Eric Dungey to the NY Giants UDFA

Rocco

Living Legend
Joined
Aug 15, 2011
Messages
10,826
Like
22,832
This is a tough roster to crack as a UFA QB. Eli is going nowhere, they aren't going to get rid of a #6 Jones even if he is outperformed, Alex Tanney was signed through next year I believe, and Lauletta is signed through next year as well.
He needs to show that he has enough "swiss army knife" in him to be more valuable than one of the back ups, because they aren't carrying 5 qb's on a roster. Hopefully he shows good enough hands that they'll want to hang on to him as some sort of special package guy that can line up in multiple positions.
Saw a clip of him wearing 12 yesterday throwing back and forth with Jones. Gave me goose bumps as a Giants fan.
He will make it awfully tough to be cut. I guarantee none of those QB's has his drive, and his heart.
This is a great take.

Lauletta and Tanney are toast IMHO. Signed doesn't mean anything anymore, especially on these baseline deals. Not saying Dungey makes it as the 3rd QB, but I agree that it's going to be awfully tough to cut him. He can instantly fill in on STs and will be a dual threat mock-up on the practice squad.
 

SWC75

Bored Historian
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
19,616
Like
30,569
For any of those waxing poetic about Ryan Nassib, it's worth remembering that he couldn't throw the deep ball to save his life.

And he got to hold the sideline clipboard for a while.

Don't count out Dungey at QB.

I remember him as having a strong arm, better than Dungeys. Also quite an improvement on Greg Paulus, who threw interceptions when he didn't throw short.
 

richmondcuse03

Scout Team
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Messages
412
Like
1,058
I remember him as having a strong arm, better than Dungeys. Also quite an improvement on Greg Paulus, who threw interceptions when he didn't throw short.
I thought Ryan's issue was more touch...good early feedback on Eric. Hope he gets a shot somewhere. Even a backup QB career in the NFL gets paid some decent money and doesn't take the hits.
 

Cuse12

Walk On
Joined
Jun 18, 2018
Messages
223
Like
625
Blake Bortles starts at QB on an NFL team. That alone let’s you know Dungey absolutely has a shot. Just matters if the pieces fall into place and he makes the most of his opportunity.
 

Melancer46

All American
Joined
Dec 1, 2011
Messages
5,913
Like
5,291
I hope Dungey carves out a role for himself, but I can't help but feel like this guy:

 

cuse62

2nd String
Joined
Dec 6, 2015
Messages
512
Like
1,032
I wonder if the Giants told him no flipping off water towers when he goes back home?
 

TheCusian

Living Legend
Joined
Sep 24, 2012
Messages
17,362
Like
21,103
I hope Dungey carves out a role for himself, but I can't help but feel like this guy:

So what if a team saw what Taysom Hill did and thought “let’s a take a flyer on this kid?” Why does he think teams aren’t doing those other things?

Twitter, where snark is a sport
 

Melancer46

All American
Joined
Dec 1, 2011
Messages
5,913
Like
5,291
So what if a team saw what Taysom Hill did and thought “let’s a take a flyer on this kid?” Why does he think teams aren’t doing those other things?

Twitter, where snark is a sport
To the latter question, teams aren't really doing those things (with the exception of the 3rd one probably).

Re: Taysom Hill; I'm not really sure he's actually a valuable NFL player, at least not with New Orleans. Any time you're taking Brees off the field is a bad move IMO.

I'm rooting like hell for Dungey, and if him having a job in the NFL requires a team to think having a guy like Hill is valuable, then I'll take it. I just don't really think it's actually an asset to use a guy like that.
 

Alsacs

I am statboy because I use stats to form opinions
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
39,580
Like
44,545
To the latter question, teams aren't really doing those things (with the exception of the 3rd one probably).

Re: Taysom Hill; I'm not really sure he's actually a valuable NFL player, at least not with New Orleans. Any time you're taking Brees off the field is a bad move IMO.

I'm rooting like hell for Dungey, and if him having a job in the NFL requires a team to think having a guy like Hill is valuable, then I'll take it. I just don't really think it's actually an asset to use a guy like that.
Belichick agrees with your logic.

 

Melancer46

All American
Joined
Dec 1, 2011
Messages
5,913
Like
5,291
I’ve never understood why you can’t have two guys on the field who can throw the ball.
Having two guys that can throw is cool if one of them is a factor in other ways. Taysom Hill, for all his hype, didn't really do anything as a pass catcher or a passer for that matter. The snaps in which he did anything were almost exclusively just QB keepers in which they preferred him running the ball rather than giving it to more talented runners or just letting Brees make a play. He wasn't a good passer and was non-existent as a receiving threat so putting him and Brees on the field at the same time was basically just playing 10 on 11.
 

TheCusian

Living Legend
Joined
Sep 24, 2012
Messages
17,362
Like
21,103
To the latter question, teams aren't really doing those things (with the exception of the 3rd one probably).

Re: Taysom Hill; I'm not really sure he's actually a valuable NFL player, at least not with New Orleans. Any time you're taking Brees off the field is a bad move IMO.

I'm rooting like hell for Dungey, and if him having a job in the NFL requires a team to think having a guy like Hill is valuable, then I'll take it. I just don't really think it's actually an asset to use a guy like that.
I think it was just a hot take special from a guy looking for likes and retweets - "Look, I'm smarter than NFL GM's" is a popular genre on ye ole twitter

I agree with you that it's not a huge deal, but honestly at this point of Eli's career it might be a good thing for hime to throw less, lol

I actually think it was smart for Eric to take this deal because it gives the Giants another reason to keep him on the roster. He needs time and a shot to learn and stick for a bit.
 

SWC75

Bored Historian
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
19,616
Like
30,569
I’ve never understood why you can’t have two guys on the field who can throw the ball.

They used to have four of them. Any of them could take the snap, hand off or pass to any of them. The result was pretty creative compared to what you see today.

 
Last edited:

Dinkyspond

(Hal) Cohen - (Marty) Headd backcourt
Joined
Dec 6, 2017
Messages
473
Like
735
I'd like to see Eric on special teams like Jim Jensen on the Dolphins in the late 80s, early 90s. 3rd team QB who covered kicks, punt protector and I think even emergency TE and LB. Heck, I think Eric is fast enough and good enough hands to return kicks too.
 

All4SU

Hall of Fame
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
8,934
Like
8,136
Having two guys that can throw is cool if one of them is a factor in other ways. Taysom Hill, for all his hype, didn't really do anything as a pass catcher or a passer for that matter. The snaps in which he did anything were almost exclusively just QB keepers in which they preferred him running the ball rather than giving it to more talented runners or just letting Brees make a play. He wasn't a good passer and was non-existent as a receiving threat so putting him and Brees on the field at the same time was basically just playing 10 on 11.
I’m not advocating have two guys playing QB. But the ability to play QB while playing another position - even in limited duty - just seems so obvious. Coaches, particularly at the highest levels are SO reluctant to be creative and try new things.
 

Top Bottom