I would be okay getting Jimmy back for another year IF Cole goes elsewhere, because having both of them is way too much of a liability on defense...especially with Buddy and Joe up top. There’s just not enough athleticism between the four, even just three of them at the same time is a bit of a stretch to be able to bang with more athletic teams.
The only way I would see running it back with the same squad working out, is if we drastically change our rotations and have everyone play 20-25 minutes, 30 tops and frequently make subs to keep guys fresh and balance our shooting with athleticism. We would need Benny taking a jump and starting in place of Cole or Jimmy and then we would need Frank, Symir and at least two of our freshman seriously ready to play at a high level.