both you and OrangeInBoston were overly skeptical. Especially when given zero evidence to refute what Jek was saying, or to corroborate the OPs bs.

sorry, i was thinking about cusians post that jek quoted. I went back and looked.

Orange in boston was responding to you because you came out of left field saying end of story, period. op is wrong.
 
I was overly skeptical?! I didnt judge 1 way or the other.

And orange in boston was not overly skeptical either. his post that jek quoted came BEFORE jek posted his information. You do realize that right?


Your words - "So 3rd hand?" "Thats grapevineish"
OrangInBoston - "And you know this how?"
Alsacs and others - "Let's just trust OP, because reasons"
 
Just counted 4 posters on page 2 alone...
Give it a rest. We want inside info here and when someone gives us something, they get pounded. The OP was the first to report about Hunt's injury. That gets him some street cred. I am sure he didn't make it up. I am also sure Jek has been told that it wasn't true. maybe the OP's source heard something after Jek's source did. who knows? Either way, let's let this play out. We will all know soon enough
 
Jim Reith with the overly conservative take, no?

Jim Reith‏@therealJimReith
If Dungey plays again this year it will be a miracle, and foolish. Obviously a severe concussion, the worst hit I've ever seen.
Bit of a tool... Nothing obvious about it; in fact I thought the hit was much more neck hyper extension than head concussion.
 
sorry, i was thinking about cusians post that jek quoted. I went back and looked.

Orange in boston was responding to you because you came out of left field saying end of story, period. op is wrong.

Yeah it was to me. But I was verifying Jeks claim in the post.
 
Your words - "So 3rd hand?" "Thats grapevineish"
OrangInBoston - "And you know this how?"
Alsacs and others - "Let's just trust OP, because reasons"
Are you really pressing on with this? How about this, maybe Jek's source told him that ED was cleared but we don't want LSU to know. That would be in the same ballpark with RW is gone but keep saying he is still with us. I'm not saying that is the case of course but the OP has been correct in the past and must have heard from someone what he posted. After watching the hit, I would be more than surprised if ED was cleared at least this soon. But I am not going to attack a poster for writing something that he heard. I have had that done to me (and I was proven correct) and I don't want it done to anyone else.
 
Give it a rest. We want inside info here and when someone gives us something, they get pounded. The OP was the first to report about Hunt's injury. That gets him some street cred. I am sure he didn't make it up. I am also sure Jek has been told that it wasn't true. maybe the OP's source heard something after Jek's source did. who knows? Either way, let's let this play out. We will all know soon enough

I'm not trying to pound anyone here. I just don't think the OP used good form. He drops a title like that, that clearly gets a ton of attention and likes without any support. I think its trollish to do that. Especially given how big of a deal that info is to all of us. The title is a lie. Plain and simple.
 
Your words - "So 3rd hand?" "Thats grapevineish"
OrangInBoston - "And you know this how?"
Alsacs and others - "Let's just trust OP, because reasons"

like i said ornage in boston was just responding to you, not to jekelish. and your post was a little over the top.

My post said nothing about his info. Jek is 1 of the 10 or so posters that I find myself following the most. I didnt doubt his information. It was funny to hear the grapevine like way he gets his info. Thats all. Sorry if the typed words didnt match my intended tone - but it had nothing to do with the info. I am leaning towards he is out for sat and its going to take an official announcement for me to be swayed that he is playing.

alsacs posted that at the exact same time jekelish posted so alsacs was not responding to jekelish, there is no way he even saw jekelish's post.

also to note: the 1st time jek posted on the subject - he wasnt posting real info. just that he would be surprised he was cleared based on what he heard (while also mentioning ED starting on the depth chart). it wasnt until later that jek posted anything that anyone could take seriously as real updated info.
 
Are you really pressing on with this? How about this, maybe Jek's source told him that ED was cleared but we don't want LSU to know. That would be in the same ballpark with RW is gone but keep saying he is still with us. I'm not saying that is the case of course but the OP has been correct in the past and must have heard from someone what he posted. After watching the hit, I would be more than surprised if ED was cleared at least this soon.

I know his source bro! I know exactly who told Jek and what he was told.

Wow, jekelish, I guess you'll never live down the RW thing, lol.
 
I'm not trying to pound anyone here. I just don't think the OP used good form. He drops a title like that, that clearly gets a ton of attention and likes without any support. I think its trollish to do that. Especially given how big of a deal that info is to all of us. The title is a lie. Plain and simple.
While in my head I doubt that OP and the title was correct, to call it a lie, plain and simple is out of bounds. You don't know that. And to call someone's info a lie and not simplyu incorrect is terrible.
 
While in my head I doubt that OP and the title was correct, to call it a lie, plain and simple is out of bounds. You don't know that. And to call someone's info a lie and not simplyu incorrect is terrible.
Yeah, I don't think it was a lie. I think it was someone who got information that, as it turns out, probably wasn't correct. I believe it was shared in good faith that the source was accurate.
 
While in my head I doubt that OP and the title was correct, to call it a lie, plain and simple is out of bounds. You don't know that. And to call someone's info a lie and not simplyu incorrect is terrible.

Ok, thats fair. He may have been told by someone who lied to him. It was incorrect and got a lot of people excited about nothing.
 
kid get knocked out for a second, struggles in pain, tries to get up...COLLAPSES back down, does anyone really think he didn't sustain a concussion?

he absolutely collapsed back down after trying to get up. someone said the trainers pushed him back down. Bullshite he collapsed. Definitely looked to be out cold for a couple of seconds to.

no way he plays this weekend. i think we'll be lucky to see him vs USF.
 
Couple of interesting Depth Chart observations:

Dungey and Ishmael on, Trudo on - don't know what to make of any of those yet.

Erv looks like he's going to be out, as expected.

Fredericks is now an "Or" with Morris, seems Morris's days are numbered on the two deep. Same goes for Wilson, now an "Or" with Mahoney.
 
I know his source bro! I know exactly who told Jek and what he was told.

Wow, jekelish, I guess you'll never live down the RW thing, lol.
He will live it down. But there is a difference between writing something that is incorrect and writing something you know to be false. Jek said he told people that he knew RW's commit was shaky but publicly he said everything was a-okay. That is very bad for your credibility. I like Jek and I like his site. But...you don't intentionally give out bad information. That is what you are accusing the OP of. I don't believe the OP did that. But Jek has admitted doing that in the RW case.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
170,435
Messages
4,891,165
Members
5,998
Latest member
powdersmack

Online statistics

Members online
283
Guests online
1,432
Total visitors
1,715


...
Top Bottom