Few Thoughts and theories on recent stuff | Page 3 | Syracusefan.com

Few Thoughts and theories on recent stuff

Sooooo is your argument things will get better with one more year? Cause I can assure you from my viewpoint the trend line is down and it won't get any better with one more year. Promise you that.

Boeheim could get the team back to the Tournament next year. That wouldn't be weird or a Herculean task.

But the count of college basketball coaches in history who have come in on year one taking over an embattled program, and had a great year is what? 2?

You're argument is that you want to get the ball rolling so we can get back to being good in 2025 instead of 2026.
 
Last edited:
LOL I mean, if you want to gloss over what's happened with this program and just look at "hey, what's one more season." By all means, have at it. I think myself (and others) aren't concerned with "1 more season". It's a way bigger issue. But hey, let him have at it. I'm sure next year's recruiting class will turn everything around for Big Jim...
Ha, right now there is no recruiting class. Maybe they add some transfers in the offseason, which would be a good idea provided they have shown they can be productive
 
It's irrelevant. The JB decision has a lot of financial considerations, but a contract buyout provision is not among the top 10 of them.
Ok that’s what you say. What should SU do?
 
Last year was one more year until this year was one more year and now next year is one more year. It will never be just one more year! His last season was suppose to be in 2017!
This was the issue with Bowden at FSU as he kept going 8-3, 7-4 and wanting another year. And the school President TK Weatherall said, nope Gator Bowl is your final game.
 
Boeheim could get the team back to the Tournament next year. That wouldn't be weird or a Herculean task.

But the count of college basketball coaches in history who have come in on year one taking over from an embattled program, and had a great year is what? 2?

You're argument is that you want to get the ball rolling so we can get back to being good in 2025 instead of 2026.
Jim is going to lose his top 2 scorers this year, for sure. He is also going to lose Benny and Bell. Mintz will have a decision to make and Sy is probably gone as he's been around 4 years. He is potentially going to lose his entire starting 5 from the start of the year, his only other PG, he has ZERO commits for next year and barely uses the portal. Yes, it would be Herculean for him to get this turned around lol. Remind me why Jim should stick around another year?
 
One of the posters that liked your post Cusefan0307 , has stated repeatedly that the best teams are not the teams full of 5 star one and dones , they are the teams with mature 3 and 4 star players. What happens if our freshman class matures a little and we add maybe a wing that can score? Your opinion is it will get worse, mine is that I have no idea what will happen and it's possible the team is better next year.

Your argument essentially comes down to - you don't think JB can coach anymore.
Anything is possible! It’s possible our geriatric coach stumbles across the fountain of youth. It’s possible that we play m2m next season. Hell, it’s even possible I win the lottery.

Why anyone thinks kicking this can down the road is a good idea is beyond me at this point.

Change can be hard. Change can be scary. Change can be good. Change can be refreshing. Change will always exist.
 
I think being fearful of the change because maybe it could get worse is insane to me. Let's not take a shot at becoming relevant again because maybe we can become slightly less irrelevant than we currently are.

If we just give JB next year then he can officially make it a full decade without finishing the year in the top 25, garnering a decent NCAA seed, having less than 13 losses*, being excited instead of nervous on selection Sunday. That sounds lovely. Nice big even number.
That's my position, as well.

And think about that not less than 13 losses factor. Whoa.
 
Why would you give JB a buyout
Let’s see. A guy who makes $Xmm a year and drives $10xMM in revenue and has competent counsel isn’t going to protect himself in the event of a termination without cause.
 
Let’s assume JB has a contract through next season with a $10mm buyout after this one. That’s a quite reasonable assumption; it aligns with what has been said about Dino’s contract. What do posters think SU should do?
Pounding the table and saying “he has to retire“ doesn’t qualify as a realistic response. Also he has not said or done anything which would remotely approach grounds for termination for cause.
I can assure you with 1 year on his contract his buyout is not $10 million. Who is buying him out of it? Kentucky? the NBA? He's not in demand anywhere else in his 70s so his buyout would not be that high with the end being near if things became a disaster and the school had to fire him. You dont need to fire him for cause, it can be due to performance and you pay him off.

You can even pay him the remainder on it and call it a retirement and honor him.
 
Let’s see. A guy who makes $Xmm a year and drives $10xMM in revenue and has competent counsel isn’t going to protect himself in the event of a termination without cause.
He can want to protect himself all he wants but Wildhack didn't have to give him one. If he did, JW should be fired immediately.
 
Jim is going to lose his top 2 scorers this year, for sure. He is also going to lose Benny and Bell. Mintz will have a decision to make and Sy is probably gone as he's been around 4 years. He is potentially going to lose his entire starting 5 from the start of the year, his only other PG, he has ZERO commits for next year and barely uses the portal. Yes, it would be Herculean for him to get this turned around lol. Remind me why Jim should stick around another year?

Ok, since we're going with that angle and not the 'rip the bandaid off now so we can be good in a few years angle,' who comes in with no players and wins 25 games? That guy is for sale?
 
Ok, since we're going with that angle and not the 'rip the bandaid off now so we can be good in a few years angle,' who comes in with no players and wins 25 games? That guy is for sale?
You're answering your own question. Nobody is winning 25 games next year. Not Jim, not Red, not GMAC, not an outside hire. So why keep with the status quo and delay the inevitable? Again, I go back to my original point that it NEVER should have gotten to this. Never should have happened.
 
You would negotiate a 5-10 million dollar buyout for a 78 year old, who has been with the same program 47 years, that has struggled for the better part of a decade? Do you think he's a hot commodity within the coaching ranks?
Took the words right out of my mouth. It’s insane seeing some of the excuses continue to be stretched into unrealistic territory. A $10M buyout for a 78 year old coach who hasn’t jumped ship in 47 years. I mean, come on.
 
Took the words right out of my mouth. It’s insane seeing some of the excuses continue to be stretched into unrealistic territory. A $10M buyout for a 78 year old coach who hasn’t jumped ship in 47 years. I mean, come on.
I'd love to see Jim's leverage in that negotiation. When he tells JW that he's going to explore his other opportunities lololololol

Added: I can't stop laughing thinking about Jim telling JW "I'm in high demand! Phone won't stop ringing"
 
I can assure you with 1 year on his contract his buyout is not $10 million. Who is buying him out of it? Kentucky? the NBA? He's not in demand anywhere else in his 70s so his buyout would not be that high with the end being near if things became a disaster and the school had to fire him. You dont need to fire him for cause, it can be due to performance and you pay him off.

You can even pay him the remainder on it and call it a retirement and honor him.
Well at least that’s an answer, pay the money (and accept the blowback from his supporters). I would note that SU has not paid the money to exit Dino, whose near term performance is worse.
 
Ok, since we're going with that angle and not the 'rip the bandaid off now so we can be good in a few years angle,' who comes in with no players and wins 25 games? That guy is for sale?
The expectation wouldnt be to win 25 in year 1. It is to set the foundation for the future.

As to who comes in? A guy looking for a step in pay and prestige, a guy who isnt happy with his current situation. A guy intrigued by taking the program that is #6 in all time wins. Guys change jobs all the time.
Different sport but why did Lincoln Riley leave a great situation at OK for USC or Brian Kelly at ND for LSU? They got sold on an idea.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
170,645
Messages
4,902,823
Members
6,005
Latest member
CuseCanuck

Online statistics

Members online
34
Guests online
1,176
Total visitors
1,210


...
Top Bottom